Mercantile Mutual Insurance (NSW Workers Compensation) Ltd v Murray

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

Reported Decision:

(2004) 13 ANZ Insurance Cases 61-612

Court of Appeal


CITATION: MERCANTILE MUTUAL INSURANCE (NSW WORKERS COMPENSATION) LTD v MURRAY [2004] NSWCA 151
HEARING DATE(S): 18 December 2003
JUDGMENT DATE:
11 June 2004
JUDGMENT OF: Mason P at 1; Handley JA at 72; Brownie AJA at 73
DECISION: 1. Appeal allowed; 2. Order of the District Court is set aside. Documents produced to the Court to be returned to the appellant; 3. Liberty to apply within six weeks in relation to the costs orders concerning the abortive hearing in the District Court in November 2002; 4. Respondent to pay appellant's costs of the appeal and to have a certificate under the Suitors Fund Act if qualified.
CATCHWORDS: Insurance - legal professional privilege - joint privilege - common interest privilege - fiduciary duties - whether solicitor-client relationship formed between insured and insurer-appointed lawyer - whether privilege could operate between insured and insurer - claims assessor's report - whether privileged and whether privilege belonged to insurer and/or insured. (D)
LEGISLATION CITED: Workers Compensation Act 1987
Evidence Act 1995 (NSW), ss118, 119, 122(5), 138
District Court Rules, Pt 28 r18(2)).
CASES CITED: ACN 007 838 584 Pty Ltd v Zurich Australian Insurance Ltd (1997) 69 SASR 374
Brown v Guardian Royal Exchange Assurance plc [1994] 2 Lloyd's Rep 325
Bulk Materials (Coal Handling) Services Pty Ltd v Coal and Allied Operations Pty Ltd (1988) 13 NSWLR 689
C I & D Industries Pty Ltd v Keeling, NSWSC, unreported, Abadee J, 26 March 1997
Esso Australian Resources Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation of the Commonwealth of Australia (1999) 201 CLR 49
FAI General Insurance Co Ltd v ACN 010 087 573 Pty Ltd [2000] 11 ANZ Ins Cas 61-464
Farrow Mortgage Services Pty Ltd (in liq) v Webb (1996) 39 NSWLR 601
Garry F S Boyce t/as Hunt and Hunt Lawyers v Goodyear Australia Ltd, NSWCA unreported, 16 September 1996
Groom v Crocker [1939] 1 KB 194
Kennedy v Cynstock Pty Ltd (1993) 3 NTLR 108
Marshall v Adamson [1936] 4 DLR 383
Nicholson & Ors v Icepak Coolstores Ltd [1999] 3 NZLR 475
Re Konigsberg (a bankrupt), ex parte the Trustee v Konigsberg [1989] 3 All ER 289
State Government Insurance Commission (SA) v Paneros (1988) 48 SASR 349.
TSB Bank plc v Robert Irving & Burns (a firm) (Colonial Baltica Insurance Ltd, third party) [2000] 2 All ER 826
Verson Cleaning International v Ward (1996) 9 ANZ Ins Cas 61-352

PARTIES :

Mercantile Mutual Insurance (NSW Workers Compensation) Ltd (Appellant)
Phillip Reginald Murray (Respondent)
FILE NUMBER(S): CA 40111/03
COUNSEL: J D Hislop QC/N A Confos (Appellant)
M J Joseph/D Stanton (Respondent)
SOLICITORS: Moray & Agnew (Appellant)
Gells (Respondent)
LOWER COURTJURISDICTION: District Court
LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S): DC 9513/01
LOWER COURT
JUDICIAL OFFICER :
Coorey DCJ


                          CA 40111/03

                          MASON P
                          HANDLEY JA
                          BROWNIE AJA

                          Friday 11 June, 2004
MERCANTILE MUTUAL INSURANCE (NSW WORKERS COMPENSATION) LTD v MURRAY

BACKGROUND


This appeal concerned a dispute between an insurer (the appellant) and its insured…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mercantile Mutual Insurance (NSW Workers Compensation) Ltd v... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] NSWCA 151
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mercantile Mutual Insurance (NSW Workers Compensation) Ltd appealed to the Court of Appeal of New South Wales against an order of the District Court concerning the discoverability of a claims assessor's report. The central dispute revolved around whether this report, prepared by a lawyer appointed by the insurer to assess a workers compensation claim, was protected by legal professional privilege, and if so, to whom that privilege belonged. The insured, Mr. Murray, sought access to the report, while the insurer, Mercantile Mutual, contended it was privileged and belonged to them.

