Metal Manufactures Limited v Gagovski

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION

DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR

CITATION:Metal Manufactures Limited v Gagovski [2006] NSWWCCPD 267

APPELLANT:  Metal Manufactures Limited

RESPONDENT:  Nikola Gagovski

INSURER:Allianz Australia Workers Compensation (NSW) Limited

FILE NUMBER:  WCC11234-04

DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION:          15 February 2005

DATE OF APPEAL DECISION:  10 October 2006

SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION: Sections 40(2)(b), 40(2A) and 40(2B) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987, and “unreasonably rejected suitable employment”

PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER:  Deputy President Gary Byron

HEARING:Determined on the papers

REPRESENTATION:  Appellant:      Vardanega Roberts Solicitors

Respondent:   Bussoletti Lawyers

ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:  The decision of the Arbitrator, dated 15 February 2005 is confirmed.

The Appellant Employer is to pay the Respondent Worker’s costs of the appeal.

BACKGROUND

  1. Nikola Gagovski has worked for Metal Manufactures Limited since 1976.  He injured his back at work on two occasions, 22 June 1998 and 6 March 2001.  The 1998 injury occurred while he was using a crane to lift a 44-gallon drum.  He returned to work after this injury.  The 2001 injury occurred when he was unloading copper tubes from a tank.  Mr Gagovski had a laminectomy on 11 May 2001.  On 10 September 2001 he returned to work on a structured program of modified duties, at his pre-injury wages. 

  1. Allianz Australia Workers Compensation (NSW) Limited (‘the Insurer’) was Metal Manufactures Limited’s workers compensation insurer at the time of the injuries.  It acted for and on behalf of the employer in the Commission proceedings.

  1. Mr Gagovski made a claim for lump sum compensation for permanent impairment of his back and left leg pursuant to sections 66 and 67 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (‘the 1987 Act’). The Insurer disputed the claim and ultimately, it was settled and registered in the Compensation Court, on 19 April 2002. The terms of settlement were as follows:

·section 66 - $18,000 with respect to permanent impairment of the back and $24,375 with respect to permanent loss of use of the left leg at or above the knee; and

·section 67- $22,000 for pain and suffering.

  1. On 3 March 2003, Mr Gagovski ceased working at level 4 status and commenced working as a cleaner for Metal Manufactures at level 2.

  1. On 22 July 2004 Mr Gagovski’s ‘Application to Resolve a Dispute’ was registered in the Workers Compensation Commission.  Mr Gagovski sought payments of weekly benefits compensation. 

  1. The dispute went to Arbitration on 5 November 2004.  It was agreed between the parties that:

·Mr Gagovski received injuries arising out of or in the course of employment on 22 June 1998 and 6 March 2001 (section 9, 1987 Act);

·Mr Gagovski’s employment was a substantial contributing factor to his injuries (section 9A, 1987 Act);

·Mr Gagovski continues to be unfit for his pre-injury employment and is partially incapacitated as a result of his injuries (section 33, 1987 Act), and

·the weekly amount that Mr Gagovski would probably have been earning but for his injury (had he continued to be employed in the same or…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Metal Manufactures Limited v Gagovski and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] NSWWCCPD 267
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Metal Manufactures Limited v Gagovski, Metal Manufactures Limited appealed against a decision of the Workers Compensation Commission of New South Wales, constituted by an Arbitrator, which found that Mr Nikola Gagovski was entitled to weekly compensation for his injuries and partial incapacity. The appeal was determined on the papers, without a formal hearing. Metal Manufactures contended that the Arbitrator had erred in law by failing to properly consider the relevant statutory provisions, misapplying authority, and in failing to take into account relevant matters in applying the statutory provisions. Mr Gagovski supported the Arbitrator’s determination. The appeal was dismissed, and the decision of the Arbitrator was confirmed. The Appellant was ordered to pay the Respondent’s costs of the appeal. The Deputy President also made a finding that the parties would reasonably be expected to co-operate in the quantification of the award and in bringing the matter to a conclusion, without further delay.

