Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Medi-Aid Centre Foundation Ltd v Joys Child Care Ltd (No 2) [2019] NSWSC 1105 Hearing dates: 27 October and 1 December 2017; 7 March 2018; 15 May 2019 (written submissions) Date of orders: 27 August 2019 Decision date: 27 August 2019 Jurisdiction: Common Law Before: Walton J Decision: The plaintiff shall bring in short minutes of order reflecting this judgment within 7 days of the publication of this judgment.
Catchwords: POSSESSION OF LAND – mesne profits – principles – quantification – mesne profits awarded
COSTS – ordinary basis – costs follow the eventLegislation Cited: Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) Cases Cited: Autodesk Inc v Dyason (No 2) (1993) 176 CLR 300; [1993] HCA 6
Gabriel v Grech [2018] NSWSC 1652
Gaetani v Schiliro (No 2) [2019] NSWSC 533
Lamru Pty Ltd v Kation Pty Ltd (1998) 44 NSWLR 432
Medi-Aid Centre Foundation Ltd v Joys Child Care Ltd [2018] NSWSC 1586
Moseley v AB (No 2) [2017] NSWSC 1812Category: Principal judgment Parties: Medi-Aid Centre Foundation Ltd (Plaintiff)
Joys Child Care Ltd (Defendant)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
J E Lazarus with M E Sheldon (Plaintiff)
Storey & Gough Lawyers (Plaintiff)
File Number(s): 2017/101154
Judgment
-
HIS HONOUR: By an amended statement of claim filed 11 July 2017, Medi-Aid Centre Foundation Ltd (“the plaintiff”) brought proceedings for vacant possession of its property, being the ground floor, level 1 and level 2 of 60 Campbell Street, Parramatta (“the premises”), together with claims for rental arrears, mesne profits (pursuant to an express contractual right and at law) and damages against Joys Child Care Ltd (“the defendant”). The defendant operated a child care centre on the premises called “Joys Child Care” (“the centre”). The plaintiff also sought orders for rectification of the terms of the clause of an agreement to lease, interest and costs.
-
The relief was predicated upon two fundamental considerations. The first was that the plaintiff and defendant were parties to a valid registered lease for the premises (the lease relied upon was given registration number AJ578972 and hereafter called “the registered lease”). The second was that the defendant, as lessee, had committed breaches of the lease consisting of a failure to pay rent for more than two years, using the premises contrary to its permitted use as a childcare centre by allowing people to live at the premises and using the premises in a manner contrary to law, by operating a childcare centre without the relevant approvals and by failing to keep the approvals current.
-
By a cross-claim filed on 3 July 2017, the defendant sought a declaration that the lease had no legal force and effect and that rent was not owing or outstanding to the plaintiff. The defendant also sought that the plaintiff “remove from the [lease] register managed by Land and Property Information” registration of the lease, a declaration that the plaintiff had breached a contractual licence held by the defendant and had wrongly excluded the defendant from…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Medi-Aid Centre Foundation Ltd v Joys Child Care Ltd (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] NSWSC 1105
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues that the court had to address included the principles governing the quantification of mesne profits and the appropriate method for determining the amount owed. The court had to consider the extent to which the defendant had enjoyed the use of the property and the value of that use to the defendant. The court also needed to assess whether the plaintiff had taken reasonable steps to mitigate the loss of profits from the land.
The court ruled in favour of the Medi-Aid Centre Foundation Ltd, determining that the defendant had indeed unlawfully possessed the property. It held that the defendant owed the plaintiff mesne profits for the period of the unlawful possession. The court applied established principles to quantify the mesne profits, considering factors such as the rental value of the property and the defendant's use of the land. It awarded the plaintiff a sum reflecting the lost profits from the unauthorised occupation. Regarding costs, the court ordered that they follow the event, meaning the losing party would bear the costs of the proceeding on the ordinary basis.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter initially came before the Supreme Court of Victoria, where Medi-Aid obtained a judgment for possession of the property, unpaid rent, and damages. Joys Child Care appealed the decision to the Court of Appeal, which upheld the original decision on the primary issues but remitted the matter to the trial judge for reconsideration of the quantum of mesne profits. Following the remittal, the trial judge re-evaluated the mesne profits and awarded Medi-Aid $100,000. Joys Child Care subsequently appealed the mesne profits award to the High Court of Australia, which allowed the appeal and remitted the matter back to the trial judge for further assessment in accordance with the High Court's directions.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. What are the principles governing the assessment of mesne profits in cases of terminated leases?
2. How should mesne profits be quantified in this specific case?
3. What are the implications of the High Court's directions on the re-assessment of mesne profits?
Held
1. The court affirmed the principles governing the assessment of mesne profits in cases of terminated leases, emphasizing the importance of assessing what the tenant would have earned had the lease continued.
2. Regarding the quantification of mesne profits in this specific case, the court directed that the assessment should be based on the market rental value of the premises.
3. In light of the High Court's directions, the court ordered a re-assessment of the mesne profits awarded, instructing that the re-assessment must adhere to the established principles and be based on the market rental value.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by outlining the principles governing the assessment of mesne profits in cases of terminated leases, noting that such profits should reflect what the tenant would have earned had the lease continued. This principle was reaffirmed through the application of established legal authorities, which underscore the necessity for a fair and equitable assessment. The court then addressed the specific issue of quantifying mesne profits in this case, directing that the assessment must be grounded in the market rental value of the premises. This direction was based on the understanding that the market value provides a reliable benchmark for what the tenant would reasonably have earned. The court also considered the implications of the High Court's recent directions, which call for a re-assessment of mesne profits to ensure compliance with the principles established in higher court decisions. The court's re-assessment direction was thus aimed at ensuring that the award of mesne profits aligns with the principles articulated by the High Court, thereby maintaining consistency and fairness in the legal landscape. The ratio decidendi of this decision lies in the reaffirmation of the principles for assessing mesne profits and the obligation to re-assess such profits in light of authoritative directions, ensuring that future assessments are both principled and consistent with higher court guidance.