Mesiti v South West Realty Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read
WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION
DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR
CITATION: Mesiti v South West Realty Pty Ltd [2010] NSWWCCPD 122
APPELLANT: Angelo Roy Mesiti
RESPONDENT: South West Realty Pty Ltd
INSURER: Employers Mutual (NSW) Ltd
FILE NUMBER: WCC A1-004026/10
ARBITRATOR: Mr B McManamey
DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION: 18 August 2010
DATE OF APPEAL DECISION: 18 November 2010
SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION: Fresh evidence on appeal; s 352(6) of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998; failure to demonstrate economic incapacity; s 40 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987
PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER: President Judge Keating
HEARING: On the papers
REPRESENTATION: Appellant: Galluzzo Lawyers
Respondent: Edwards Michael Lawyers

ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:

1.     The Arbitrator’s findings, orders and directions made in the Certificate of Determination dated 18 August 2010 are confirmed, subject to the addition of the following order:

“Each party is to pay his or its own costs of the arbitration.”

2.     Each party is to pay his or its own costs of the appeal.

BACKGROUND TO THE APPEAL

  1. At the time of having sustained the injuries the subject of this appeal, the appellant worker, Mr Mesiti, was a self-employed working director of South West Realty Pty Ltd. The company operated a real estate agency known as L J Hooker Hoxton Park.

  2. Mr Mesiti alleges he was injured on three occasions. The first injury occurred on 2 August 2007, when the vehicle he was driving went off the side of the road and collided with a telegraph pole. He suffered a fractured sternum and injuries to his knees, shoulders, neck, back and left hip.

  3. The second injury occurred on 18 April 2008, when he slipped at his business premises and suffered injuries to his right shoulder, back and right knee.

  4. On 26 June 2009, during the course of a property inspection, he tripped and fell, injuring his left shin, left knee, right knee and right shoulder.

  5. After the motor vehicle accident on 2 August 2007, Mr Mesiti had difficulty performing his normal duties and reduced his working hours. In particular, he stopped working on Saturday afternoons and Sundays.

  6. After the injuries in April 2008 and June 2009, he progressively reduced his working hours and ultimately sold his business, with settlement occurring on 6 May 2010. Immediately prior to the sale, he had reduced his hours to five hours per day, five days per week. It was a condition of the sale that Mr Mesiti was to continue work in the agency for three months after the sale, for which he was not to be separately remunerated.

  7. At the end of the three-month transition period, it was agreed between Mr Mesiti and the new proprietors of the agency that he would work for them as real estate agent on a commission basis. He had not received any remuneration as a commission agent at the time of the arbitration.

  8. Employers Mutual (NSW) Ltd (Employers Mutual) accepted liability for Mr Mesiti’s claim and made voluntary payments…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mesiti v South West Realty Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NSWWCCPD 122
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mesiti v South West Realty Pty Ltd was a case before the New South Wales Court of Appeal, which involved a dispute between an employee, Mesiti, and his former employer, South West Realty Pty Ltd, regarding workers' compensation claims. Mesiti sought to introduce fresh evidence on appeal to challenge the Arbitrator's decision that he had failed to demonstrate economic incapacity under section 40 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987. The legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether it was appropriate to admit fresh evidence in the circumstances of the case, in light of Practice Direction No 6 of the Workers' Compensation Commission and relevant case law.

The Court of Appeal held that the fresh evidence was not admissible. The Court found that the evidence could have been obtained with reasonable diligence and was therefore not admissible under the first condition set out in Akins v National Australia Bank. The Court also found that there was not a high degree of probability that there would have been a different decision if the evidence had been admitted at the arbitration, and therefore the second condition was not satisfied. Finally, the Court found that the evidence was not credible and therefore the third condition was not satisfied. The Court also considered whether it was just to admit the fresh evidence in all the circumstances of the case, and concluded that it was not.

The Court of Appeal confirmed the Arbitrator's findings, orders and directions, and ordered that each party was to pay their own costs of the arbitration and appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Arbitrator’s findings, orders and directions made in the Certificate of Determination dated 18 August 2010 are confirmed, subject to the addition of the following order:

“Each party is to pay his or its own costs of the arbitration.”

2. Each party is to pay his or its own costs of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Practice Direction No 6 sets out the process for seeking leave of the Commission to give ‘new evidence’ on appeal. It provides as follows:“FRESH EVIDENCE AND/OR ADDITIONAL EVIDENCEEach application to introduce fresh evidence or additional evidence on appeal will be considered on its own facts and circumstances and in the context of the Commission’s obligation to act according to equity, good conscience and the substantial merits of the case without regard to technicalities or legal forms (see s 354 of the 1998 Act).In the exercise of its discretion to admit fresh evidence or further evidence on appeal the Commission will have regard to, and the parties should make submissions on, whether:·it can be demonstrated that the evidence could not with reasonable diligence have been obtained by the party and tendered in proceedings before the Arbitrator;·the evidence is credible;·there is a high degree of probability that there would have been a different decision if the evidence had been admitted at the arbitration, and/or ·it is just to admit the evidence in all the circumstances of the individual case.Parties should be aware that a review under s 352 of the 1998 Act is not a rehearing or hearing de novo. The original arbitration should not be treated as a preliminary hearing and all relevant evidence should be called at that time.” Practice Direction No 6 also provides that, if fresh evidence or evidence in addition to or in substitution for the evidence received in relation to the decision appealed against is relied upon, parties must include:·a schedule of the fresh or additional evidence;·a copy of the fresh or additional evidence;·a brief outline of the fresh or additional evidence and the reasons why it was not given in proceedings before the Arbitrator, and·submissions on why the fresh or additional evidence should be admitted, or rejected as the case may be.Where a party seeks leave to rely on fresh or additional evidence in relation to the decision appealed against, that party must serve a copy of the fresh or additional evidence on the other parties to the dispute when serving the Application or Notice of Opposition. The Court of Appeal considered the introduction of fresh evidence or additional evidence on appeal in Haider v J P Morgan Holdings Aust t/as J P Morgan Operations Australia Ltd [2007] NSWCA 158; 4 DDCR 634, where Basten JA referred to Akins v National Australia Bank (1994) 34 NSWLR 155 (Akins) and other authorities. In Akins, Clarke JA (Sheller JA and Powell JA agreeing) stated at [160] that three conditions need to be met before ‘fresh evidence’ can be admitted. These are:“(1) It must be shown that the evidence could not have been obtained with reasonable diligence for use at the trial;(2) The evidence must be such that there must be a high degree of probability that there would be a different verdict;(3) The evidence must be credible.” However, in Nowlan v Marson Transport Pty Ltd [2001] NSWCA 346; 53 NSWLR 116, Heydon JA stated at [15]:“Even if the three tests stated in the Akins case are applicable and are not satisfied, a question remains: is it just to admit the further evidence in the case?”

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.