Medical Board of Australia v Doolabh

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read
CITATION: Medical Board of Australia v Doolabh [2014] QCAT 582
PARTIES: Medical Board of Australia
(Applicant)
v
Dr Bharat Doolabh
(Respondent)
APPLICATION NUMBER:   OCR284-11
MATTER TYPE: Occupational regulation matters
HEARING DATE: 4 November 2014
HEARD AT: Brisbane
DECISION OF:

Judge Rafter SC

Assisted by:
Dr Sandra Congdon
Mr Kai Dahl
Dr Stephen Pozzi

DELIVERED ON: 4 November 2014  
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane

ORDERS MADE:    

1.     The Tribunal finds that the Registrant has behaved in a way that constitutes unsatisfactory professional conduct pursuant to section 124(1)(a) of the Health Practitioner (Disciplinary Proceedings) Act 1999.

2.     The Registrant is reprimanded.

3.     The Registrant's registration is suspended for a period of 12 months from 12 May 2011.

4.     The following conditions are to be imposed on the Registrant's registration:

The practitioner must only practise in a position approved by the Board; (a)   

The practitioner’s specialist practice is limited to surgical assisting in gynaecology and surgical assisting with caesarean section;(b)   

Otherwise, the practitioner will only work as an assistant to a consultant medical practitioner approved by the Board in advance; (c)   

The practitioner must notify the Board in writing, for approval, of any medical practitioner he proposes to work with either as a specialist or a surgical assistant, including:(d)   

the name and address of the employer;(i)    

the address of the practitioner’s place of employment as a medical practitioner; and(ii)   

the practitioner’s position description at the place of employment;(iii)   

The role of an assistant for the purposes of condition (c) is defined to include:(e)  

assisting a consultant surgeon, subject to the constant and continuous supervision and direction of that consultant surgeon;(i)    

the consultant surgeon will remain present throughout the provision of the assistance; and(ii)   

the assistant must not be involved in the personal dissection of tissue or the application of suture material;(iii)   

The practitioner will allow a representative of the Board to inspect/take or copy the clinical records of his patients, his appointment diary or diaries, at such time or times as the Board or its delegated representative shall determine for the purpose of monitoring compliance with these conditions.(f)   

The practitioner will provide the Board, at his own expense, a copy of the clinical records of patients nominated by the Board, his appointment diaries at such time or times as the Board or its delegated representative shall determine for the purpose of monitoring compliance with these conditions.(g)    

Within seven (7) days of the conditions being imposed, the practitioner will notify all partners/employers/employees/colleagues in his practice and every person who is, or may be, responsible for booking consultations with the practitioner of these conditions.(h)    

Within seven (7) days of the conditions being imposed, the practitioner will, notify the Board of the name of each person the practitioner notified of these conditions pursuant to condition (h).(i)   

The practitioner will notify the Board within seven (7) days of any change in any of the circumstances referred to in (d)(i) to (d)(iii) above.(j)   

The practitioner authorises Medicare Australia to provide information to the Board about his practice of medicine to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Medical Board of Australia v Doolabh and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] QCAT 582
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Medical Board of Australia brought disciplinary proceedings against a medical practitioner, Dr Doolabh, concerning his conduct during two separate obstetric deliveries that resulted in the deaths of two babies. The Board alleged that Dr Doolabh engaged in unsatisfactory professional conduct by failing to examine and review the labour during the first delivery, not proceeding to immediate assisted delivery, failing to provide advice and direction, and not arranging a paediatrician. In the second delivery, Dr Doolabh failed to arrange a paediatrician. The Board and Dr Doolabh agreed on the sanction to be imposed, including conditions on his registration and a 12-month suspension of his registration.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the 12-month suspension of Dr Doolabh's registration could be backdated to the date of his initial suspension. The court needed to consider the statutory framework governing disciplinary proceedings and the interpretation of the relevant provisions. The court also needed to determine whether the agreed sanction was in the public interest and appropriate in the circumstances of the case.

