Mentha v Australian Securities and Investments Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Mentha v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2023] FCA 667  

File number(s): VID 200 of 2023
Judgment of: BUTTON J
Date of judgment: 20 June 2023
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – suppression orders – where suppression orders are sought in relation to parts of a letter from the second respondent to the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) seeking authorisation as an eligible applicant to apply for examination summonses under Div 1 of Pt 5.9 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), and parts of further correspondence with ASIC and internal ASIC documents – where liquidators of company have sought judicial review of ASIC’s decision to grant eligible applicant status – whether suppression order is “necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice” – whether not making suppression order will result in topics of proposed examination being disclosed to any material extent given previous ventilation of issues of concern so as to prejudice the proper administration of justice – whether not making suppression order sought will prejudice the proper administration of justice by effectively granting access to an affidavit otherwise confidential under s 596C of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) and r 11.3 of the Supreme Court (Corporations) Rules 1999 (NSW) – application for suppression order dismissed – Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 37AF, s 37AG
Legislation:

Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) s 127

Corporations Act2001 (Cth) ss 439A, 447A, 447D, 596A, 596B, 596C

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 37AE, 37AF, 37AG

Supreme Court (Corporations) Rules 1999 (NSW) r 11.3

Cases cited:

Accord Pacific Holdings Pty Ltd v Accord Pacific Land Pty Ltd (in liq) [2011] NSWSC 707

Australian Broadcasting Commission v Parish (1980) 29 ALR 228

Country Care Group Pty Ltd v Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions (No 2) (2020) 275 FCR 377

Hogan v Australian Crime Commission (2010) 240 CLR 651

In the matter of ACN 004 410 833 Ltd (formerly Arrium Ltd) (in liq) [2023] NSWSC 461

In-N-Out Burgers, Inc v Hashtag Burgers Pty Ltd (2020) 377 ALR 166; [2020] FCA 193

Kogan, in the matter of Rogulj Enterprises Pty Ltd (in liq) [2021] FCA 856

Lee v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation [2023] FCAFC 22

Lombe, in the matter of Babcock and Brown Ltd (in liq) [2022] FCA 957

Motorola Solutions Inc v Hytera Communications Corporation Ltd (No 2) [2018] FCA 17

O’Brien v Wily (2009) 76 NSWLR 428

Porter v Australian Broadcasting Corporation [2021] FCA 863

Rinehart v Welker (2011) 93 NSWLR 311

Secatore, in the matter of Last Lap Pty Ltd (in liq) (2020) 144 ACSR 648; [2020] FCA 627

Sister Marie Brigid Arthur (Litigation Representative) v Northern Territory of Australia (No 2) [2020] FCA 215

Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Corporations and Corporate Insolvency
Number of paragraphs: 67
Date of hearing: 14 June 2023
Counsel for the Applicants: Ms V Whittaker SC with Mr A Di Stefano
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mentha v Australian Securities and Investments Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 667
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Mentha v Australian Securities and Investments Commission involved the liquidators of Arrium Group, who sought judicial review of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission's (ASIC) decision to grant Atradius, a trade credit insurer, the status of an eligible applicant to apply for examination summonses under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). Atradius sought suppression orders in relation to parts of a letter to ASIC, further correspondence, and internal ASIC documents. The liquidators argued that the suppression orders were necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice and that not making such orders would prejudice justice by granting access to an affidavit otherwise confidential.

The court examined the legal issues surrounding the necessity of suppression orders to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice and whether not making such orders would result in the disclosure of topics of proposed examination to any material extent, given the previous ventilation of issues of concern. The court also considered whether not making suppression orders sought would prejudice the proper administration of justice by effectively granting access to an affidavit otherwise confidential under s 596C of the Corporations Act and r 11.3 of the Supreme Court (Corporations) Rules 1999 (NSW).

The Federal Court dismissed Atradius's application for suppression orders. The court found that Atradius had not satisfied the onus of proving that the orders were necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice. The court emphasised that the determination of whether suppression orders should be made turns on whether they are necessary for the stated reason, without involving a balancing exercise or discretionary considerations. The court also highlighted that a primary objective of the administration of justice is to safeguard the public interest in open justice.

The final orders of the court dismissed Atradius's interlocutory application, required Atradius to pay the liquidators' costs of the application, and set out the procedure for any future costs applications between the parties.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The second respondent’s interlocutory application dated 29 May 2023 (the Application) is dismissed.

2. The second respondent pay the applicants’ costs of the Application.

3. If the applicants seek any costs order against the first respondent, or if the first respondent seeks its costs of the Application, they are to notify the other parties by 4:00pm on Friday, 23 June 2023. If there is any dispute as to costs, the parties are to file and serve submissions of no more than three pages on costs by 4:00pm on Friday, 30 June 2023, following which costs will be determined on the papers.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

