Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Metals Trading Pty Ltd v Doctor Scrap Pty Ltd [2012] NSWSC 366 Hearing dates: 13 - 17 February 2012 Decision date: 05 April 2012 Jurisdiction: Equity Division Before: Rein J Decision: 1. Judgment for the plaintiff for costs of works and hire and repair of hired equipment.
2. Judgment for the cross claimant for the costs of remediation of soil in the area underneath scrap piles maintained by the cross defendant.
Catchwords: LANDLORD AND TENANT - tenant's liability to remediate land contaminated by asbestos
EVIDENCE - burden of proof, presumptions, and weight and sufficiency of evidence - proof that prior activities might lead to contamination with asbestos insufficient to undo linkage between scrap piles maintained by cross defendant and discovery of asbestos at those locationsLegislation Cited: Conveyancing Act 1919 Cases Cited: Jones v Dunkel [1959] HCA 8; (1959) 101 CLR 298 Category: Principal judgment Parties: Metals Trading Pty Ltd (Plaintiff)
Doctor Scrap Pty Ltd (Defendant)Representation: Counsel:
P Greenwood SC; J Hynes (Plaintiff)
S D Robb QC; J Baxter (Defendant)
Solicitors:
Minter Ellison (Plaintiff)
Anderson Lawyers (Defendant)
File Number(s): SC 2010/106818
Judgment
These proceedings, commenced by Metals Trading Pty Ltd ("Metals"), concern the lease by Metals of a property at Hereford Street, Wagga Wagga ("the Site") from the defendant, Doctor Scrap Pty Ltd ("Doctor Scrap"), and equipment hired by Doctors Scrap for Metals. Mr Greenwood SC appears with Mr Hynes for Metals and Mr Robb QC with Ms Baxter appears for Doctor Scrap.
The two elements of Metals' claim were:
(1) the cost of works on the Site to a value of $216,169.70 for which Metals paid and which Doctor Scrap promised to reimburse it, plus interest;
(2) an amount for hire and repair of an item of equipment hired by Metals to Doctor Scrap, with the amount claimed being $116,507.94 plus interest.
There is now no dispute by Doctor Scrap that it is liable to Metals for these two heads of claim to a total amount of $332,677.64 (plus interest), subject to its cross claim.
In view of the concessions made, the background to the lease becomes of less importance, namely that Metals bought the scrap metal business that Doctor Scrap conducted at several sites. Doctor Scrap, shortly before the sale, was contemplating purchasing the Site and as part of the sale agreement it was agreed that it would purchase the Site and lease it to Metals for initially a two-year period. It was agreed that Doctor Scrap would arrange for the completion of works required to make the Site functional as a yard suitable for Metals' business (principally by installing a shed, a road and a weighbridge) and later that Metals instead would arrange those works and be reimbursed for an amount of up to $350,000 (including the $216,169.70 referred to above). Doctor Scrap purchased the Site for $1.1 million in May 2007.
In late 2009, Doctor Scrap sought to have Metals…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Metals Trading Pty Ltd v Doctor Scrap Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] NSWSC 366
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the court was whether the evidence provided by Metals Trading Pty Ltd was sufficient to establish the tenant's liability for the asbestos contamination. Specifically, the court had to determine whether the proof that prior activities might lead to contamination with asbestos was enough to undermine the direct link between the scrap piles maintained by Doctor Scrap Pty Ltd and the discovery of asbestos at those locations. The court also considered whether any presumptions or burden of proof principles applied to the evidence presented.
In delivering the judgment, the court held that the evidence presented by Metals Trading Pty Ltd did not sufficiently establish that prior activities might have led to contamination with asbestos. The court found that the direct linkage between the scrap piles maintained by Doctor Scrap Pty Ltd and the discovery of asbestos at those locations was strong enough to hold the tenant liable for the remediation of the contaminated land. The court also noted that the presumptions and burden of proof principles did not shift the onus onto Metals Trading Pty Ltd to prove that prior activities might have led to contamination. As a result, the court ruled in favour of Metals Trading Pty Ltd, finding Doctor Scrap Pty Ltd liable for the remediation of the asbestos-contaminated land.
The court ordered Doctor Scrap Pty Ltd to undertake the necessary remediation of the contaminated land in accordance with the relevant environmental regulations and guidelines. The court also noted that any costs associated with the remediation would be borne by Doctor Scrap Pty Ltd. The judgment serves as an important reminder to tenants of the potential liability they may face for environmental contamination arising from their activities on leased premises.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi