Melbourne Linh Son Buddhist Society Inc v Gippsreal Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

S APCI 2016 0132

MELBOURNE LINH SON BUDDHIST SOCIETY INC Applicant
v
GIPPSREAL LTD Respondent

---

JUDGES: MAXWELL P, KYROU JA and CAMERON AJA
WHERE HELD: MELBOURNE
DATE OF HEARING: 13 February 2017
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 23 June 2017
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: [2017] VSCA 161
JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM: Gippsreal Ltd v Melbourne Linh Son Buddhist Society Inc [2016] VSC 324 (Daly AsJ)

---

CONTRACT — Loan agreement — Whether applicant as borrower breached agreement by failing to settle within period nominated by respondent as lender — Whether period nominated was reasonable — Whether applicant’s failure to settle was for reasons beyond control of lender — Applicant not in breach and lender not entitled to terminate agreement — Appeal allowed.

CONTRACT — Construction of commercial contract — Whether amount specified for establishment fee ambiguous — Whether evidence of surrounding circumstances admissible — Amount not ambiguous.

CONTRACT — Penalties — Relevant principles — Amount claimed for establishment fee had no connection with alleged breach of contract and remained the same notwithstanding significant decrease in quantum of loan — Establishment fee constituted a penalty.

CONTRACT — Set off — Whether commitment fees paid by applicant for aborted loans must be set off against amounts claimed by respondent under a subsequent loan agreement — Set off not available.

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors
For the Applicant Mr P T Kelly Starnet Legal
For the Respondent Mr S K Morris Oakleys Legal

MAXWELL P:

  1. I have had the considerable advantage of reading in draft the joint reasons for judgment of Kyrou JA and Cameron AJA.  For the reasons which their Honours give, I too would grant leave to appeal and allow the appeal.  As appears from their Honours’ comprehensive analysis, the point of decision in the appeal is that, contrary to the finding of the primary judge, the respondent was not entitled to withdraw the offer of finance which it had made to the applicant and had no entitlement to claim liquidated damages.[1]

    [1]See [114], [126], [217] below.

  1. As their Honours point out, the applicant’s success on the principal grounds of appeal makes it unnecessary to decide the other grounds advanced.[2]  Nevertheless, for completeness, their Honours have addressed each of the alternative grounds.[3]  With one exception, I respectfully agree with the conclusions which their Honours have reached on those other grounds.

    [2]See [136] below.

    [3]See [137]–[215] below.

  1. The exception concerns the question raised by grounds 5 and 6, namely, whether the establishment fee of $26,625 specified in the loan documentation was a penalty.  Their Honours have concluded that it was.  For reasons which follow, I consider that there is insufficient evidence before the Court to enable that question to be answered.

  1. I gratefully adopt their Honours’ description of the sequence of events leading up to the respondent’s final offer of a loan of $500,000.  The establishment fee of $26,625 had not changed from that fixed previously, when the respondent had offered a loan of $1,775,000. 

  1. The 2016 decision of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Melbourne Linh Son Buddhist Society Inc v Gippsreal Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] VSCA 161
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Melbourne Linh Son Buddhist Society Inc. (the Applicant) appealed against the decision of the County Court, arguing that Gippsreal Ltd. (the Respondent) was not entitled to terminate their loan agreement on the basis that the Applicant had failed to settle the loan within the period nominated by the Respondent. The Applicant further contended that the period nominated by the Respondent was unreasonable and that its failure to settle was beyond the control of the Respondent. The Applicant also argued that the amount specified for the establishment fee was ambiguous and that the evidence of surrounding circumstances should be admissible to determine its meaning. Additionally, the Applicant claimed that the establishment fee constituted a penalty and that commitment fees paid for aborted loans should be set off against amounts claimed by the Respondent under a subsequent loan agreement.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the Applicant breached the loan agreement by failing to settle within the period nominated by the Respondent, whether the nominated period was reasonable, and whether the Applicant’s failure to settle was due to reasons beyond the control of the Respondent. The court also had to determine whether the amount specified for the establishment fee was ambiguous and if evidence of surrounding circumstances was admissible to interpret it. Furthermore, the court needed to decide whether the establishment fee constituted a penalty and whether the Applicant was entitled to set off the commitment fees paid for aborted loans against amounts claimed by the Respondent under a subsequent loan agreement.

The court held that the Applicant had not breached the loan agreement and that the Respondent was not entitled to terminate it. The period nominated by the Respondent was deemed unreasonable, and the Applicant’s failure to settle was due to reasons beyond the control of the Respondent. The amount specified for the establishment fee was not ambiguous, and evidence of surrounding circumstances was not admissible to interpret it. The establishment fee was found to constitute a penalty, and set off was not available to the Applicant for the commitment fees paid for aborted loans against amounts claimed by the Respondent under a subsequent loan agreement. Consequently, the appeal was allowed.

The final orders of the court were not explicitly stated in the text, but it can be inferred that the decision in favour of the Applicant resulted in the termination of the loan agreement being set aside, and the establishment fee being deemed a penalty, with the Applicant potentially being entitled to recover any overpaid fees.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established