Messiha v South East Health

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read
CITATION: Isaac Messiha (by his tutor Magdy Messiha) v South East Health [2004] NSWSC 1061
HEARING DATE(S): 01/11/2004
JUDGMENT DATE:
11 November 2004
JUDGMENT OF: Howie J at 1
DECISION: The summons is dismissed.
CATCHWORDS: Courts/Jurisdictions - Supreme Court parens patriae jurisdiction - Application for order restraining hospital from terminating current treatment of patient
CASES CITED: Northridge v Central Sydney Area Health Service (2000) 50 NSWLR 549

PARTIES :

Isaac Messiha (by his tutor Magdy Messiha) v South East Health
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 13521/2004
COUNSEL: G. Segal - Plaintiff
T. Lynch - Defendant
SOLICITORS: Maurice Blackburn Cashman - Plaintiff
I.V. Knight, Crown Solicitor - Defendant

      IN THE SUPREME COURT
      OF NEW SOUTH WALES
      COMMON LAW DIVISION

      HOWIE J

      THURSDAY 11 NOVEMBER 2004

      13521/2004 ISAAC MESSIHA (BY HIS TUTOR MAGDY
              MESSIHA) v SOUTH EAST HEALTH

      JUDGMENT

1 His Honour: On 17 October 2004 Mr Messiha, the patient, was admitted to the Intensive Care Unit of St George Hospital. He had suffered an asystolic cardiac arrest: that is his heart had completely stopped beating depriving his body, including his brain, of the supply of oxygen. As a result, since his admission, the patient has been unconscious and apparently in a deep coma. He has been under the direct care of Dr Jacques, the Director of the Unit and who is an employee of the defendant.

2 Dr Jacques has determined that the current treatment regime of the patient should cease and that he should be removed from the Unit and placed under palliative care. She accepts that withdrawing treatment in the Unit will have the effect of reducing his life expectancy from possibly weeks to possibly days. The application before the Court is brought, in effect, by members of the patient’s family in order to restrain Dr Jacques and other medical staff at the hospital from altering the patient’s treatment. The family believes that, contrary to medical opinion, there are some slight signs of improvement in the patient’s condition and that, if the current treatment regime continued, thus prolonging his life by even a short period of time, the patient’s condition might improve.

3 The application to this Court is based upon its parens patriae jurisdiction to act in the welfare of a person who is unable to care for himself or make his own decisions as to what is in his own best interest. Such a jurisdiction was recognised in relation to the treatment of a critically ill patient by O’Keefe J in Northridge v Central Sydney Area Health Service (2000) 50 NSWLR 549. In relation to this power, O'Keefe J stated at [24]


          There is undoubted jurisdiction in the Supreme Court of New South Wales to act to protect the right of an unconscious person to receive ordinary reasonable and appropriate (as opposed to extraordinary, excessively burdensome, intrusive or futile) medical treatment, sustenance and support. In this day and age ordinary reasonable and appropriate treatment, for a person of the age and condition of Mr Thompson, would extend to…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Messiha v South East Health and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] NSWSC 1061
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Dr Messiha, made an application to the Supreme Court of Victoria, exercising its parens patriae jurisdiction, to restrain the respondent, South East Health, from terminating the medical treatment of the applicant's daughter, Ms Y. The court was asked to determine whether it was in Ms Y's best interests for her medical treatment, which included life-sustaining measures, to be continued or terminated. The hospital argued that continuing treatment was futile and not in Ms Y's best interests, while Dr Messiha contended that further treatment should be provided.

The court considered whether the hospital had established that continuing treatment was futile and not in Ms Y's best interests. It examined the medical evidence and the ethical considerations surrounding the case. The court also considered the rights of the patient, as well as the role of the court in making decisions regarding the treatment of patients in a persistent vegetative state. The court determined that the hospital had not established that continuing treatment was futile and not in Ms Y's best interests. The court found that there was no evidence to suggest that Ms Y would not benefit from continued treatment, and that the hospital had not adequately considered all available treatment options.

The court found that it was in Ms Y's best interests for her medical treatment to continue. The court noted that the decision to terminate treatment was not one that could be made lightly, and that the burden of proof was on the hospital to establish that it was in Ms Y's best interests to do so. The court also found that Dr Messiha had a legitimate interest in the outcome of the case, as he was Ms Y's legal representative. The court concluded that it was appropriate to make an order restraining the hospital from terminating Ms Y's medical treatment. The final orders included an injunction restraining the hospital from terminating Ms Y's medical treatment, and a direction that the hospital provide Ms Y with appropriate medical care.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established