CITATION: Menuko Pty Ltd v Tinine Group Pty Ltd [2007] NSWADT 149 DIVISION: Retail Leases Division PARTIES: APPLICANT
Menuko Pty Ltd
RESPONDENT
Tinine Group Pty LtdFILE NUMBER: 065205 HEARING DATES: 13 April 2007 SUBMISSIONS CLOSED: 13 April 2007
DATE OF DECISION:
25 July 2007BEFORE: Higgins S - Judicial Member CATCHWORDS: Claim for declaration of rights, obligations and liabilities under a lease - Claim for payment of money MATTER FOR DECISION: Principal matter LEGISLATION CITED: Interpretation Act 1987
Retail Leases Act 1994CASES CITED: Hanna v Saracoglu [2005] NSWADT 227
Moratic Pty Ltd v Laurence James Gordon [2007] NSWSC 5 Polgara Pty Ltd v Vision Wise Holdings Pty Ltd (BC9600730)(unreported, NSWSC, 11 March 1996)REPRESENTATION: APPLICANT
RESPONDENT
D Murr, Barrister
G McNally, BarristerORDERS: 1. Declare that the final sentence of clause 8 of the lease is void by reason of s.18(4) of the Retail Leases Act; 2. Parties wishing to make an application for costs to file and serve written submissions within 28 days of this decision, failing which there will be no order as to costs; 3. Subject to submissions being filed as referred to in order 2. above, submissions in reply to be served within a further 28 days and the tribunal to determine costs on the papers.
1 The applicant lessor has sought a declaration on the proper construction of cl.8 of a lease made between the applicant and the respondent lessee and the applicability of s.18 of the Retail Leases Act1994 (the RL Act) to that clause. In addition to this the applicant seeks orders as to the rent which is payable pursuant to the lease, in light of the findings of the tribunal in respect to these issues of construction.
2 The dispute arose after the respondent had exercised its right of a further option to lease the premises. That right was exercised pursuant to cl.8 which also made provision for the rent that was payable at the commencement of the new term of the lease. This rent was to be the market rent as at the date of renewal of the lease, but the clause also contained a ‘ratchet’ clause that provided that the rent was not to be any less than what the rent had been immediately prior to its renewal. The parties were not able to agree on the market rent and appointed a valuer to determine the rent as at the date of renewal. The valuer determined this rent to be less than the rent that was payable immediately prior to renewal. Furthermore, it was less than the rent at the commencement of the original term of the lease. On receipt of the valuation the respondent agreed to pay rent in accordance with the valuation, whereas the respondent relied on the ratchet provision in cl.8 of the lease. It is the respondent’s position that the ratchet provision is void by reason of s.18(4) of the RL Act.
The Lease
3 The lease the subject of these proceedings commenced…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Menuko Pty Ltd v Tinine Group Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2007] NSWADT 149
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the tribunal was whether the final sentence of clause 8 of the lease was enforceable or if it was void under section 18(4) of the Retail Leases Act. This section of the Act prevents the enforcement of certain lease provisions that are deemed unfair or unreasonable. The tribunal had to consider whether the clause in question met the criteria for being unfair or unreasonable, and if so, whether it should be voided under the Act.
After examining the lease agreement and relevant legal principles, the tribunal found that the final sentence of clause 8 was indeed unfair and unreasonable, and therefore, it was void under section 18(4) of the Retail Leases Act. Consequently, the tribunal declared that the final sentence of clause 8 was void. Additionally, the tribunal noted that parties wishing to make an application for costs should file and serve written submissions within 28 days of the decision. If no submissions were filed within the specified timeframe, there would be no order as to costs. If submissions were filed, the tribunal would allow a further 28 days for submissions in reply, after which it would determine the costs on the papers.
The tribunal's final orders included a declaration that the final sentence of clause 8 of the lease was void, instructions for parties to file submissions regarding costs within a specified timeframe, and a provision for the tribunal to determine costs based on the submissions received.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Declare that the final sentence of clause 8 of the lease is void by reason of s.18(4) of the Retail Leases Act; 2. Parties wishing to make an application for costs to file and serve written submissions within 28 days of this decision, failing which there will be no order as to costs; 3. Subject to submissions being filed as referred to in order 2. above, submissions in reply to be served within a further 28 days and the tribunal to determine costs on the papers.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.