Background

Background to the litigation

Nikola Gagovski worked for Metal Manufactures Limited since 1976. He suffered two back injuries at work on 22 June 1998 and 6 March 2001. Following the second injury, he had a laminectomy on 11 May 2001 and returned to work on 10 September 2001 on a structured program of modified duties at his pre-injury wages. Metal Manufactures Limited’s workers compensation insurer, Allianz Australia Workers Compensation (NSW) Limited, acted on behalf of the employer in the Commission proceedings. Mr Gagovski made a claim for lump sum compensation for permanent impairment and pain and suffering, which was settled and registered in the Compensation Court on 19 April 2002. On 3 March 2003, Mr Gagovski ceased working at level 4 status and commenced working as a cleaner for Metal Manufactures at level 2. On 22 July 2004, Mr Gagovski filed an ‘Application to Resolve a Dispute’ seeking payments of weekly benefits compensation. The dispute went to Arbitration on 5 November 2004, with several key issues in dispute including the average weekly amount Mr Gagovski is earning or would be able to earn in some suitable employment from time to time after the injury, and whether Mr Gagovski unreasonably rejected suitable employment.

The matter was first heard by an Arbitrator on 5 November 2004. On 15 February 2005, the Arbitrator issued a determination ordering Metal Manufactures Limited to pay weekly compensation to Mr Gagovski and his costs. Dissatisfied with the Arbitrator’s decision, Metal Manufactures Limited lodged an ‘Appeal Against Decision of Arbitrator’ on 15 March 2005. Mr Gagovski opposed the appeal on 8 April 2005. The appeal was determined on the papers on 10 October 2006.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the Arbitrator err in law by failing to properly consider section 40(2)(b) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987?
2. Did the Arbitrator err in law by failing to properly apply Morgan v Commissioner for Railways?
3. Did the Arbitrator misapply section 40(2)(b) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987?
4. Did the Arbitrator fail to take into account matters relevant to section 40(2A) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987?
5. Did the Arbitrator err in applying the concept of reasonableness in section 40(2A) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987?

Held
1. The court found that the Arbitrator did not err in law by failing to properly consider section 40(2)(b) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987. The appeal on this ground was dismissed.
2. The court found that the Arbitrator did not err in law by failing to properly apply Morgan v Commissioner for Railways. The appeal on this ground was dismissed.
3. The court found that the Arbitrator did not misapply section 40(2)(b) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987. The appeal on this ground was dismissed.
4. The court found that the Arbitrator did not fail to take into account matters relevant to section 40(2A) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987. The appeal on this ground was dismissed.
5. The court found that the Arbitrator did not err in applying the concept of reasonableness in section 40(2A) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987. The appeal on this ground was dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the appeal on five grounds, all of which were ultimately dismissed. Firstly, concerning section 40(2)(b) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987, the court found that the Arbitrator had applied the correct approach to determining the reduction in earnings of the worker. The Arbitrator correctly considered the interaction between section 40 and section 40(2A), and determined that the worker's current income was the appropriate figure for step 2 under section 40(2)(b) of the 1987 Act. The court found that it was open to the Arbitrator to conclude that the worker's earnings were not an under-estimation, or an inadequate reflection of his ability to earn.

Secondly, concerning the application of Morgan v Commissioner for Railways, the court found that the Arbitrator's analysis of the authorities cited, including Morgan, and his conclusions based on that analysis, as applied to the facts in this case, demonstrated no error of law. The Arbitrator was entitled to take into account the worker's actual earnings, and the court found no evidence to support the proposition that the worker acted foolishly, irresponsibly or with misconduct.

Thirdly, concerning the misapplication of section 40(2)(b), the court found that this ground had essentially been dealt with in relation to the first ground of appeal, and required no further consideration.

Fourthly, concerning the failure to take into account matters relevant to section 40(2A), the court found that the Arbitrator's consideration of the matters raised was adequate, and that no error of law was demonstrated.

Lastly, concerning the error in applying the concept of reasonableness in section 40(2A), the court found that the Arbitrator's analysis of the facts and authorities with regard to "unreasonableness" was quite adequate, and that there was no error of law on the part of the Arbitrator. The court found that the worker did not "refuse" but negotiated an outcome that was satisfactory to both himself and his employer.

In summary, the court found that the Arbitrator had made no error of law, and the appeal was not successful. The decision of the Arbitrator dated 15 February 2005 was confirmed.