Meaney v Comcare

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

[2013] AATA 815

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2010/5151

Mary Meaney

APPLICANT

And

Comcare

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

RM Creyke, Senior Member

Date 15 November 2013  
Place Canberra

The reviewable decision is affirmed.

......................[sgd]..........................................

RM Creyke, Senior Member

Catchwords

COMPENSATION – Commonwealth Employees – adjustment reaction – other contributing factors - whether contributed to by employment to a significant degree

Legislation

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) ss 4(1), 5A and 5B

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) s 44

Cases

Re Meaney and Comcare (2012) 130 ALD 293
Comcare v Mooi (1996) FCA 1587


Comcare v Sahu-Khan (2007) 156 FCR 536

Secondary Materials

American Psychiatric Association’s Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (4th edn, Text Revision (DSM IV – TR) (2000)

REASONS FOR DECISION

RM Creyke, R, SMember

  1. The primary issue was whether Ms Mary Meaney suffered an ‘injury’ under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (Act).

  2. The issue was decided in Ms Meaney’s favour in the initial decision by the Tribunal (Re Meaney and Comcare (2012) 130 ALD 293). On appeal to the Federal Court under section 44 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), the appeal was upheld.

  3. At the resumed hearing before the Tribunal on 17 September 2013, the parties provided written submissions and made oral presentations to the Tribunal.

    Background

  4. The following chronology is substantially based on the facts as agreed by both parties. Where the notation ‘#’ appears at the beginning, or in, a paragraph, additional facts by Ms Meaney have been provided. 

  5. # Ms Meaney commenced with the Australian Public Service on 12 October 1981, and is a career public servant with over thirty years’ experience in the public sector.

  6. In 1997 Ms Meaney became a carer of her widowed mother.

  7. On or around 5 January 2005, Ms Meaney commenced employment as a Director in the Ministerial and Parliamentary Services (MPS) section of the Department of Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development and Local Government.

  8. # This Agreement remunerated Ms Meaney at a significantly higher salary classification equivalent to a Senior Executive Band 1 (Band 1) approximately $50,000 above the EL2 salary band.  The package was in recognition of her superior responsibilities and abilities as compared to officers at a similar EL2 level.

  9. The Tribunal found at the initial hearing that Ms Meaney had negotiated with Mr Chandler on her appointment in 2005 that she could work flexible hours in recognition of the nature of the work in MPS. Ms Meaney said that the arrangement was that she could take a certain number of days per year in lieu of the extra hours worked to manage parliamentary business, with additional days in an election year.  For this purpose, Ms Meaney kept a diary of her hours.

  10. On 15 January 2009, Ms Meaney’s mother fell, broke her hip and required hospitalisation and an operation.  Her mother was 86 years old at the time, and it was anticipated she would not survive the fall, and the operation.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Meaney v Comcare and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] AATA 815
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Meaney v Comcare involved a claim for compensation by Ms Meaney, a long-serving public servant, who alleged that she suffered a mental illness due to workplace stress and leave mismanagement. The case was heard in the Federal Court, where Justice Buchanan reviewed the decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The central issue in the case was whether Ms Meaney's employment by the Commonwealth contributed significantly to her mental illness, specifically her adjustment disorder, as defined under the relevant acts. The court had to determine if the Tribunal had correctly applied the statutory definitions of 'disease' and 'injury', and whether Ms Meaney's condition was indeed caused by her employment to a significant degree.

Justice Buchanan found that while the Tribunal had not provided adequate reasons for its decision, there were no erroneous findings of fact or other legal errors. The court detailed that Ms Meaney suffered from Chronic Adjustment Disorder, which was a recognised psychological condition and not a normal variation of mental behaviour. The Tribunal's findings on the nature and timeline of her condition were supported by medical evidence, which indicated that Ms Meaney had recovered by early May 2009. The medical experts' opinions varied on the exact recovery timeline, but the court found Dr Mills' assessment more reliable given his long-term relationship with Ms Meaney.

The court concluded that the Tribunal had not sufficiently explained its reasoning in relation to the contribution of Ms Meaney's employment to her mental illness. Despite this, Justice Buchanan did not find any misapplication of the statutory definitions or other legal errors. The court's decision highlighted the importance of clear and comprehensive reasoning in administrative decisions, particularly in complex cases involving psychological conditions and employment relationships.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

At the resumed hearing before the Tribunal on 17 September 2013, the parties provided written submissions and made oral presentations to the Tribunal.Background The following chronology is substantially based on the facts as agreed by both parties. Where the notation ‘#’ appears at the beginning, or in, a paragraph, additional facts by Ms Meaney have been provided. # Ms Meaney commenced with the Australian Public Service on 12 October 1981, and is a career public servant with over thirty years’ experience in the public sector. In 1997 Ms Meaney became a carer of her widowed mother. On or around 5 January 2005, Ms Meaney commenced employment as a Director in the Ministerial and Parliamentary Services (MPS) section of the Department of Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development and Local Government. # This Agreement remunerated Ms Meaney at a significantly higher salary classification equivalent to a Senior Executive Band 1 (Band 1) approximately $50,000 above the EL2 salary band. The package was in recognition of her superior responsibilities and abilities as compared to officers at a similar EL2 level. The Tribunal found at the initial hearing that Ms Meaney had negotiated with Mr Chandler on her appointment in 2005 that she could work flexible hours in recognition of the nature of the work in MPS. Ms Meaney said that the arrangement was that she could take a certain number of days per year in lieu of the extra hours worked to manage parliamentary business, with additional days in an election year. For this purpose, Ms Meaney kept a diary of her hours. On 15 January 2009, Ms Meaney’s mother fell, broke her hip and required hospitalisation and an operation. Her mother was 86 years old at the time, and it was anticipated she would not survive the fall, and the operation. The last rites were administered prior to the operation. # After the operation the mother’s health improved and there was an expectation that she would gain full recovery, following some six to eight weeks rehabilitation at home. After she left hospital, the mother had rehabilitation care for three weeks in a respite care facility prior to her return home on or about 25 February 2009. # At the time of the mother’s fall Ms Meaney was on approved three days’ recreation leave. At 8.03am on 16 January 2009 Ms Meaney contacted her supervisor, Mr David Banham, to inform him of her mother’s accident: ‘David – my mum is in hospital and is awaiting a hip operation after a fall. [TA] is looking after the section in my absence’. Mr Banham responded at 9.22am on 16 January 2009: ‘I assume [TA] will be in contact to provide me with the information’. Ms Meaney responded again to Mr Banham at 10.59am on 16 January 2009: ‘I will be away next week due to my mother’s illness. I will not be accessing emails’. This email had followed a number of calls made on 16 January 2009 by Ms Meaney to staff members organising work, and informing them of her absence. # Ms Meaney had approved recreation leave prior to the fall from 15-17 January and again from 20 January until 2 February 2009. Dr Mills, Ms Meaney’s general practitioner, issued a carer’s certificate from 15 January 2009 to 23 January 2009 to care for elderly and sick mother (next of kin).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 10 November 2009, Ms Meaney submitted a claim for compensation. Ms Meaney claimed she suffered an illness affecting her mental state, which she first noticed (and for which she first sought treatment) on 16 April 2009. Ms Meaney claimed that she was made ill by the ‘mistreatment of leave requirements following [her] mother’s incapacity’. Medical evidenceDr Mills Dr Ian Mills, Ms Meaney’s general practitioner since 1995, was also her mother’s doctor. He reported on 30 July 2009 that he had issued a sick certificate dating from 23 February 2009 for Ms Meaney. He had continued to issue medical certificates of her unfitness for work ‘given the ongoing instability at work’. In his report of 13 March 2010 he noted that his carer’s certificates for Ms Meaney ‘became sick certificates from 23 February 2009’, and noted ‘Her symptoms are reactive to her perceived workplace stress’. As he said:… when Mary told me that there were problems at work resulting in symptoms of stress and anxiety. I was not aware of the details however Mary stated that there were problems with her work position and that legal action was pending. Given her previous conscientious work-ethic and her noticeable worried state I decided that time away from the perceived threatening environment was the best form of management. He had initially diagnosed ‘Acute Situational Crisis’, but having seen the report of Dr George, he agreed this had become chronic adjustment disorder. He noted ‘Generally she has been well but minor exacerbations over the years have resulted from various stressors usually related to her employment’. As he said ‘Given her difficulties at work I felt it best to provide her with sick leave until the waters settled’. His report went on:With regard to Ms Meaney’s employment relationship, the main factors which have contributed to the claimed medical condition relate to alleged inappropriate workplace actions by one of her supervisors. Ms Meaney believes that as long as this supervisor remains within the departmental chain of command her vocational future with the department remains limited. Hence the continuing certificates relating to her being unfit to return to the current department. At the hearing, Dr Mills confirmed that Ms Meaney has suffered a chronic mental illness since 1995/96 which was controlled by an anti-psychotic drug. That condition was usually provoked by stress. He confirmed that to his recollection he had not spoken to Ms Meaney on 18/19 February 2009 when he issued a carer’s certificate and then a revision of the dates. He had done this in response to a message to the surgery. He did have a consultation with her on 18 March 2009 when he changed her medication because of her stress. Dr Mills said he did not backdate medical certificates so he could not explain why there was a sickness certificate for Ms Meaney dated 19 February when his clinical notes suggest that he only saw her on 18 March 2009 and issued a certificate on that day.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The relevant issues are set out the findings of Justice Buchanan listed in these reasons under ‘Consideration’. Specifically, however, the issues are:·Whether the Tribunal failed to apply, or misapplied, the definition of ‘disease’ as it appears in section 5B of the Act;·Whether the Tribunal failed to apply, or misapplied, the definition of ‘injury’ as it appears in section 5A of the Act.Consideration The Federal Court (Justice Buchanan) found the Tribunal had failed to provide adequate reasons for its decision. Otherwise, Buchanan J found no erroneous findings of fact or other errors of law.Whether injury was contributed to, to a significant degree, by Ms Meaney’s employment by the CommonwealthNature of condition At the initial hearing, the Tribunal found that Ms Meaney suffered from Chronic Adjustment Disorder. The condition is recognised in the American Psychiatric Association’s Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (4th edn, Text Revision (DSM IV – TR) (2000),[4] an authoritative source, and it is accordingly a psychological ailment which is outside the boundaries of normal mental behaviour and functioning.[5] It is significant that the condition may arise any time up to three months after the onset of the stressor(s),[6] and usually resolves within no more than six months of that initiator.[7] When the condition persists beyond six months, it is described as chronic.[8] No challenge has been made to that diagnostic finding.[4] American Psychiatric Association’s Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (4th edn, Text Revision (DSM IV – TR) (2000) 679-680. [5] Comcare v Mooi (1996) FCA 1587. [6] American Psychiatric Association’s Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (4th edn, Text Revision (DSM IV – TR) (2000) at 679.[7] Ibid.[8] Id at 680. The medical experts were of the opinion that Ms Meaney had recovered from her adjustment disorder condition. On 16 April 2009 Dr Mills was prepared to provide a graduated return to work certificate from the beginning of May 2009. Associate Professor Robertson said by August 2009 Ms Meaney was able to return to work, and by September 2009, Dr George said she was no longer suffering symptoms of the condition. Although Dr Lark said she was not fit for any work in July 2009 the symptoms he described of anxiety, depression and insomnia were also side effects of her anti-psychotic medication and were recurrent. The Tribunal prefers the findings of Dr Mills, her treating practitioner since 1995, on the date of her recovery, to that of Dr Lark who had seen her on one occasion only. Accordingly from early May 2009, Ms Meaney was no longer suffering from the adjustment disorder which is the subject of the claim. The Tribunal notes additionally that the condition, according to Dr Reutens, was of a ‘mild to moderate’ variety at most. As Dr Reutens said in her 1 April 2011 report:Ms Meaney told me that these symptoms appeared prior to 23 February 2009, and around the time she was discussing her potential leave arrangements with her supervisor. In the absence of any collaborative history, I am therefore reliant on Ms Meaney’s account, however, I note that she was sufficiently capable of caring for her mother prior to the establishment of home services, and providing psychological support to her mother after services were established, indicating a mild to moderate level of severity.