Medlin v Nominal Defendant

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Medlin v Nominal Defendant [2021] QSC 186

PARTIES:

DARREN GEORGE MEDLIN

(Plaintiff)

v
NOMINAL DEFENDANT

(Defendant)

FILE NO/S:

RS 463 of 2017

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Trial

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Rockhampton

DELIVERED ON:

5 August 2021

DELIVERED AT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

3, 4 and 11 December 2020

JUDGE:

Brown J

ORDER:

The order of the Court is that:

1.   The claim is dismissed; and

2.   The parties are to provide written submissions as to costs within 14 days.

CATCHWORDS:

TORTS – NEGLIGENCE – DUTY OF CARE: EXISTENCE

TORTS – NEGLGIENCE – OTHER PARTICULAR CLAIMANTS, DEFENDANTS AND CIRCUMSTANCES – ROAD ACCIDENTS  

Where the Plaintiff was driving a utility and collided with another vehicle – where the circumstances of the collision were the subject of controversy – where the Plaintiff alleges the crash was caused by an unidentified red vehicle – whether the Plaintiff was following a red vehicle that swerved late and dangerously – whether the unidentified red vehicle owed the Plaintiff a duty of care

Civil Liability Act 2003 (Qld) ss 11, 22, 23, 24

Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298, cited
Kerle v BM Alliance Coal Operations Pty Ltd & Ors (2016) 262 IR 381; [2016] QSC 304, cited
Nguyen v Cosmopolitan Homes (NSW) Pty Ltd [2008] NSWCA 246, cited
Pell v R (2020) 94 ALJR 394, cited

COUNSEL:

M T O’Sullivan for the Plaintiff
G O’Driscoll for the Defendant

SOLICITORS:

Shine Lawyers for the Plaintiff
Jensen McConaghy Lawyers for the Defendant

  1. On 1 December 2014 Darren Medlin, the plaintiff, was driving home to Yeppoon, along Yeppoon Road in his Toyota Hilux.  He collided with the back of a white Ford Falcon utility, driven by Hayden Finn.  The Ford Falcon was waiting to turn right into the driveway of 1600 Yeppoon Road.  Hayden Finn’s mother, Ms Sharon Finn, was a passenger in the Ford Falcon. Mr Medlin suffered severe injuries.  Hayden Finn and Ms Finn were also injured.

  2. The circumstances in which the collision occurred are the subject of significant controversy, which this Court must determine.  In particular, the plaintiff alleges that the accident was caused by an unidentified red vehicle violently swerving to the left, without warning, in front of the Toyota Hilux.  The red vehicle is said not to have stopped at the accident and left the scene.  As a result of the red vehicle not being identified, the defendant in the present action is the Nominal Defendant. The Nominal Defendant disputes that there was any red vehicle involved in the accident which occurred. 

  3. If the threshold issue of whether there is a red car is determined in favour of the plaintiff, the parties are in dispute about all aspects of liability. The plaintiff contends that the red car was negligent in a number of ways. The Nominal Defendant denies that the driver of the red car owed a duty of care to the plaintiff which extended to it driving in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Medlin v Nominal Defendant and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QSC 186
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Medlin v Nominal Defendant, the plaintiff, Mr Medlin, sought to hold the defendant responsible for an accident involving his vehicle and another. The crux of the dispute was whether the defendant, who was driving a red vehicle, was negligent and owed a duty of care to Mr Medlin. Mr Medlin alleged that the accident was caused by the defendant’s vehicle swerving dangerously, but the identity of the driver and vehicle remained unidentified. The case was heard in the relevant Australian court, which was tasked with determining the existence of a duty of care and whether negligence on the part of the unidentified driver contributed to the accident.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the unidentified driver of the red vehicle owed a duty of care to Mr Medlin. Secondary issues included the specific circumstances leading to the collision and whether there was sufficient evidence to identify the driver of the red vehicle. The court needed to assess whether the unidentified driver could have reasonably foreseen that their actions might harm Mr Medlin and whether there were any mitigating factors that could negate a duty of care.

The court found that there was insufficient evidence to identify the driver of the red vehicle, and the critical issues were largely agreed upon by the parties. Given the absence of direct evidence or submissions regarding the identity of the driver, the court did not address this matter further. The court concluded that Mr Medlin’s account of the events leading to the accident was credible, but it did not find that another vehicle in front of Mr Medlin had swerved, causing the collision. Therefore, the court dismissed the claim, ruling that the defendant was not liable for the accident.

The final orders of the court were that the claim against the defendant was dismissed and that the parties were to submit written costs within 14 days. This ruling underscores the necessity of clear evidence in establishing liability in negligence cases, particularly when the identity of the alleged tortfeasor is unknown.

Orders

Orders of the court

The order of the Court is that:

1. The claim is dismissed; and

2. The parties are to provide written submissions as to costs within 14 days.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

While the defendant denied that the red vehicle could not be identified despite proper enquiry and search being made by the plaintiff, that ultimately was not a matter the subject of any evidence or submissions at trial. Given the critical issues were agreed between the parties, and it was not the subject of evidence or submission, I will not address that matter further. Summary of Evidence It is uncontentious that the accident between the Finns’ vehicle and Mr Medlin’s vehicle occurred at approximately 3.15pm. The conditions were dry and fine. The stretch of Yeppoon Road where the accident took place was a straight road with two lanes separated by a painted, dotted centre line. Each lane was approximately 3.5 metres wide, bordered by painted continuous “fog” lines. The bitumen shoulders beyond the “fog” lines of each side of the roadway were 1.3 metres wide. There were gravel shoulders extending approximately 3.5 metres on each side of the road beyond the bitumen. The collision occurred outside 1600 Yeppoon Road which was the property where the Finns resided. There was an overtaking lane which merged into a single lane approximately 1.3 kilometres from the entry to 1600 Yeppoon Road. At 1600 Yeppoon Road there was a gravel driveway from the road. It was on the opposite side of the highway from the lane in which Mr Medlin was travelling. Photographic evidence was tendered of Yeppoon Road in the vicinity of the accident, including the highway travelling towards Yeppoon and Rockhampton, as well as the entry to 1600 Yeppoon Rd. According to the witnesses to whom the photos were shown, the state of the road is largely unchanged from what it was at the time of the accident. The plaintiff called two factual witnesses in relation to the circumstances in which the accident occurred, Darren Medlin and Jason Spence. Jason Spence was travelling in the opposite direction to Darren Medlin along Yeppoon Road, towards Rockhampton, at the time the accident occurred. Darren Medlin On the day in question, Mr Medlin was travelling home to Yeppoon from Rockhampton. He had commenced a new role with a government department some four months prior. He and his family had moved to Yeppoon.[6] He was familiar with the route from Rockhampton to Yeppoon, particularly Yeppoon Road. He had travelled on Yeppoon Road many times, including when he grew up in Rockhampton. Thus, he was familiar with Yeppoon Road and the area where the accident occurred.[6]His family had moved to Yeppoon slightly earlier than Mr Medlin. Darren Medlin described the circumstances leading up to the accident as follows: “Right. Now, let’s deal with the journey on Yeppoon Road. Tell us what you recall of that journey prior to the accident? I was – I was just travelling home. Pretty – pretty excited because I’d been working towards this – this job at the department for some years. You know, the traffic conditions were fine. It was – on that sort of a day there’s a lot of traffic to and from Yeppoon. So I was – I was travelling predominantly in the left lane. It’s a – it’s a two – it’s a two lane section of road for half the journey. Nearly half. I was overtaken by numerous cars. As I said, I was pretty – pretty excited with my new appointment and very proud of the fact being in public service. So I was very conscious. I set my speed control at about 98 kilometres an hour. Just continued travelling home. So there’s one more intersection that you come to. There’s a set of lights. There’s some other vehicles that come out on the – from that entry point onto the highway. Just continued home like a normal sort of journey. I was travelling behind a red car. I was keeping my distance. My safe distance. As we were approaching the – the overtaking lanes, just probably around halfway home, I disengaged my – my cruise control, because the traffic congestion was getting a bit heavier. I stayed in the left lane. Continued to follow me red car. Just kept off him. We come back out onto the single lane, and I continued behind that vehicle. As we were approaching, there’s a couple of farms on the right-hand side. Down to the left-hand side there’s – it was a point known as Mount Jim Crow. So I was – I was on and off the brakes. You know, we were only going between 85 and 95. It was slow – slow down. Speed up. Slow down. Then as I was getting closer towards – there’s a – there’s an earthworks business on the right-hand side. There’s a property, and there’s a horse place. I was looking down the highway at – just having a look at why the traffic was slowing down, and I then had a – the – the red car that I was following sort of violently ripped it off to the left-hand side of the road, and I had brought my attention directly straight back in front of my car. I then seen the white – white bumper bar, back of a white car, as I’ve – as I’ve hit the brakes and turned the steering wheel. That’s – that’s what I can remember. The – this white flash, and then the crushing of the windscreen”[7][7]Plaintiff’s Outline of Argument, [43].

Decision

Reasons for decision

Given my answer, it is unnecessary to deal with the remaining issues which the parties identified.Conclusion I do not find that there was another vehicle in front of Mr Medlin behind the Ford Falcon utility which swerved to the left, causing Mr Medlin to collide with the Ford Falcon utility. I will therefore dismiss the claim. I will list the matter at a date convenient to the parties for submissions to be made as to costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.