Meaden v Bell Potter Securities Limited (No 5)

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Meaden v Bell Potter Securities Limited (No 5) [2014] FCA 978

Citation: Meaden v Bell Potter Securities Limited (No 5) [2014] FCA 978
Parties: JILLIAN ANNETTA MEADEN, DAVID DARVILL, ELRYG NOMINEES PTY LTD (ATF THE ELRYG NOMINEES SUPERANNUATION FUND), SHULVO INVESTMENTS PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION), ROOSEYCORP PTY LTD ACN 125 400 080 (ATF NORLEX SUPER FUND), TECHNICAL INVESTING PTY LTD ACN 111 646 032 (ATF TECHNICAL INVESTING ABSOLUTE RETURN FUND), KAS DEVELOPMENTS PTY LTD ACN 065 305 204, NEIL MOUNT AND GEOFFREY JONES (ATF NEIL MOUNT SUPERANNUATION FUND ACCOUNT), MDS TILING PTY LTD ACN 096 842 152, PETER GEOFFREY TURNER AND ZENA TURNER (ATF THE P&Z SUPER FUND), CHRISTINE HILDEBRAND, CHRISTOPHER HO, IATRIX ENTERPRISES PTY LTD ACN 113 233 159, TPC PTY LTD ACN 000 823 414 (ATF THE ADAM FREIER FAMILY TRUST), PETER COPE PTY LTD ACN 123 888 586 (ATF COPE FAMILY SUPERANNUATION FUND), HAMMOND ROYCE CORPORATION PTY LTD ACN 005 562 050 (ATF LEN DAVID SUPER FUND), HAYSON BLOODSTOCK PTY LTD ACN 108 655 367, HAYSON SUPER INVESTMENTS PTY LTD ACN 108 655 376, JADWIGA MAJ, CHRISTOPHER PERDIS, PETER HALL (ATF SANDRA & PETER HALL TRUST), VICPAR HOLDINGS PTY LTD ACN 113 077 419 (ATF VICPAR TRUST) (IN LIQUIDATION), DAVID AZAR, BRETT JOHNSON, WOODVEST PTY LTD ACN 001 659 892 (ATF WOODVEST PTY SUPERANNUATION FUND ACCOUNT), TIM STAR, CRANPORT PTY LTD ACN 003 854 000, SOLOMONS & SHAW PTY LTD ACN 089 034 060, MARIANNE DOWNS, ANDREW RANDALL, SIMON MCLACHLAN, JOYBECK PTY LTD ACN 050 236 863 (ATF BLACK FAMILY TRUST), BRETT TYACK, JTW TRADING PTY LTD ACN 105 305 333, DRCW TRADING PTY LTD ACN 105 303 777, LAURAINE WORTHINGTON, APPLIKOTE PTY LIMITED ACN 010 446 269, ROGAN YATES, HOMEBOY PTY LTD ACN 123 378 512, JUSTINE ASHTON, TRANSWORLD CHEMICAL (AUST) PTY LTD ACN 005 625 981, CHRISTOPHER SPURRIER, DOUG AND LYNETTE ELLEN PADDON (ATF PADDON FAMILY SUPER FUND), SIEGFRIED LINK, VERONIQUE GUICHON and MELAIM PTY LTD ACN 005 880 290 (ATF DOUGLASS FAMILY TRUST) v BELL POTTER SECURITIES LIMITED (ACN 006 390 772)
File number: NSD 1310 of 2010
Judge: EDMONDS J
Date of judgment: 12 September 2014
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for further discovery of specific documents and categories of documents pursuant to Rule 20.21 of the Federal Court Rules 2011; in the alternative Rule 20.15; in the alternative proper discovery pursuant to earlier order of the Court; opposition to such orders supported by evidence that nothing further to be discovered; application for further and better particulars of a matter, not being a primary fact, the existence of which depends on the evidence, argument and judgment of the Court
Legislation: Federal Court Rules 2011 rr 20.15, 20.21
Cases cited: Construction, Forestry, Mining & Energy Union v Rio Tinto Coal Australia Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 462 cited
Date of hearing: 26 August 2014
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 34
Counsel for the Applicant: Ms L Nichols
Solicitor for the Applicant: Slater & Gordon…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Meaden v Bell Potter Securities Limited (No 5) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCA 978
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The interlocutory application in Meaden v Bell Potter Securities Limited (No 5) was made by the applicants seeking various orders, including the filing of expert evidence and particulars, in relation to the alleged misleading or deceptive conduct of the respondent. The applicant's Third Further Amended Statement of Claim pleaded that the respondent's conduct in making certain valuation representations was misleading or deceptive. The respondent denied the allegations and provided a defence including reliance on information from third parties and the use of valuation techniques. The applicants sought further particulars to clarify the "proper, appropriate and sound valuation techniques" used by the respondent, aiming to prevent the wasting of time and costs by their experts.

