Mellor v Police No. Scciv-01-1158

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

MELLOR  v  POLICE

[2001] SASC 357

Nyland J

  1. This is an appeal against conviction and sentence.  The appellant was charge on information with assaulting Karl Lemberg on 15 July 1999 thereby occasioning him actual bodily harm.  On 18 April 2001, the appellant appeared in the Port Adelaide Magistrates Court with respect to the charge.  The appellant was unrepresented.  No plea was taken, but the learned magistrate advised the appellant that he was considering a custodial sentence and advised the appellant to obtain legal advice. 

  2. A written pre-sentence report was ordered with respect to sentence.  The matter was then remanded to 8 June 2001.  On that date, the appellant again appeared before the magistrate at which time he pleaded guilty to the offence.  He was sentenced to be imprisoned for a period of four months, which term was not suspended.  The appellant served a period of about two months custody before being released on home detention.

  3. A notice of appeal against sentence was filed by the appellant on 31 July 2001. Those grounds were subsequently amended on 23 August 2001 to include an appeal against conviction.  The grounds of appeal now before the court are as follows:

    “(1)In the circumstances the sentence imposed by the honourable Magistrates Court is excessive.           

    (a)    (deleted)

    (b)    The Appellant was engaged in employment.

    (c)   The Appellant had acted in self defence.

    (d)    Although the Appellant had a defence he elected to plead guilty without legal advice.  He was unrepresented in Court.

    (e)    At the time the Appellant committed the crime he was under emotional stress due to his father dying of cancer.

    (2)Insufficient weight was given to the above mitigating factors.

    (3)   In the circumstances a suspended sentence was warranted.

    (4)The Honourable Magistrate misstated the facts of the case as presented by the prosecution.  The misstatement was that the accused had earlier in the evening in question been refused entry into the hotel premises and then swore at and assaulted a member of the hotel staff.  This was incorrect.  According to the prosecution’s own evidence it was the alleged victim who had sworn at and assaulted the accused.  This fundamental error had serious repercussions in that:

    (a)    His Honour, with erroneous facts in mind, did not properly consider the issue of self defence when it was raised by the accused in court.

    (b)    His Honour, with erroneous facts in mind, was inclined to view the ensuing alleged assault as a more serious one than was otherwise the case.

    (5)The prosecution case was that the alleged victim had, earlier in the evening in question, pushed the accused.  The accused (who was unrepresented) told his Honour that the alleged victim had later come at him with a raised clenched fist and he had then reacted by hitting him.  This should have alerted his Honour to the issue of self defence but this issue was not adequately addressed.”

  4. On the hearing of the appeal, the appellant was represented by Mr Grogan of counsel and Mr Lesses appeared on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mellor v Police No. Scciv-01-1158 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] SASC 357
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant in Mellor v Police has appealed against his conviction and sentence for assaulting Karl Lemberg, an offence which resulted in the victim sustaining significant dental injuries. The appeal was heard by Nyland J in the Supreme Court of South Australia. The grounds of appeal included the severity of the sentence, the lack of consideration of mitigating factors, the absence of a suspended sentence, and an alleged misstatement of facts by the magistrate. The court was required to determine whether the magistrate's error in describing the events of the offence constituted a miscarriage of justice and whether the sentence imposed was appropriate.

The court found that while the magistrate had erred in describing the events of the offence, this did not constitute a miscarriage of justice. The court held that the appellant had been adequately informed of the possibility of a custodial sentence and given ample opportunity to obtain legal advice. The court further found that the magistrate had not erred in dismissing the defence of self-defence as the appellant's actions were objectively disproportionate to any perceived threat from the victim. The court also concluded that the sentence, while perhaps influenced by the magistrate's mischaracterisation of the offence, was appropriate given the seriousness of the assault and the appellant's prior conviction for a violent offence.

In conclusion, the appeal against conviction and sentence was dismissed. The court found no basis to interfere with the conviction or sentence, despite acknowledging that the magistrate's error in describing the circumstances of the offence was a factual misstep.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established