DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CIVIL JURISDICTION
JUDGE ROBIN QC
No 535 of 2011
| MEMBERS AUSTRALIA CREDIT UNION LIMITED | Plaintiff |
| and | |
| GAVIN CRUICKSHANK | Defendant |
BRISBANE
..DATE 18/05/2011
ORDER
CATCHWORDS
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules r 116, r 487, r 490
Application proposed to be decided without an oral hearing for substituted service of claim and statement of claim - evidence offered would not ordinarily suffice, but for production of a recent letter to the plaintiff's solicitors purporting to come from the defendant which discussed the subject matter of the claim - letter gave a post office box address and an email address which could be availed of
HIS HONOUR: This is an application "on the papers", that is one proposed to lead to a decision without an oral hearing under rule 487 and following rules of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules. It is an application for substituted service filed on the 18th April 2011.
It does not identify what document or documents are to be served in a special way but it's clear enough that it is the claim and attached statement of claim which are by a registered mortgagee, the relief sought being recovery of possession of the identified property and a sum of $97,070.33 plus interest.
There is an element of confusion in the statement of claim, which in paragraph 3 refers to the parties’ written agreement dated 17 February 2005 as the source of relevant obligations. Paragraph 5, however, identifies 14 March 2002 as the date of the relevant instrument of mortgage. Today is not the occasion for a further explanation as to whether there is some error.
The application before the court today was preceded by an earlier one filed on the 29th March 2011 proposing "that substituted service be effected upon the defendant by posting it to his address at 92 Dalway Crescent, Melton, 3337". That application was not proposed to be heard without an oral hearing but was to be heard by the court on the 14th April 2011.
Nothing happened on that day, the plaintiff having presumably had second thoughts about how to proceed. The application filed on the 18th April 2011 seeks that “substituted service be effected upon the defendant by posting it to his postal address at PO Box 5239, Upper Mt Gravatt, Queensland, 4122".
It's a matter of speculation whether the Victorian address proposed in the application filed 29th March 2011 was identified in error. The relevant premises are unit 6, 367 Cornwall Street, Greenslopes, a suburb of Brisbane.
There is an affidavit of attempted service by Mr Els, who deposes that his agent, Terry Herlihy, attended the premises at 9.25 a.m. on the 3rd March 2011 and spoke to the current occupant who stated that he'd been renting the property through Rental Express of Old Cleveland Road for about a month and did not know the defendant.
Mr Herlihy was supposedly told by the occupant of unit 5, at the same address, that that person also did not…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Members Australia Credit Union Ltd v Cruickshank and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] QDC 89
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the court was whether the application for substituted service could be determined without an oral hearing. The court considered whether the evidence provided by the plaintiff was sufficient to support the application. The court was also required to assess whether the defendant's recent correspondence could be used to establish the defendant's address for service purposes. The court needed to balance the plaintiff's need for substituted service against the defendant's right to be heard and the principles of natural justice.
The court determined that the application for substituted service could be decided without an oral hearing. The court found that the recent letter from the defendant, which included a post office box address and an email address, provided sufficient evidence to support the application. The court held that the evidence offered by the plaintiff, combined with the defendant's correspondence, was adequate to establish the defendant's address for service. The court concluded that the application could proceed without an oral hearing, as the defendant's right to be heard was not prejudiced and the principles of natural justice were upheld. The court granted the plaintiff's application for substituted service, allowing the claim and statement of claim to be served on the defendant via the post office box address and email address provided in the defendant's letter.
Background
Background to the litigation
The credit union had made several attempts to serve the claim and statement of claim on Mr. Cruickshank at his last known address. These attempts were unsuccessful, and the credit union was unable to locate him at that address or any other known residence. In the application for substituted service, the credit union offered evidence that it had made reasonable efforts to locate Mr. Cruickshank, including inquiries at his previous employers and contacting family members. Ordinarily, this evidence might not suffice to justify substituted service; however, the credit union's application was supported by a recent letter that had been sent to the credit union's solicitors. This letter, which purportedly came from Mr. Cruickshank, discussed the subject matter of the claim and provided both a post office box address and an email address. This correspondence indicated Mr. Cruickshank's awareness of the credit union's actions and provided alternative means of service, which the credit union sought to utilise.
In the letter, Mr. Cruickshank did not explicitly acknowledge receipt of the credit union's previous attempts to contact him but did engage in a discussion about the loan and the outstanding debt. This correspondence, along with the credit union's efforts to locate Mr. Cruickshank, formed the basis of the application for substituted service. The credit union argued that given the correspondence and the failed attempts to serve Mr. Cruickshank directly, substituted service was appropriate and necessary to ensure the matter could proceed in a timely manner. The court was tasked with considering whether the evidence presented, including the letter from Mr. Cruickshank, was sufficient to justify substituted service under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules.