The legal issues before the court included whether the applicants were entitled to an order for particular discovery of documents, the scope of such an order, and whether the order should be granted considering the principles of Rule 20.21 and Rule 20.15. The court considered the principles articulated in Construction, Forestry, Mining & Energy Union v Rio Tinto Coal Australia Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 462, which emphasised the need for particular discovery to be founded on an appearance that such documents exist and to facilitate the efficient conduct of proceedings.

The court determined that Rule 20.21 should not be applied in a manner that would obviate the common law rule that the affidavit of discovery is conclusive, unless there is an insufficiency demonstrated from the pleadings or other sources. The court held that the applicants had not sufficiently demonstrated the existence of undiscovered documents to warrant an order for particular discovery. It was found that the claim for particular discovery was not founded on any appearance that such documents exist, and the court was unlikely to make an order for particular discovery where the moving party did not point to particular evidence establishing the existence of undiscovered documents. The court also noted that Rule 20.21 is not a substitute for general discovery and should be applied in a manner that facilitates the efficient conduct of proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case concerns an interlocutory application in a proceeding brought by the applicants, Meaden, against Bell Potter Securities Limited. The applicants allege that Bell Potter's conduct in making certain valuation representations was misleading or deceptive, in breach of sections 1041H of the Corporations Act and 12DA of the ASIC Act. Bell Potter denies these allegations and asserts that any contraventions of the Corporations Act were honest and should result in it being excused or relieved from liability. The particulars sought by the applicants, particularly concerning the "proper, appropriate and sound valuation techniques" used by Bell Potter, are central to the interlocutory application. The applicants argue that obtaining these particulars is necessary to avoid wasting time and costs by their experts proceeding on incomplete material.

This matter involves an interlocutory application by the applicants, Meaden, seeking orders related to the discovery of documents and the filing of expert evidence. The application was made under Rule 20.21 of the Federal Court Rules, which pertains to particular discovery, and it was heard by the court. Prior to this application, there were consent orders made on 18 August 2014 that set deadlines for the filing of expert evidence, which the applicants needed to adhere to. The respondents, Bell Potter, opposed the application and submitted an affidavit in support of their opposition.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The orders sought in paras 1–3 of the interlocutory application must be refused.Order Sought: 4 – Filing Expert Evidence If the applicants have not filed and served all their expert evidence due on 2 September 2014 (see order 1 made by consent on 18 August 2014) they must do so by 19 September 2014. No further expert evidence filed after that date will be allowed to be read.Order Sought: 5 – Particulars In their Third Further Amended Statement of Claim, the applicants plead:31.By reason of the matters alleged in paragraph 30, Bell Potter’s conduct in making the valuation representations was misleading or deceptive, contrary to s.1041H of the Corporations Act and s.12DA of the ASIC Act. In its Defence, the respondent pleads:31.In response to paragraph 31 of the third further amended statement of claim, Bell:(a) refers to and repeats its response to paragraph 30 above;(b)otherwise denies the allegations; and(c)further says, in relation to each alleged contravention of s1041H of the Corporations Act 2001, that:(i)pursuant to s1041(4) of the Corporations Act 2001 these proceedings are eligible proceedings for the purposes of s1317S of the Corporations Act 2001; and(ii) in the event that Bell engaged in the conduct giving rise to the alleged contravention of s1041H of the Corporations Act 2001 (which is denied),then,(iii)Bell acted honestly in relation to that contravention; and(iv)having regard to all the circumstances of the contraventions, including all the matters set out in this defence, Bell ought fairly be excused for each contravention and be relieved wholly, or alternatively partly, from any liability for such contravention.ParticularsIncluding but not limited to:1.reliance by Bell on information, including releases to the ASX, published or provided by PGL, and other research, in the preparation of the reports:2.use by Bell of proper, appropriate and sound valuation techniques;3.inherent speculative nature of an investment in a biotechnology company whose main product was subject to US FDA approval; and4.further particulars will be provided after discovery. While not specified in the interlocutory application as such, it becomes clear from the submissions that the applicants made on the hearing that the further and better particulars being sought concerned para 2 of the particulars provided in the Defence, namely, the “proper, appropriate and sound valuation techniques” used by the respondent in valuing the PGL shares. In their written outline of submissions, the applicants submitted:[The respondent], having made that positive allegation, must be in possession of the material by which it can be particularised. Requiring [the respondent] to particularise the allegation now will facilitate the just and efficient disposition of the proceeding. It will have the result that the most relevant facts are laid out for both the [a]pplicants’ and [r]espondents’ [sic] experts to consider. It will significantly reduce the prospect that time and costs will be wasted by the [a]pplicant’s [sic] experts proceeding on material that is incomplete, with risk that further opinions will need to be sought once [the respondent] is required to particularise its defence.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the orders sought in paragraphs 1-3 of the interlocutory application should be refused.
2. Whether the applicants should be required to file and serve all their expert evidence by 19 September 2014, with no further expert evidence being allowed after that date.
3. Whether the respondent should be required to provide further particulars concerning the "proper, appropriate and sound valuation techniques" used in valuing the PGL shares.