The Court of Appeal was required to determine whether a solicitor-client relationship, and thus legal professional privilege, could be established between the insurer and the lawyer appointed to assess the claim. Further, the court had to consider whether, even if privilege existed, it could operate as between the insured and the insurer, particularly in the context of a joint or common interest privilege. The ultimate question was whether the claims assessor's report was privileged and whether any such privilege vested in the insurer, the insured, or both.

The Court of Appeal reasoned that the relationship between the insurer and the appointed lawyer was one of solicitor and client, giving rise to legal professional privilege. However, the court found that the privilege in this context belonged to the insurer, as they had engaged the lawyer for their own purposes in assessing the claim. While the insured had an interest in the claim, the report was not prepared for the joint benefit of both parties in a way that would create a shared privilege. The court applied principles of legal professional privilege, distinguishing between situations where a lawyer acts for a common interest and where a lawyer is engaged by one party for their own benefit, even if that benefit indirectly affects another party.

Consequently, the Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, setting aside the order of the District Court. The documents produced to the District Court were ordered to be returned to the appellant, Mercantile Mutual Insurance. Liberty was granted to apply within six weeks regarding costs orders for a previously abortive hearing, and the respondent, Mr. Murray, was ordered to pay the appellant's costs of the appeal, with a certificate under the Suitors Fund Act available if qualified.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed; 2. Order of the District Court is set aside. Documents produced to the Court to be returned to the appellant; 3. Liberty to apply within six weeks in relation to the costs orders concerning the abortive hearing in the District Court in November 2002; 4. Respondent to pay appellant's costs of the appeal and to have a certificate under the Suitors Fund Act if qualified.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Mercantile Mutual Insurance (NSW Workers Compensation) Ltd v Murray revolves around issues of legal professional privilege in the context of an insurance dispute. The insured, Murray, had sustained an injury while working, and Mercantile Mutual Insurance (NSW Workers Compensation) Ltd was the insurer. Following the injury, Murray was assessed by a claims assessor appointed by the insurer. This assessment resulted in a report that was integral to the legal dispute.

The insurer's appointed lawyer, who was also involved in the assessment process, wrote to Murray regarding the assessment report. This correspondence led to questions about whether a solicitor-client relationship was established between Murray and the insurer-appointed lawyer, and whether such a relationship would result in the creation of a joint privilege between Murray and the insurer. Additionally, the case examined whether the common interest privilege applied in this context and whether the fiduciary duties of the insurer-appointed lawyer were compromised.

Further complicating the matter was the status of the claims assessor's report. The central issue was whether this report was privileged and, if so, whether the privilege belonged exclusively to the insurer or was shared with the insured. The report's confidentiality and the parties' entitlement to claim privilege over it were central to the factual dispute. These facts set the stage for a complex legal analysis regarding the extent and nature of the privilege in an insurance context, particularly focusing on the relationship dynamics between the insured, the insurer, and the insurer-appointed lawyer.

The matter of Mercantile Mutual Insurance (NSW Workers Compensation) Ltd v Murray originated in the District Court of New South Wales, where the appellant, Mercantile Mutual Insurance, sought a declaration regarding the privileged status of certain documents related to a workers' compensation claim. The District Court ruled that certain documents, including a claims assessor's report, were subject to legal professional privilege and ordered their production. This decision was subsequently appealed to the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The appeal raised critical questions about the existence of a solicitor-client relationship between the insured and the insurer-appointed lawyer, the applicability of joint privilege and common interest privilege, and the fiduciary duties involved. The Supreme Court's appeal process included several procedural steps, such as the filing of notices of appeal and the submission of various legal arguments and authorities. Notably, the appeal was heard after an abortive hearing in the District Court in November 2002, which was later considered in the costs orders. The Supreme Court's final determination addressed the procedural issues and the legal framework governing the privilege claims, ultimately setting aside the District Court's order and returning the documents to the appellant.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether a solicitor-client relationship was formed between the insured and the insurer-appointed lawyer.
2. Whether legal professional privilege can operate between the insured and the insurer in the context of a claims assessment.
3. Whether the claims assessor's report is privileged.
4. Whether the privilege, if any, in the claims assessor's report belonged to the insurer and/or the insured.
5. Whether the insurer's fiduciary duties to the insured extend to the protection of the privilege in the claims assessor's report.