A more detailed, although still concise, summary of the Arrium Group, its administration and financial arrangements, is set out in the judgment of Black J in In the matter of ACN 004 410 833 Ltd (formerly Arrium Ltd) (in liq) [2023] NSWSC 461 (the NSW judgment). While Atradius has filed a notice of intention to appeal in respect of the NSW judgment, Black J’s reasons nevertheless provide a useful summary. As Black J set out, a subset of subsidiaries in the Arrium Group were known as the Moly-Cop entities. They operated a business providing consumables to mining companies. Many of the grievances pursued by Atradius relate to the way in which the then-administrators dealt with the Moly-Cop entities and a group of financiers, which ultimately resulted in the group of financiers receiving a significantly higher return than other creditors: 70 cents in the dollar as against 24 cents in the dollar. Atradius is a trade credit insurer and, in April 2022, took an assignment of debt from one of its insured trade creditors. On 11 April 2022, Atradius applied to ASIC to be authorised as an eligible applicant for the purposes of Div 1 of Pt 5.9 of the Corporations Act (the April 2022 letter). Atradius’s application was granted by ASIC by letter on 7 June 2022. On 1 August 2022, Atradius commenced proceedings in the Supreme Court of New South Wales by an Originating Process, which attached (as a schedule) its proposed statement of claim (the 2022 SOC). The Originating Process was not served straight away; rather, Atradius sought an extension of time in which to serve the Originating Process. That application was ultimately heard with the Liquidators and some of the group of financiers appearing. They had, amongst other documents, the 2022 SOC and a supporting affidavit of Atradius’ solicitor in support of the application for an extension of time in which to serve the Originating Process. The 2022 SOC raises a number of points previously raised in a Statement of Claim filed in this Court in December 2017 by a creditor, Epic Energy South Australia Pty Ltd (Epic), but not determined. Epic had been appointed to represent the interests of approximately 4,000 general creditors in an application brought by the then-deed administrators of the former Arrium Group, some of whom are now the Liquidators in the current proceeding. On 1 November 2022, Atradius applied to the Supreme Court of New South Wales for the issue of examination summonses and orders for production pursuant to ss 596A and 596B of the Corporations Act. The proposed examinees included the Liquidators and Leon Zwier of Arnold Bloch Leibler who, along with Elyse Hilton, act for the Liquidators in this proceeding. Mr Zwier also acts for a number of other proposed examinees. No summonses for examination have yet been issued. Although not entirely clear, it appears that the issue of summonses has been deferred pending the outcome of the proposed appeal of the NSW judgment, and this proceeding. The Liquidators have stated that, if examination summonses are issued, they will apply to have them set aside. Atradius refused to provide a copy of the affidavit filed in support of the application for the issue of examination summonses to the Liquidators, relying on s 596C of the Corporations Act. Section 596C(2) provides that the affidavit filed in support of an application for a summons under s 596B is “not available for inspection except so far as the Court orders”. The affidavit in support of the summonses annexed a copy of the April 2022 letter, but I was not otherwise provided with any information as to the contents of the affidavit. As I will come to, s 596C and the affidavit filed in support of the examination summonses, assume importance in the present application.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Liquidators also note that, where an application for the issue of a summons for examination is made by someone other than a liquidator, r 11.3(5) of the NSW Rules provides that the liquidator is to be given notice of the application and, if required by the liquidator, served with a copy of the supporting affidavit. The Liquidators further noted that, while the matters that may lead to an affidavit that would otherwise be confidential pursuant to s 596C being made available include the adequacy of disclosure, those issues do not arise on the present application as no summonses for examination have been issued. In the Liquidators’ submission, s 596C does not provide a shield when no summonses have been issued and no application for access to the supporting affidavit has been made.CONSIDERATIONLegal principles Atradius accepted that it bears the onus of satisfying the Court that the orders it seeks pursuant to s 37AF of the FC Act are necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice. Section 37AF of the FC Act provides that the Court has power to make a “suppression order or non‑publication order on grounds permitted by this Part”. The permitted grounds are set out in s 37AG: (1)The Court may make a suppression order or non‑publication order on one or more of the following grounds:(a)the order is necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice;(b) the order is necessary to prevent prejudice to the interests of the Commonwealth or a State or Territory in relation to national or international security;(c) the order is necessary to protect the safety of any person;(d)the order is necessary to avoid causing undue distress or embarrassment to a party to or witness in a criminal proceeding involving an offence of a sexual nature (including an act of indecency).(2)A suppression order or non‑publication order must specify the ground or grounds on which the order is made. While the parties cited different cases in their submissions, it was not in dispute that:(a)the orders sought can only be made if “necessary” to avoid prejudice to the proper administration of justice;(b)“necessary” is a strong word; (c)the determination of whether the orders sought should be made turns on whether they are necessary for the stated reason, and does not involve a balancing exercise, nor is the exercise of discretion involved; and(d)the Court must take into account that a primary objective of the administration of justice is to safeguard the public interest in open justice (s 37AE). The applicable principles are considered in further depth in cases including: Hogan v Australian Crime Commission (2010) 240 CLR 651 (Hogan) at [30]–[31] (French CJ, Gummow, Hayne, Heydon and Kiefel JJ); Sister Marie Brigid Arthur (Litigation Representative) v Northern Territory of Australia (No 2) [2020] FCA 215 at [9] (Murphy J); Motorola Solutions Inc v Hytera Communications Corporation Ltd (No 2) [2018] FCA 17 at [6] (Perram J); In-N-Out Burgers, Inc v Hashtag Burgers Pty Ltd (2020) 377 ALR 166; [2020] FCA 193 at [361] (Katzmann J) and the cases cited therein; Country Care Group Pty Ltd v Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions (No 2) (2020) 275 FCR 377 at [9] (Allsop CJ, Wigney and Abraham JJ).