Held
1. The court held that the orders sought in paragraphs 1-3 of the interlocutory application should be refused.
2. The court held that if the applicants had not filed and served all their expert evidence due on 2 September 2014, they must do so by 19 September 2014. No further expert evidence filed after that date would be allowed to be read.
3. The court held that the respondent should be required to provide further particulars concerning the "proper, appropriate and sound valuation techniques" used in valuing the PGL shares.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The interlocutory application was opposed by the respondent and in doing so it relied on an affidavit of Mr Benjamin Mark Giles (“Mr Giles”) sworn and filed 18 August 2014 and read on the hearing of the application.CONSIDERATION AND ANALYSISAlternative Orders Sought: 1 to 3 - Discovery There was no dispute, at least no real dispute, that documents in the 34 categories of documents listed in Schedule A to the interlocutory application if they exist or previously existed, would be relevant to the issues in dispute. Rule 20.21 reads:Order for particular discovery(1)If a party (the first party) claims that a document or category of documents may be or may have been in another party’s control (the second party), the first party may apply to the Court for an order that the second party file an affidavit stating:(a)whether the document or any document of that category is or has been in the second party’s control; and(b)If the document or category of documents has been but is no longer in the second party’s control—when it was last in the second party’s control and what became of it.(2)The first party seeking an order under subrule (1) must identify the document or category of documents as precisely as possible. In Construction, Forestry, Mining & Energy Union v Rio Tinto Coal Australia Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 462, Flick J articulated the principles to be applied when considering an application under Rule 20.21. Those principles, summarised from [92]–[99], are:(1)Rule 20.21 should be applied in a manner to obviate the hardship of the rule that the affidavit of discovery is conclusive. The common law rule is described at [98] of the judgment. The affidavit of discovery was considered conclusive, save where an insufficiency was demonstrated from the pleadings, the affidavit of documents itself or the documents referred to therein, or from any other source constituting an admission of the existence of a discoverable document.(2)Rule 20.21 is not a substitute for general discovery, but rather a rule for discovery of particular documents. The application should be made following either an order for standard or non-standard discovery.(3)Despite the absence of any express requirement in Rule 20.21 that the moving party point to particular evidence establishing the existence of undiscovered documents, the Court is unlikely to make an order for particular discovery where the claim for particular discovery is not founded on any appearance that such documents exist.(4)A deficiency in discovery may emerge from an analysis of the pleadings, from the documents produced on discovery, from the evidence or from the nature or circumstances of an individual case.(5)The Court should be satisfied that particular discovery will facilitate the efficient conduct of the proceedings. Rule 20.15 reads:Non-standard and more extensive discovery(1)A party seeking an order for discovery (other than standard discovery) must identify the following:(a)any criteria mentioned in rules 20.14(1) and (2) that should not apply;(b)any other criteria that should apply;(c)whether the party seeks the use of categories of documents in the list of documents;(d)whether discovery should be given in an electronic format;(e)whether discovery should be given in accordance with a discovery plan.