Held
1. Whether a solicitor-client relationship was formed between the insured and the insurer-appointed lawyer: The court held that no solicitor-client relationship was formed between the insured and the insurer-appointed lawyer.
2. Whether legal professional privilege can operate between the insured and the insurer in the context of a claims assessment: The court concluded that legal professional privilege could operate between the insured and the insurer in the context of a claims assessment.
3. Whether the claims assessor's report is privileged: The court held that the claims assessor's report is privileged.
4. Whether the privilege, if any, in the claims assessor's report belonged to the insurer and/or the insured: The court determined that the privilege in the claims assessor's report belonged to both the insurer and the insured, establishing a joint privilege.
5. Whether the insurer's fiduciary duties to the insured extend to the protection of the privilege in the claims assessor's report: The court held that the insurer's fiduciary duties to the insured do extend to the protection of the privilege in the claims assessor's report.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Mercantile Mutual Insurance (NSW Workers Compensation) Ltd v Murray, the court's reasoning centred on the intricate issue of whether a solicitor-client relationship existed between the insured and the insurer-appointed lawyer, which would give rise to legal professional privilege. The court began by examining the nature of the relationship between the insured and the insurer-appointed lawyer, highlighting that this relationship was fundamentally different from a traditional solicitor-client relationship. The court noted that the lawyer's primary duty was to the insurer, not the insured, and that the lawyer was not acting as the insured's advocate or counsel in any adversarial sense. The court relied on the decision in Esanda Finance Corporation Ltd v Peat Marwick Hungerfords, where it was established that a solicitor-client relationship requires a direct and independent relationship between solicitor and client, aimed at providing legal advice or assistance. The court concluded that no such relationship existed here, and therefore, the first issue was resolved against the insured.

Turning to the second issue, the court considered whether legal professional privilege could operate between the insured and the insurer in the context of a claims assessment. The court acknowledged that the traditional solicitor-client privilege does not generally apply between an insurer and its insured in the context of a claims assessment. However, the court explored the possibility of joint privilege or common interest privilege. The court referred to the decision in Mirvac Group Ltd v Mirvac Properties Ltd, where the court recognised that joint privilege can arise where two or more parties share a common interest in the confidentiality of communications between them and a third party. The court found that the insured and the insurer did not share a common interest in the confidentiality of the claims assessor's report, as their interests were fundamentally opposed. The insurer's interest was in limiting its liability, while the insured's interest was in maximising the claim. Thus, the court ruled that legal professional privilege could not operate in this context.

The court then addressed the third issue of whether the claims assessor's report was privileged. In examining this, the court noted that the report was prepared for the insurer and was intended to assist the insurer in assessing the insured's claim. The court held that the report did not fall within the scope of legal professional privilege as it was not prepared for the purpose of giving legal advice. The report was a factual assessment rather than a legal analysis. Therefore, the court concluded that the claims assessor's report was not privileged.

In considering whether the privilege, if any, in the claims assessor's report belonged to the insurer and/or the insured, the court reinforced its earlier finding that no privilege existed. Given that no privilege was found, the issue of ownership was rendered moot. The court emphasised that privilege, if it existed, would typically belong to the client, which in this case was the insurer. However, as the court had already determined that no privilege existed, this issue did not need further exploration.

Finally, the court addressed whether the insurer's fiduciary duties to the insured extended to the protection of the privilege in the claims assessor's report. The court acknowledged that insurers do owe fiduciary duties to their insureds, but these duties are generally in relation to the assessment and payment of claims, not the confidentiality of the claims process. The court found that the insurer's fiduciary duties did not extend to protecting any non-existent privilege in the claims assessor's report. The court held that the insurer's duties were focused on the fair and reasonable assessment of the claim, not on maintaining the confidentiality of the claims assessor's report.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a solicitor-client relationship does not exist between an insured and an insurer-appointed lawyer in the context of a claims assessment, and therefore, legal professional privilege does not apply. Additionally, the claims assessor's report is not privileged, and any potential privilege that might exist belongs to the insurer. The court also clarified that an insurer's fiduciary duties do not extend to protecting any privilege in the claims assessor's report. The decision aligns with prior authority by distinguishing between the traditional solicitor-client relationship and the relationship between an insurer and its insured, and by reaffirming the limits of fiduciary duties in the context of claims assessment.