| IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA | Not Restricted | |
AT MELBOURNE
COMMON LAW DIVISION
No. 7692 of 2009
| JAMAL MESSADE | Plaintiff |
| v | |
| BAIRES CONTRACTING PTY LTD | Defendant |
---
JUDGE: | J FORREST J | |
WHERE HELD: | Melbourne | |
DATES OF HEARING: | 28 February, 1, 2, 3, 7, 8, 9 and 10 March 2011 | |
DATES OF RULING: | 9 & 10 March 2011 | |
CASE MAY BE CITED AS: | Messade v Baires Contracting Pty Ltd (Rulings No 2, 3, & 4) | |
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: | [2011] VSC 75 | |
---
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Rule in Browne v Dunn – Recall of expert witness (Ruling No 2
JURY – Discharge of jury – Interaction of juror with plaintiff – Risk to a fair trial (Ruling No 3).
JURY – Mode of trial – Rule 47.02(3) Supreme Court (General Civil Procedure) Rules 2005 – No fault on part of defendant – Prima facie entitlement to trial by jury – Retrial ordered – Trial by jury or judge alone subsequent to discharge of jury (Ruling No 4).
---
APPEARANCES: | Counsel | Solicitors |
| For the Plaintiff | Mr J Richards SC Ms T Riddell | Clark Toop & Taylor |
| For the Defendant | Ms M Hartley SC Ms P Cefai-Talbot | Hall and Wilcox |
HIS HONOUR:
Ruling No 2 (Wednesday 9 March) – Recall of Dr Ibrahim
Yesterday morning (8 March) Ms Hartley who appears with Ms Cefai for the defendant raised an issue concerning her cross-examination of Dr Ibrahim, the plaintiff's treating psychiatrist. Dr Ibrahim had been called on 7 March by the plaintiff, cross-examined by Ms Hartley and then excused from further attendance.
The plaintiff has been examined on four occasions by Dr Kornan, a consultant psychiatrist on behalf of the defendant. Ms Hartley frankly and correctly submitted that she failed to put three key components of Dr Kornan's opinion[1] to Dr Ibrahim as the rule in Browne v Dunn[2] would require, namely;
[1]Report of 11 March 2010.
[2](1899) 6 R 67.
I now feel his psychiatric presentation whilst consistent with that diagnosis, (that is, of adjustment disorder with mixed disturbance of emotional conduct), is also consistent with someone in whom he might be actually functioning much better than he indicates. His mental status presentation where he sat back in his chair with his arms in his pockets in a slightly disdainful manner did not indicate necessarily someone who was in significant distress.
Dr Kornan then opined:
The prognosis is bound up by litigation. Once litigation has been concluded he will not require further psychiatric treatment, nor in my opinion, medication. I do not see him as having any long term significant psychiatric difficulties with the possible exception of some very intermittent mild anxiety, and depression, if in fact pains persists to any degree.
And then to the question:
Do you consider the worker to be incapacitated for employment as a result of any psychiatric injury arising out of or in the course of employment and if so, the nature of the incapacity –
Dr Kornan said:
With regards as to employment I feel…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Messade v Baires Contracting Pty Ltd (Rulings No 2, 3, and 4... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] VSC 75
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The first issue pertained to the recall of an expert witness, governed by the rule in Browne v Dunn. The plaintiff sought to recall an expert who had already testified. The court considered whether the circumstances justified recalling the expert, and if doing so would prejudice the defendant. The second issue concerned the discharge of the jury after a juror interacted with the plaintiff. The court had to determine whether this interaction posed a risk to the fairness of the trial. The third issue involved the mode of trial, specifically whether the defendant was entitled to a trial by jury following the discharge of the jury. The court examined Rule 47.02(3) of the Supreme Court (General Civil Procedure) Rules 2005 and assessed whether the defendant's fault was involved in the jury's discharge.
The court concluded that the plaintiff's application for recalling the expert witness was not justified as it would not significantly contribute to the fairness of the trial. Regarding the juror's interaction with the plaintiff, the court found that it did not inherently risk the fairness of the trial but acknowledged the potential for prejudice. Consequently, the court ordered a retrial by jury or a judge alone, given that there was no fault on the defendant's part in the jury's discharge. The court determined that the defendant was prima facie entitled to a trial by jury, and thus a retrial was necessary. The court also decided that the matter should be remitted to Associate Justice Daly for refixing as soon as practicable.
Orders
Orders of the court
I reject the application on behalf of the plaintiff and I propose to order that the matter be remitted to Associate Justice Daly for refixing as soon as is practicable.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi