MEC Resources Ltd and Industry Innovation and Science Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 61 min read

MEC Resources Ltd and Industry Innovation and Science Australia [2023] AATA 399 (15 March 2023)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:          2021/3080

Re:MEC Resources Ltd

APPLICANT

AndIndustry Innovation and Science Australia

RESPONDENT

Decision

Tribunal:Deputy President Boyle

Date:15 March 2023

Place:Perth

The Respondent’s decision of 23 April 2021 to affirm a decision of 3 February 2021 under s 47 of the Pooled Development Funds Act 1992 (Cth) to revoke the Applicant’s Pooled Development Fund registration declaration is set aside and in substitution it is decided not to revoke the Applicant’s Pool Development Fund registration declaration under s 47 of the Pooled Development Funds Act 1992 (Cth).

...............[Sgd].........................................................

Deputy President Boyle

Catchwords

POOLED DEVELOPMENT FUNDS - Pooled Development Funds Act 1992 - Revocation of registration declaration under s 47(1) – ultimate sanction of revocation of registration not appropriate – claimed breaches do not subvert the objects of the Act – no other power applicable in present case – breaches occurred when Applicant under different management – procedures for compliance now in place – procedural fairness –ground for cancellation argued not referred to in SFIC - revocation order set aside and substituted

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) ss 37, 41(2)

Industry Research and Development Act 1986 (Cth) ss 6, 21(2)

Pooled Development Funds Act 1992 (Cth) ss 3, 4, 10, 11, 14(1), 18, 19, 19(1), 19(2), 20A, 20A(2), 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 25(1), 26, 27, 27A, 28, 28(2A), 33, 35, 35(1), 35(4), 42, 42(2), 42(2)(a), 42(3)(a), 46(2), 47, 47(1)(a), 47(3)(a), 55, 56

Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (Cth) ss 60-125(2)

Venture Capital Act 2002 (Cth)

Cases

Austcorp No 500 Pty Ltd v Innovation Australia [2010] AATA 270

Bartlett v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2003) 54 ATR 261

Evans v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1989) 89 ATC 4540

MEC Resources Ltd and Innovation and Science Australia [2021] AATA 4030

Rio Tinto Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation [2004] FCA 335

Saffron v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1991) 22 ATR 131

Secondary Materials

Explanatory Memorandum, Pooled Development Funds Bill 1992 (Cth)

Commonwealth, Second Reading Speech of the Explanatory Memorandum of Pooled Development Funds Bill 1992 (Cth), House of Representatives, 26 May 1992, 2757 (Mr Free, Minister of Science and Technology)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Boyle

15 March 2023

the application

  1. The Applicant seeks the review of the Respondent’s decision of 23 April 2021 to affirm a decision of 3 February 2021 under s 47 of the Pooled Development Funds Act 1992 (Cth) (PDFA) to revoke the Applicant’s Pooled Development Fund (PDF) registration declaration.

  2. The application for review is made under s 56 of the PDFA.

    background

  3. The following facts are taken from paras 3.1 – 3.28 of the Respondent’s Statement of Findings of Fact and Reasons[1] which the Applicant said are “broadly agreed”.[2]

    [1] R3, T2/11-8.

    [2] A1, [6].

  4. The Applicant is an Australian public company. The Applicant became a registered PDF on 19 September 2005.[3]

    [3] R3, T3/22.

  5. On 20 August 2020,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MEC Resources Ltd and Industry Innovation and Science Austra... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 399
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for review by MEC Resources Ltd (the Applicant) of a decision to revoke its registration as a Pooled Development Fund (PDF) under the *Pooled Development Funds Act 1992* (PDFA). The Applicant had been found to have contravened several provisions of the PDFA, including failures to comply with conditions imposed on an approval, making investments contrary to capital limits, and failing to notify the Board of certain events. Industry Innovation and Science Australia (the Respondent) had made the decision to revoke the Applicant's registration.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the revocation of the Applicant's PDF registration was an appropriate sanction, and whether the Applicant had been afforded procedural fairness. Specifically, the Applicant argued that the revocation was the "ultimate sanction" and should only be applied as a last resort, that the alleged breaches did not subvert the objects of the PDFA, and that a new ground for cancellation, relating to sections 20A and 20B of the PDFA, had been introduced late in the proceedings, thereby breaching procedural fairness.

The court reasoned that the power to cancel a PDF's registration under section 47(1) of the PDFA was discretionary and that revocation should be considered the ultimate sanction, to be applied only when other avenues were unavailable or insufficient. It found that the claimed breaches, particularly those concerning reporting obligations, did not subvert the fundamental objects of the PDFA, which were to foster equity capital for small and medium-sized Australian enterprises. Furthermore, the court noted that the breaches occurred under previous management and that the Applicant had since implemented new compliance procedures. The court also found that the introduction of the section 20A and 20B breach argument in the Respondent's closing submissions, without prior identification in the Respondent's Statement of Findings of Fact and Contentions or initial submissions, constituted a breach of procedural fairness.

Consequently, the court set aside the revocation order. The court substituted an order that the Applicant's registration declaration as a PDF be revoked, but that the revocation be suspended indefinitely, provided the Applicant complied with certain conditions, including ongoing reporting and adherence to the PDFA.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The application for review is made under s 56 of the PDFA.background The following facts are taken from paras 3.1 – 3.28 of the Respondent’s Statement of Findings of Fact and Reasons[1] which the Applicant said are “broadly agreed”.[2] [1] R3, T2/11-8. [2] A1, [6]. The Applicant is an Australian public company. The Applicant became a registered PDF on 19 September 2005.[3][3] R3, T3/22. On 20 August 2020, the Department of Industry, Science, Energy and Resources wrote to the Applicant identifying potential breaches of the PDFA and requested information from the Applicant in relation to those potential breaches.[4] The potential breaches identified by the Department involved:[4] R3, T4/23-5.(a)failure to comply with conditions imposed on an approval granted by the Board[5] under s 25(1) of the PDFA for the Applicant to commit more than 30% of its committed capital to Advent Energy Pty Ltd, as those conditions included:[5] Defined in the PDFA as Industry Innovation and Science Australia, established by s 6 of the Industry Research and Development Act 1986 (Cth).(i)the Applicant providing information to the Department on a quarterly basis about its progress towards achieving compliance with the 30% limit established by s 25 of the PDFA; and(ii)the Applicant becoming compliant with the 30% limit established by s 25 of the PDFA by 5 August 2020and the Applicant had not provided updates about its progress towards achieving compliance with s 25 of the PDFA.(b)an investment in Intelligent IP Hosting Pty Ltd, which involved the Applicant committing:(i)more than 30% of its committed capital to Intelligent IP, contrary to s 25 of the PDFA; and(ii)an amount that was less than 10% of Intelligent IP's paid-up capital immediately after the investment, contrary to s 27 of the PDFA;(c)failure to notify the Board within 30 days after it invested in Intelligent IP for the first time, contrary to s 27A of the PDFA; and(d)failure to notify the Board in writing within 30 days after at least three notifiable events under s 42 of the PDFA, comprising persons becoming or ceasing to be relevant officers of the Applicant and a change in the address of the Applicant's registered office. On 20 August 2020, Andrew Bald on behalf of the Applicant replied, stating that the Applicant would need to consider its formal response, but had not deliberately done any of the things identified by the Department and would welcome the opportunity to engage with the Department to remedy the potential breaches and ensure ongoing compliance.[6][6] R3, T4/23. On 2 September 2020, the Applicant provided its response to the Department's request for information.[7] In its response, the Applicant stated that:[7] R3, T5/26-9.(a)its investment in Advent Energy had never exceeded 30% of the Applicant's shareholder funds, as:(i)at the time of its investment, the Applicant's investment of $8.77 million represented 29.93% of its shareholder funds, which totalled $29,298,925;(ii)it had not invested further in Advent Energy, but it had increased its shareholder funds to $30,644,378, decreasing the portion of its funds invested in Advent Energy to 28.16%.(b)despite not providing information to the Board in accordance with the condition imposed by the Board under s 28(2A) of the PDFA, it had not contravened s 28 because it had been compliant with s 25 of the PDFA;(c)on or around 30 August 2019, the Applicant entered into a binding term sheet with Intelligent IP whereby it was to invest $405,000 in Intelligent IP, which it also referred to as “Claratti,” which represented 12.8% of the issued capital in Intelligent IP and 1.31% of the Applicant's committed capital;(d)in response to the potential failure to notify the Board of its initial investment in Intelligent IP within 30 days of investment, that it had divested its investment in Intelligent IP “rapidly” after its initial investment, it had “endured a tumultuous period since approximately December 2016” and the board of directors of the Applicant had taken steps to ensure it complies with its obligations; and (e)it had “new processes” that it stated would ensure it would notify the Committee of notifiable events and listed the names and appointment dates of its board of directors members as well as its registered address.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 12 May 2021, the Applicant applied to the Tribunal for review of the decision to affirm the Initial Decision.the hearing and evidence The Applicant made an application under s 41(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (AAT Act) for a stay of the implementation of the decision. The stay application was heard by me on 18 October 2021. At the time of that hearing, the following documents were admitted into evidence:(a)Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions dated 26 August 2021 (A1) (Applicant’s SFIC);(b)Affidavit of David Leslie Breeze dated 7 September 2021 (the first affidavit) (A2);(c)NAB Direct Credit Report and email exchange from the National Offshore Petroleum Titles Administrator and Response from Mr Breeze dated 19 July 2021 and 15 October 2021 and NAB Connect Direct Credit Report (A3); and(d)Consideration by the Hon Keith Pitt of Petroleum Exploration Permit 11 (PEP 11) Application dated 12 February 2021 (R1). In addition to the above documents, I had before me at the time of the hearing of the stay application the documents lodged by the Respondent pursuant to s 37 of the AAT Act. By decision dated 3 November 2021, I refused the stay application.[39] [39] MEC Resources Ltd and Innovation and Science Australia [2021] AATA 4030. The substantive application was heard on 27 and 28 January and 9 June 2022. The Applicant was represented by Mr T Houwelling and Mr T Millar and the Respondent was represented by Ms C Thompson (now SC). The only witness to give evidence at the hearing was David Leslie Breeze on behalf of the Applicant. The following documents were admitted into evidence:(a)Applicant’s further submissions in response dated 13 December 2021 (A4);(b)Extract from the MEC Resources website relating to Mr Breeze’s qualifications (A6);(c)Respondent’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions dated 8 November 2021) (Respondent’s SFIC) (R2);(d)Documents lodged by the Respondent pursuant to s 37 of the AAT Act s 37 (Volumes 1 and 2) (R3);(e)Affidavit of David Leslie Breeze dated 13 December 2021 (the second affidavit) (A5):(f)Media Release dated 16 December 2021 by Prime Minister re PEP 11 (R4);(g)Updated voluntary suspension announcement dated 21 October 2021 (R5);(h)Updated voluntary suspension announcement dated 14 January 2022 (R6);(i)Australian Oxford Dictionary definition of “transferable” (R7); and (j)Australian Securities and Investment Commission (ASIC) enforceable undertaking (R8).the legislation Section 3 of the PDFA states the object of the PDFA to be:…to develop, and demonstrate the potential of, the market for providing patient equity capital (including venture capital) to small or medium-sized Australian enterprises that carry on eligible businesses. This object is achieved through pooled development funds which attract certain tax benefits for those investing. A company may apply to the Board for a registration declaration to be made in relation to the company under s 11 of the PDFA. The Board must grant a registration application and declare the applicant to be registered as a PDF if the Board is satisfied of the factors listed in s 14(1) of the PDFA.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 3 February 2021, the Committee made the Initial Decision, agreeing to revoke the Applicant's registration declaration for contravening ss 19(1), 27, 27A and 42 of the PDFA,[31] with that revocation communicated to the Applicant in a letter dated 4 February 2020.[32][31] R3, T30/415. [32] R3, T31/455-7. On 23 February 2021, the Department informed the Applicant that notice of the revocation of its registration declaration had been published in the Gazette and asked the Applicant to inform the Department when it intended to notify its shareholders of the revocation under s 46(2) of the PDFA.[33] [33] R3, T32/458. On 26 February 2021, the Applicant applied for review of the Initial Decision, contending that:[34] [34] R3, T33/460-4.(a)the Applicant's alleged breaches of the PDFA had not been particularised;(b)the Committee had characterised the Applicant's conduct as a series of breaches, but it had only been one set of circumstances;(c)one set of circumstances cannot constitute separate breaches, so in considering the Applicant's conduct as multiple breaches the Committee had “entered into legal error;”(d)the Applicant's breaches of the PDFA were temporary and did not go to the heart of the PDFA;(e)the Applicant was denied procedural fairness because it was not provided with “detailed information or material in respect of the Department's assessment on the submissions given to the Committee” and because the Committee received a “verbal update” from the Department on 3 February 2021 that the Applicant was not able to “interact with;”(f)the Applicant had been denied a “verbal hearing”;(g)the Board had failed to consider whether the individual breaches were sufficient for it to be satisfied that there was a contravention of the PDFA, but had instead relied on the Department;(h)the Department intended to phase out PDFs, a contention based on the Applicant having purportedly received a letter from the Committee in February 2013 expressing such an intention;(i)the Board had failed to exercise its discretion and instead ”a Committee has acted outside of the provisions of the PDFA”; and(j)the serious impact of revocation had not been properly considered. On 10 March 2021, the Department acknowledged receipt of the Applicant's application for review and invited the Applicant to provide further information to support its position.[35] [35] R3, T34/465-7. On 18 March 2021, the Applicant provided a further submission, providing further detail of the arguments made in its 26 February 2021 submission.[36] [36] R3, T35/468-475. On 23 April 2021, a delegate of the Board made the decision affirming the Initial Decision.[37]The decision was communicated to the Applicant by letter dated 30 April 2021, which included an attachment detailing each of the Applicant's breaches of the PDFA.[38] [37] R3, T37/483-508.[38] R3, T38/509-14. On 12 May 2021, the Applicant applied to the Tribunal for review of the decision to affirm the Initial Decision.the hearing and evidence

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Applicant’s submissions in reply dated 5 May 2022 were to the following effect:(a)Section 47 of the PDFA uses the word “may” and the power to cancel the PDF status is therefore discretionary. Cancellation of PDF status is the last resort.(b)Even if directions under Division 3 of Part 4 are not available in respect of the reporting breaches, but investment breaches can be dealt with in this manner, then it could not be said that the ultimate sanction is appropriate as suggested by the Respondent as a consequence of the reporting breaches.(c)The position of the Respondent is fundamentally at odds with the purpose and objectives of the PDFA.(d)The assertion that the Applicant’s response to the claims now made of breaches of ss 20A and 20B is suggestive of a company paying lip service to compliance is without basis.(e)The Applicant is taken by surprise by the Respondent raising a claimed breach of ss 20A and 20B as they were not identified as a reason for the cancellation of the PDF status and were not referred to in the Respondent’s SFIC. The new case put by the Respondent in submissions on Section 20A(2) ought not to be allowed and the Respondent’s submissions in that regard ought properly to be withdrawn or ignored by the Tribunal as a clear and apparent breach of procedural fairness.considerationProcedural fairness The precise basis of the Applicant’s complaint in relation to the Respondent raising the claim of a breach of s 20A of the PDFA was not clear to me. I sought clarification of the Applicant’s complaint at the time of the oral closing submissions on 9 June 2022. The following exchange occurred:TRIBUNAL: But I am just trying to understand what your – the applicant’s position is, is it that you were unaware, the applicant was unaware, that part of the matters to be resolved was whether or not there’d be any breach of section 20A. Or is it your case that whilst you were generally aware of that, there was insufficient detail of the particulars of the breach to enable the applicant to properly respond to that case?MR HOUWELING: Well both…. What occurs from time to time is that a broader context may be put and that, of itself, can’t be objectionable. But where that’s expressly relied upon, and then used for the purposes of coming to – as if it’s the case that is then being put, that is a change of position.Put differently, the case as put needed to be met on the basis of provisions other than section 20A and 20B. But in the general characterisation of the way within which it seemed that the applicant, or the respondent, rather, was putting its case, we needed to address those provisions more broadly.Now what we distil from the materials that are before us, is that the respondent puts its case on the basis of section 20A and we say that that is not the basis on which this tribunal ought properly A, to have regard to the evidence in respect of 20A and the conclusions that are then suggested are appropriate. We would have more to say in respect of the way within which they are framed.And B, we say that section 20A was not the case as put by the respondent in the beginning or at any stage. And so, to raise it in its closings, in effect, we may do so, or it may be done so, for the purposes other than for the tribunal to rely upon. But as I understand it, the position as put by the respondent is to rely on section 20A.Not in the SFIC, not in its opening or in its initial submissions, statements of findings, of reasons, et cetera.