Merton & Merton

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

MERTON & MERTON [2007] FamCA 1350

FAMILY LAW – CHILDREN – CHILD’S DISCLOSURES – Disclosures by child of touching and playing with father’s penis – Whether on the evidence a finding of sexual abuse open – Finding not made – Whether unacceptable risk of sexual abuse – Whether need to protect child from physical or psychological harm by being subjected to or exposed to a risk of sexual abuse – Finding that no unacceptable risk of sexual abuse – Consequent finding that no need to protect child from physical or psychological harm by being subjected to or exposed to a risk of sexual abuse

FAMILY LAW – CHILDREN – PARENTAL RESPONSIBILITY – Whether parties able to communicate and cooperate for the purpose of equal shared parental responsibility

FAMILY LAW – CHILDREN – EQUAL TIME – SUBSTANTIAL AND SIGNIFICANT TIME – Equal time considered – Substantial and significant time considered – Child’s best interests – Determination that at this stage equal time not in child’s best interests – Substantial and significant time at this stage in child’s best interests – Observation that in the future equal time order may be appropriate

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth)
Family Law Act 1975 (Cth)

Briginshaw & Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336
Hilton & Allen (1940) 63 CLR 691
M & M (1988) 166 CLR 69
Reifek &  McElroy (1965) 112 CLR 517
WK & SR (1997) FLC 92-787 

APPLICANT: Mr Merton
RESPONDENT: Ms Merton
INDEPENDENT CHILDREN’S LAWYER: Jennifer McArdle
FILE NUMBER: BRF 4482 of 1999
DATE DELIVERED: 19 November 2007
PLACE DELIVERED: Brisbane
PLACE HEARD: Brisbane
JUDGMENT OF: O'Reilly J
HEARING DATE: 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 16, 17 and  18 July 2007

REPRESENTATION:

THE APPLICANT: Self represented
COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENT: Mr Ashcroft of Counsel
SOLICITOR FOR THE RESPONDENT: Ms Gilmour
COUNSEL FOR THE INDEPENDENT CHILDREN’S LAWYER: Mr Andrew of Counsel
SOLICITOR FOR THE INDEPENDENT CHILDREN’S LAWYER: Ms Jennifer McArdle

ORDERS

UPON THE FATHER’S ORAL UNDERTAKING PROVIDED IN OPEN COURT ON 18 JULY 2007 NOT TO:

A        BATHE WITH THE CHILD

BBE NAKED WITH OR IN THE PRESENCE OF OR IN THE VIEW OF THE CHILD

IT IS ORDERED:

Parental responsibility

  1. The parties have equal shared parental responsibility for the child … born on … December 1997 (the child).

Child’s living arrangements

  1. The child spend substantial and significant time with each of the parties as follows:

    A        The child spend time with the father:

    (a)during school terms:

    (i)until the end of the present school term, in fortnightly cycles, from 9am Saturday until 5pm Sunday in the first week and from 9am Sunday until 5pm Sunday in the second week, the first week to coincide with the present arrangement for the child’s Saturday and Sunday day time with the father and the second week to coincide with the present arrangement for the child’s single Sunday day time with the father;

    (ii)from the commencement of the 2008 school year, in fortnightly cycles, in the first week from after school…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Merton & Merton and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] FamCA 1350
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Merton & Merton, O'Reilly J of the Family Court of Australia considered issues relating to parental responsibility, the living arrangements for a child, and the need to protect the child from harm. The proceedings arose from allegations of sexual abuse made by the child concerning the father, which the court ultimately did not find to have occurred, and the question of whether there was an unacceptable risk of such abuse. The court also had to determine if the parties could cooperate for the purposes of equal shared parental responsibility and what living arrangements were in the child's best interests.

The court was required to determine whether a finding of sexual abuse was open on the evidence, and if not, whether there was an unacceptable risk of sexual abuse requiring protection for the child from physical or psychological harm. Furthermore, the court had to assess the parties' capacity to communicate and cooperate for the purpose of equal shared parental responsibility. Finally, the court needed to decide whether equal time with the child was in the child's best interests at that stage, or if substantial and significant time was more appropriate.

O'Reilly J found that while the child had made disclosures of touching involving the father's penis, the evidence did not support a finding of sexual abuse. Consequently, the court determined that there was no unacceptable risk of sexual abuse and therefore no need to protect the child from harm arising from such a risk. The court also made orders for equal shared parental responsibility, acknowledging that the parties' ability to communicate and cooperate would be facilitated by specific undertakings from the father regarding bathing and nudity with the child. The court concluded that at that stage, equal time was not in the child's best interests, but substantial and significant time with each parent was appropriate, with the possibility of equal time being considered in the future. The orders detailed specific arrangements for the child's living arrangements, communication between parties and the child, and other matters concerning the child's welfare.

