Meland Holdings Pty Ltd v Saunders & Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

MELAND HOLDINGS PTY LTD v SAUNDERS & ANOR

[2024] SASC 27

Reasons for Decision of Judge Dart a Master of the Supreme Court  

REAL PROPERTY - TORRENS TITLE - CAVEATS AGAINST DEALINGS - WHO MAY LODGE AND WHAT INTEREST SUFFICIENT - GENERALLY

Applicant and respondents entered into letters of offer - subject matter of those documents is the sale and purchase of land - further documents anticipated - applicant lodged caveats - respondents warn the caveats - application for an extension - respondents say no binding agreement - applicant makes out serious question to be tried - caveats extended.

Held:

1. Time for removal of the caveats is extended.

2. Applicant to file a statement of claim.

Real Property Act 1886 (SA) s 191, referred to.
Adderley v Dixon (1824) 1 Sim & St 607; Harry v Fidelity Nominees Pty Ltd (1985) 41 SASR 458; Masters v Cameron (1954) 91 CLR 353; Nexus Mortgage Securities v Mawson KLM Holdings & Starmaker (No 51) Pty Ltd SCGRG-97-364, Judgment No S6347; Pua Hor Ong & Ors v Wu You Yang Pty Ltd & Ors [2008] SASC 365; Toll (FGCT) Pty Ltd v Alphapharm Pty Ltd (2004) 219 CLR 165, considered.

MELAND HOLDINGS PTY LTD v SAUNDERS & ANOR
[2024] SASC 27

  1. This is an application to extend the time for the removal of two caveats. I made an order extending time for removal and directed the applicant to file a statement of claim so the matter can be progressed on an expedited basis. These are my brief reasons for doing so.

    Background

  2. The applicant, by its sole director, signed two documents headed “Letter of Offer” on or about 15 December 2022. One of the documents related to land owned by the first respondent and the other relates to land owned by the second respondent. The two documents have the same structure but do have some different terms.

  3. In relation to the first respondent, it was proposed that he would sell the identified land to the applicant for the sum of $10,400,000 (GST exclusive). A draft contract of sale was attached to the Letter of Offer. It was anticipated that the applicant would have a 60 day due diligence period from execution of the contract of sale and that, at the end of that period, the applicant could either terminate the contract or pay the deposit. The deposit was fixed in the amount of $2,320,000 (GST exclusive). The agreement provided that the deposit was non-refundable and upon payment could be used by the first respondent for his own purposes. A settlement period of 72 months from the date of execution of the contract of sale was provided for.

  4. The second respondent agreed to sell the identified land to the applicant for the sum of $12,800,000 (GST exclusive). In relation to this contract, it was intended that a put and call option agreement would be signed. A draft of that document was attached to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Meland Holdings Pty Ltd v Saunders & Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] SASC 27
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Meland Holdings Pty Ltd applied for an extension of time to remove two caveats against land owned by the respondents, Saunders. The court heard arguments on the binding nature of the Letters of Offer signed by the parties and the necessity for an undertaking as to damages in interlocutory injunctions. The central legal issue was whether the Letters of Offer constituted binding contracts for the sale and purchase of the land, and if so, whether the caveats could be removed and the matter expedited.

The court considered the plain language of clause 7 in the Letters of Offer, which stated that the offer was executed as a deed and legally binding for both parties. The court found that this clause indicated an intention to create legal relations, sufficient to establish a serious question to be tried at an interlocutory stage. The court also noted that no issues of sufficient weight arose in relation to the balance of convenience, making it appropriate to extend the time for removal of the caveats and to expedite the matter to trial.

In light of the above, the court granted the application to extend the time for the removal of the caveats and directed the applicant to file a statement of claim to expedite the matter. The court considered it appropriate to expedite the matter to trial due to the serious question as to the binding nature of the Letters of Offer.

The court's final orders included an extension of time for the removal of the caveats and a direction for the applicant to file a statement of claim to expedite the matter to trial.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an application to extend the time for the removal of two caveats. I made an order extending time for removal and directed the applicant to file a statement of claim so the matter can be progressed on an expedited basis. These are my brief reasons for doing so. Background The applicant, by its sole director, signed two documents headed “Letter of Offer” on or about 15 December 2022. One of the documents related to land owned by the first respondent and the other relates to land owned by the second respondent. The two documents have the same structure but do have some different terms. In relation to the first respondent, it was proposed that he would sell the identified land to the applicant for the sum of $10,400,000 (GST exclusive). A draft contract of sale was attached to the Letter of Offer. It was anticipated that the applicant would have a 60 day due diligence period from execution of the contract of sale and that, at the end of that period, the applicant could either terminate the contract or pay the deposit. The deposit was fixed in the amount of $2,320,000 (GST exclusive). The agreement provided that the deposit was non-refundable and upon payment could be used by the first respondent for his own purposes. A settlement period of 72 months from the date of execution of the contract of sale was provided for. The second respondent agreed to sell the identified land to the applicant for the sum of $12,800,000 (GST exclusive). In relation to this contract, it was intended that a put and call option agreement would be signed. A draft of that document was attached to the Letter of Offer. The put option provided that it was to be exercised within three years. The agreement also provided that settlement would be three years from the exercise of the option. Each of the Letters of Offer referred to the other and each contains a term that both contracts must settle at the same time. Again, a deposit of $2,320,000 (GST exclusive) was provided for and again upon payment the money was able to be utilised by the second respondent. The first sentence of each Letter of Offer is as follows:The parties agree that the Vendor shall sell to the Purchaser who shall purchase from the Vendor the Property on the terms below: (description of land and price) Each of the Letters of Offer contains clause 7 which is in the following terms:This offer is executed as a deed and legally binding for both parties. The vendor may withdraw this offer any time before the vendor signs. Each of the vendors signed their respective Letter of Offer on or about 21 December 2022. Since the Letters of Offer were executed by the parties, there have been discussions about amending the contract of sale of land in relation to the first matter and the terms of the put and call option agreement in relation to the second. The applicant says that the respondents stopped communicating, after the applicant understood that all terms of the additional documents had been agreed. It says the respondents have refused to provide execution copies for the applicant to sign. The respondents dispute the applicant’s version of events.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As an aside, it is curious that an undertaking as to damages is required. It arises because of the treating of this type of application as equivalent to an interlocutory injunction. The practice is well-established and it is not for a single judge to depart from the practice. I note that s 191(1)(j) provides a statutory power to award compensation for a caveat lodged wrongfully and without reasonable cause. It is not clear that an undertaking as to damages adds to the right to compensation. Conclusion I am satisfied that the applicant has established a serious question in relation to whether or not the Letters of Offer are binding contracts for the sale and purchase of the land. On their face, they appear to be. The wording of clause 7 of each Letter of Offer indicates that the parties intended the document to be legally binding. That is sufficient, at an interlocutory stage, to establish that there is a serious question to be tried. No issues of sufficient weight arise in relation to the balance of convenience. It is appropriate to extend the time for the removal of the caveats. The progress of the matter to trial should be expedited.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.