The court found that Dr Doolabh's conduct constituted unsatisfactory professional conduct and that the agreed sanction was appropriate. The court noted that the parties had agreed to the sanction, which included conditions on Dr Doolabh's registration and a 12-month suspension. The court held that the suspension could not be backdated as it would have the effect of punishing Dr Doolabh twice for the same conduct, which would be unjust. The court also noted that the suspension was intended to protect the public and maintain public confidence in the medical profession. The court imposed the conditions on Dr Doolabh's registration, including limiting his specialist practice to surgical assisting in gynaecology and surgical assisting with caesarean section, and requiring him to notify the Board of any medical practitioner he proposes to work with. The court also ordered that the reprimand be recorded on the Board's register for a period of 12 months and that Dr Doolabh pay the Board's costs.

In summary, the court found that Dr Doolabh's conduct constituted unsatisfactory professional conduct and that the agreed sanction was appropriate. The court held that the 12-month suspension of Dr Doolabh's registration could not be backdated and imposed the conditions on his registration as agreed. The court also ordered that the reprimand be recorded on the Board's register for a period of 12 months and that Dr Doolabh pay the Board's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Tribunal finds that the Registrant has behaved in a way that constitutes unsatisfactory professional conduct pursuant to section 124(1)(a) of the Health Practitioner (Disciplinary Proceedings) Act 1999.

2. The Registrant is reprimanded.

3. The Registrant's registration is suspended for a period of 12 months from 12 May 2011.

4. The following conditions are to be imposed on the Registrant's registration:

The practitioner must only practise in a position approved by the Board; (a)

The practitioner’s specialist practice is limited to surgical assisting in gynaecology and surgical assisting with caesarean section;(b)

Otherwise, the practitioner will only work as an assistant to a consultant medical practitioner approved by the Board in advance; (c)

The practitioner must notify the Board in writing, for approval, of any medical practitioner he proposes to work with either as a specialist or a surgical assistant, including:(d)

the name and address of the employer;(i)

the address of the practitioner’s place of employment as a medical practitioner; and(ii)

the practitioner’s position description at the place of employment;(iii)

The role of an assistant for the purposes of condition (c) is defined to include:(e)

assisting a consultant surgeon, subject to the constant and continuous supervision and direction of that consultant surgeon;(i)

the consultant surgeon will remain present throughout the provision of the assistance; and(ii)

the assistant must not be involved in the personal dissection of tissue or the application of suture material;(iii)

The practitioner will allow a representative of the Board to inspect/take or copy the clinical records of his patients, his appointment diary or diaries, at such time or times as the Board or its delegated representative shall determine for the purpose of monitoring compliance with these conditions.(f)

The practitioner will provide the Board, at his own expense, a copy of the clinical records of patients nominated by the Board, his appointment diaries at such time or times as the Board or its delegated representative shall determine for the purpose of monitoring compliance with these conditions.(g)

Within seven (7) days of the conditions being imposed, the practitioner will notify all partners/employers/employees/colleagues in his practice and every person who is, or may be, responsible for booking consultations with the practitioner of these conditions.(h)

Within seven (7) days of the conditions being imposed, the practitioner will, notify the Board of the name of each person the practitioner notified of these conditions pursuant to condition (h).(i)

The practitioner will notify the Board within seven (7) days of any change in any of the circumstances referred to in (d)(i) to (d)(iii) above.(j)

The practitioner authorises Medicare Australia to provide information to the Board about his practice of medicine to monitor compliance with these conditions.(k)

The practitioner authorises insurance funds to provide a list of patients who have submitted claims in order to pay for treatment rendered by him.(l)

5. The review period for the conditions is two and a half years.

6. Details of the reprimand are to be recorded on the Board's register for a period of 12 months.

7. The Registrant must pay the Board's costs as agreed or assessed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established