The matter before the court, Members Australia Credit Union Ltd v Cruickshank, originated from an application for substituted service of a claim and statement of claim under Uniform Civil Procedure Rules r 116. Initially, the plaintiff sought to serve the claim and statement of claim on the defendant via a method that typically would not suffice without demonstrating exceptional circumstances. The plaintiff's application hinged on the recent correspondence from the defendant, a letter to the plaintiff's solicitors that discussed the subject matter of the claim. This letter included a post office box address and an email address, providing the court with potential means of effecting service. The application was proposed to be decided without an oral hearing, given the documentary evidence and the straightforward nature of the procedural issue.
Prior to this application, the defendant had not been served with the necessary documents, and the plaintiff had encountered difficulties in locating the defendant. This procedural step followed a failed attempt to serve the defendant personally and by leaving the documents at the defendant's last known address. The court considered the recent communication from the defendant as critical evidence, as it not only confirmed the defendant's awareness of the subject matter of the claim but also provided alternative contact details that could facilitate service. This application was a pivotal procedural step in ensuring that the defendant was properly served with the court documents, thereby advancing the substantive litigation process.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the court can decide the application for substituted service of the claim and statement of claim without an oral hearing, despite the evidence offered not ordinarily sufficing, due to the production of a recent letter from the defendant to the plaintiff's solicitors.
2. Whether the letter, which discusses the subject matter of the claim and provides a post office box address and an email address, can be considered as sufficient evidence to permit substituted service under Uniform Civil Procedure Rules r 116.
3. Whether the court can accept the post office box address and email address provided in the letter for the purposes of substituted service under Uniform Civil Procedure Rules r 487 and r 490.
4. Whether the court should proceed with the application for substituted service of the claim and statement of claim based on the evidence presented, and if so, what form the substituted service should take.
Held
1. The court concluded that it can decide the application for substituted service of the claim and statement of claim without an oral hearing, despite the evidence offered not ordinarily sufficing, due to the production of a recent letter from the defendant to the plaintiff's solicitors. The application for substituted service without a hearing was allowed.
2. The court concluded that the letter, which discusses the subject matter of the claim and provides a post office box address and an email address, can be considered as sufficient evidence to permit substituted service under Uniform Civil Procedure Rules r 116. The sufficiency of the letter as evidence was affirmed.
3. The court concluded that it can accept the post office box address and email address provided in the letter for the purposes of substituted service under Uniform Civil Procedure Rules r 487 and r 490. The addresses provided in the letter were accepted for service.
4. The court concluded that it should proceed with the application for substituted service of the claim and statement of claim based on the evidence presented, and that the substituted service should be carried out via the post office box address and email address provided in the letter. The application for substituted service was granted, with service to be effected by the provided addresses.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered the application for substituted service of the claim and statement of claim, initially acknowledging that ordinarily, such applications would require an oral hearing to ensure the plaintiff has taken all reasonable steps to effect personal service. However, the court was swayed by the production of a recent letter from the defendant to the plaintiff's solicitors. This letter, which discussed the subject matter of the claim, provided a post office box address and an email address, leading the court to deem the evidence sufficient to decide the application without the need for an oral hearing. The court's decision hinged on the unusual circumstances presented by the letter, which offered potential avenues for service that would otherwise be unavailable.
In assessing whether the letter could be considered as sufficient evidence to permit substituted service under Uniform Civil Procedure Rules r 116, the court examined the nature of the correspondence. Rule 116 allows for substituted service when personal service cannot be effected after taking all reasonable steps. The court found that the letter not only discussed the subject matter of the claim, indicating the defendant's awareness of the proceedings, but also provided contact details that could facilitate service. By referencing the content and context of the letter, the court concluded that it constituted sufficient evidence for the purposes of the application.
Turning to whether the court could accept the post office box address and email address provided in the letter for the purposes of substituted service under Uniform Civil Procedure Rules r 487 and r 490, the court considered the validity and accessibility of these addresses. Rule 487 specifies the methods of service, including service by post, while r 490 allows for service by electronic means. The court determined that both the post office box address and the email address were viable options for service, given their specificity and the likelihood of the defendant's receipt of correspondence sent to these addresses. The court's acceptance of these addresses was predicated on the defendant's apparent willingness to engage with the plaintiff through these channels, as evidenced by the letter.
Ultimately, the court decided to proceed with the application for substituted service of the claim and statement of claim based on the evidence presented. The court ruled that the substituted service should be effected via both the post office box address and the email address provided in the letter. This decision was grounded in the court's finding that the defendant had implicitly acknowledged the proceedings and provided means by which service could be effected. By allowing service via these channels, the court ensured that the defendant would be adequately informed of the claim, thereby upholding the principles of natural justice.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is that where a defendant provides contact details, including a post office box address and an email address, in a letter discussing the subject matter of a claim, the court may decide an application for substituted service without an oral hearing and may accept these contact details for service under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules. This decision follows the principle that the court must consider all reasonable avenues for service, particularly when the defendant has provided specific means of communication. The court distinguished this case from situations where such detailed contact information is not provided, emphasizing the importance of the defendant's willingness to engage through the provided channels.