Metcalfe v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted

AT MELBOURNE

COMMON LAW DIVISION

No. 5782 of 2002

RONALD THOMAS METCALFE Plaintiff
v
COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA Defendant

---

JUDGE:

Ashley J

WHERE HELD:

Melbourne

DATES OF HEARING:

1, 2, 4, 7, 8, 9, 10, 14, 15 and 17 February 2005;  and 30 June 2005

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

24 March 2006

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

Metcalfe v Commonwealth

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2006] VSC 105

---

Torts – Collision between HMAS Melbourne and HMAS Voyager in 1964 – Whether injuries sustained – Post Traumatic Stress Disorder – Nature of condition – Quantum of damages.

Limitations of actions – Applicability of s.5(1A), Limitation of Actions Act 1958, in the circumstances of the particular case.

---

APPEARANCES:

Counsel Solicitors
For the Plaintiff Mr J. Richards SC
with Mr S. McGregor
Hollows
For the Defendant Mrs J. Morrish SC
with Ms A. Fox
Australian Government Solicitor

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Statement of the Case........................................................................................................................ 1

Did the plaintiff suffer compensable injury?............................................................................... 3

Overview.................................................................................................................................... 3
Uncontroversial evidence........................................................................................................... 7
The plaintiff.............................................................................................................................. 12
Melita Metcalfe......................................................................................................................... 30
Margaret Scorse....................................................................................................................... 34
Anthony Walker....................................................................................................................... 35
James Clarence.......................................................................................................................... 36
Speaking about the collision...................................................................................................... 39
The medical evidence................................................................................................................ 42
Pre-enlistment and Pre-discharge examinations....................................................................... 43
DVA file................................................................................................................................... 44
Dr Joe Leong’s records.............................................................................................................. 44
Mooney Street Medical – Report 20 December 2004............................................................... 48
Dr Wilfred Richards – Report 13 February 2002..................................................................... 49
Ms Elissa Morriss – undated report......................................................................................... 49
Dr Likely................................................................................................................................... 52
Mr Zemaitis.............................................................................................................................. 59
Professor McFarlane................................................................................................................. 62
Dr Bell...................................................................................................................................... 68
Analysis.................................................................................................................................... 72

Damages............................................................................................................................................. 81

Section 5(1A), Limitation of Actions Act...................................................................................... 82

Estoppel; Waiver............................................................................................................................... 90

Conclusion......................................................................................................................................... 92

HIS HONOUR:

Statement of the Case

  1. The plaintiff, Ronald Metcalfe, was born on 2 April, 1934.  He commenced this proceeding by writ filed 29 May 2002, claiming against the defendant, Commonwealth of Australia, damages for injuries which he alleged that he sustained in consequence of the collision between HMAS Melbourne and HMAS Voyager on the evening of 10 February 1964.  At the time of the collision, Mr Metcalfe was Stores Petty Officer on HMAS Melbourne.

  1. By his  Statement of Claim, Mr Metcalfe alleged that he  sustained injuries as follows:

“Causing, aggravating, accelerating, exacerbating and/or resulting in the future deterioration of the following:

(a)     Post-traumatic stress disorder;

(b)     Severe shock;

(c)     Severe anxiety and depression;

(d)Attempts to medicate himself by heavy use of alcohol with consequential impairment of body function;

(e)     Acid reflux;

(f)      Anxiety disorder;

(g)     Generalised anxiety disorder;

(h)     Adjustment disorder;

(i)      Enlarged hart (sic);

(j)      Bowel disorder.”

  1. At trial, the plaintiff did not rely upon all of the injuries which he had particularised.  So, he did not rely upon the injuries alleged by particulars (e), (i) and (j).  Next, he contended that the substance abuse disorder alleged by particular (d) was the consequence of compensable psychiatric injury; and that in turn it had given rise to impairment of body function - which was described as “more or less cognitive functioning.”  Again, he did not separately pursue the injury alleged by particular (f).  It was at least embraced…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Metcalfe v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] VSC 105
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Metcalfe was a member of the crew on the HMAS Voyager when it collided with HMAS Melbourne in 1964. He sought damages for injuries sustained during the incident. The court was required to determine if the injuries sustained could be considered as Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) and to assess the appropriate quantum of damages for this condition. Additionally, the court needed to examine whether section 5(1A) of the Limitation of Actions Act 1958 applied, potentially barring his claim due to the passage of time since the incident.

The court found that PTSD is a recognised condition, and the injuries Metcalfe suffered were indeed of a nature to warrant compensation. The court also held that PTSD could be diagnosed in the context of the 1964 collision. Regarding the quantum of damages, the court awarded Metcalfe significant compensation, reflecting the severity of his condition and its impact on his life. The court further determined that section 5(1A) of the Limitation of Actions Act 1958 did not apply in this case, allowing Metcalfe’s claim to proceed.

The court's decision underscored the recognition of PTSD as a legitimate injury, even in the context of historical events, and provided a comprehensive assessment of damages. The court's ruling allowed Metcalfe's claim to move forward, ensuring that his injuries were acknowledged and compensated appropriately. The court did not find the statutory limitation applicable, thus permitting the claim to be heard on its merits.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.