Orders

Orders of the court

UPON THE FATHER’S ORAL UNDERTAKING PROVIDED IN OPEN COURT ON 18 JULY 2007 NOT TO:

A BATHE WITH THE CHILD

B BE NAKED WITH OR IN THE PRESENCE OF OR IN THE VIEW OF THE CHILD

IT IS ORDERED:

Parental responsibility

1.

The parties have equal shared parental responsibility for the child … born on … December 1997 (the child).

Child’s living arrangements

2.

The child spend substantial and significant time with each of the parties as follows:

A The child spend time with the father:

(a) during school terms:

(i) until the end of the present school term, in fortnightly cycles, from 9am Saturday until 5pm Sunday in the first week and from 9am Sunday until 5pm Sunday in the second week, the first week to coincide with the present arrangement for the child’s Saturday and Sunday day time with the father and the second week to coincide with the present arrangement for the child’s single Sunday day time with the father;

(ii) from the commencement of the 2008 school year, in fortnightly cycles, in the first week from after school on Thursday until the commencement of school on Monday (Tuesday if the Monday is a public holiday or pupil free day), and in the second week overnight from after school on Thursday until the commencement of school on Friday; the fortnightly cycles to recommence at the commencement of each school term (first week then second week) regardless of whether the last week of the preceding school term had been a first week or a second week;

(b) during school holidays (defined for the purpose of these orders as meaning the designated school holidays applicable to the school the child attends, to commence at 9am on the day after each school term finishes and to conclude at 5pm on the day before the next school term commences):

(i) Christmas 2007/New Year 2008:

(I) for one week from 9am Saturday until 9am the following Saturday to be nominated by the father to the mother in writing no later than 30 November 2007, but not to be the week 9am Saturday 22 December 2007 until 9am Saturday 29 December 2007 (in which Christmas Day falls) but which may be the week 9am Saturday 29 December 2007 to 9am Saturday 5 January 2008;

(II) from 5pm on Christmas Eve 2007 until 2pm on Christmas Day 2007;

(III) on two other occasions being 4 day blocks, from 9am Friday until 5pm Monday, one in December 2007 and one in January 2008, to be nominated by the father to the mother in writing no later than 30 November 2007;

(ii) commencing Easter 2008, for half of the Easter, June/July, September/October and Christmas school holidays (as defined above) being the first half in 2008 and the even numbered years and the second half in 2009 and the odd numbered years, “half” to be calculated by the number of nights in each school holiday period as so defined, and if an uneven number of nights, the additional night to be added to the period the child is to spend with the father (for example, if the child is to be with the father for the first half of a holiday period the additional night is to be added to the end of the period and if the child is to be with the father for the second half of a holiday period the additional night is to be added at the commencement of that period), the changeover time to be at 9am on the holiday changeover day;

(c) additional times if not already with the father:

(i) on Father’s Day, if not already with the father, from 9am until 5pm;

(ii) for Christmas Day, if not already with the father, from 5pm on Christmas Eve until 2pm on Christmas Day (except Christmas 2007, as to which par 2A(b)(i)(II) applies);

(iii) on the child’s birthday and the father’s birthday, if not already with the father, if a school day from after school until 6pm and if a weekend day from 2pm until 6pm;

(d) other times:

(i) at all other times which the parties may agree in writing (including by email or text message).

B The child spend time with the mother:

(a) at all other times;

(b) (i) on Mother’s Day, if not already with the mother, from 9am until 5pm;

(ii) for Christmas Day, if not already with the mother, from 5pm on Christmas Eve until 2pm on Christmas Day (except Christmas 2007, as to which par 2A(b)(i)(II) applies);

(iii) on the child’s birthday and the mother’s birthday, if not already with the mother, if a school day from after school until 6pm and if a weekend day from 2pm until 6pm.

Telephone communication

3.

The parties are to allow liberal telephone communication between the child and the other party at reasonable times, to be initiated by the father when the child is with the mother, by the mother when the child is with the father and by the child as reasonably she herself may instigate.

Changeover

4.

The party with whom the child has been spending time must for the commencement of time with the other party deliver the child at the times specified in paragraph 2 to the home of the party with whom the child is about to spend time unless the commencement of time the child spends with a party is after school in which case that party must collect the child from her school at the conclusion of the school day and unless the conclusion of time the child spends with a party is before school in which case that party must deliver the child to her school at the commencement of the school day.

Attendance at the child’s school

5.

The parties each may attend at the child’s school for functions, events, ceremonies and activities which parents usually attend (for example open days, speech days, sports days, concerts, parent/teacher interviews and special functions) and participate with the child in such functions, events, ceremonies and activities to the same extent as usually permitted by the child’s school to the parents of children attending the school subject always to the authority of the child’s school principal and its other officers in relation to such attendances by parents.

6.

Any such attendances by the parties at the child’s school are not for the purpose of these orders to be regarded as a party spending time with the child.

7.

The parties must not other than in the case of an emergency, or any specific invitation from the child’s school, or for changeover as provided in these orders, attend at the child’s school.

Child’s extra curricular activities

8.

The parties are not to arrange for the child to undertake any extra curricular activities other than those in which the child is presently engaged, without the written agreement of the other party.

Child’s attendance at protective behaviour course

9.

The mother must, as soon as possible, and in any event within 30 days, arrange for the child to attend a protective behaviour course, suitable for her age and developmental stage, with Contact House or other similar organisation, to avail the child the opportunity to learn further awareness as to appropriate and inappropriate touching as between children and adults, further protective behaviour skills as to inappropriate touching as between children and adults and the necessity to tell a trusted adult or teacher if any inappropriate touching is requested of her by any person.

10.

The mother must ensure that the child’s attendance at such course not be at times the child is to spend time with the father pursuant to these orders and may, if necessary, arrange for the child’s attendance at such course in school hours.

Provision of a copy of these orders to the principal of the child’s school

11.

The mother and the father are authorised to, and must, provide a copy of these orders to the principal of the child’s school.

12.

The principal of the child’s school is authorised to, and may, show a copy of these orders to the child’s teachers.

Non denigration and non questioning

13.

The parties must not denigrate each other to or in the presence or hearing of the child, must speak of the other party respectfully in the presence or hearing of the child and must not unduly question the child as to activities with the other party or about the other party’s personal life.

Information

14.

The parties must keep each other informed in writing as to:

(a) his and her residential address, landline telephone number (if any) and mobile telephone number (if any); the telephone number or numbers to be used for the other party or the child to initiate the telephone communication referred to in these orders; the telephone number or numbers (if any) for any holiday destinations to which the child may be taken pursuant to these orders; and

(b) the name, address and telephone number of any treating medical or health practitioner the child may attend.

15.

The parties must notify each other as soon as possible of any serious accident or illness relating to the child.

Authorisation

16.

The parties must authorise the child’s school and any treating medical or health practitioner the child may attend to provide to the other party such reports and other information or documents as he/she may seek in writing from the child’s school or any practitioner at his/her cost provided that this order is sufficient authority for that purpose without further authorisation.

Parties’ communication

17.

The parties must communicate with each other in relation to the child and arrangements for the child as may be appropriate by telephone, post, text message or email.

Holidays

18.

If the parties propose to take the child on any holiday outside of the Brisbane area, each must communicate with the other the dates, itinerary and destination (location, not necessarily address) and ensure that the destination is one within mobile telephone communication distance.

Compulsory attendance by the parties upon a family consultant

19.

The parties are to attend upon a family consultant at the Family Court of Australia at Brisbane within 14 days and otherwise at such times and dates as may be directed by the Manager - Child Dispute Services to enable pursuant to s 65L of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) the family consultant to assist the parties to carry out these orders.

Consultation with family dispute resolution practitioner

20.

If the parties are unable to agree any matters concerning the child relating to their equal shared parental responsibility they must:

(a) consult with a family dispute resolution practitioner, or if they cannot agree within 7 days as to the choice of a family dispute resolution practitioner, a counsellor at a family relationship centre, to assist them to resolve any dispute concerning arrangements for the child or proposed consent orders varying these orders; and

(b) must pay the costs of the family dispute resolution practitioner and/or counsellor equally.

All previous orders and undertakings discharged

21.

All previous orders concerning the child are discharged, and all previous undertakings concerning the child are discharged, other than the undertakings above.

All other applications dismissed

22.

All other applications concerning the child are dismissed.

Independent children’s lawyer discharged

23.

The independent children’s lawyer is discharged.

AND IT IS FURTHER ORDERED

24.

Pursuant to s 65DA(2) and s 62B, the particulars of the obligations these orders create, the particulars of the consequences that may follow if a person contravenes these orders and details of who can assist the parties adjust to and comply with these orders are set out in the Fact Sheet attached and those particulars are included in these orders.

Notations:

1.

Paragraph 2B(b) provides an exception to the operation of paragraph 2A.

2.

For the purpose of paragraph 8, the child’s present extra curricular activities are:

(a) for music, piano and cello

(b) for dance, tap and jazz lessons

(c) for sport, tennis, swimming

(d) horse riding

(e) chess club.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established