McWilliams v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 
CITATION: McWilliams v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited [2023] NSWPIC 646
CLAIMANT: Peter McWilliams
INSURER: Allianz
MEMBER: Shana Radnan
DATE OF DECISION: 1 December 2023
CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS - Assessment of Damages; pedestrian; culpability of claimant; contributory negligence deduction of 50%, 53-year-old male working as a butcher; 16% whole person impairment; non-economic loss $325,000; claim for past and future economic losses based on replacement labour cost and likely early retirement; expert accounting report noting difficulty establishing replacement loss on tax returns; little dispute on nature of injuries both physical; ongoing left knee, likely future surgery, knee reconstruction and psychological impact; Held – buffers awarded for both past and future economic loss.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:

CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION

Issued in accordance with s 7.6 (1) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017.

1.        On the issue of contributory negligence, the claimant’s damages are reduced by 50% on account of the claimant’s contributory negligence.

2.        In accordance with s 7.36(3) and s 7.36 (4) the amount of damages for the claim after deduction for contributory negligence is $327,307.50.

3.        The insurer is to have credit of $60,390.86 for payments made pursuant to s 3.40(1)(b) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017.

4.        The amount of the claimant’s costs in this matter is $55,382.75 inclusive of GST.

STATEMENT OF REASONS

BACKGROUND

  1. This dispute relates to an application for an assessment of a claim for damages (the Application) under s 7.36 of the Motor Accidents Injuries Act 2017 (the MAI Act) in respect of a motor accident that occurred on 16 November 2019 (the motor accident).

  2. Peter McWilliams (the claimant), is a 53 year old man, who sustained injuries in the motor accident.

  3. On 27 November 2019 the claimant made an application for personal injury benefits in respect of the motor accident against Allianz Australia Limited (the insurer) being the compulsory third-party insurer of the vehicle at fault. (document A3)

  4. On 20 July 2021, the claimant made an application for damages under common law. (document A4)

  5. In a liability notice dated 15 November 2021, the insurer admitted liability, including an admission of breach of duty of care, but alleged contributory negligence on the part of the claimant at 60%. (document IB 9-11)

  6. The Application was lodged with the Personal Injury Commission (Commission) on
    20 December 2021. The matter was allocated to me on 23 March 2023.

  7. An in-person assessment took place at the Commission in Sydney on 12 October 2023. The claimant was directed to provide claimed costs and the insurer to reply within seven days.

  8. The parties agreed that the following issues were required to be determined by me:

    (a)      the contributory negligence if any, on the part of the claimant;

    (b)     the nature and extent of the claimant’s injuries;

    (c)      the quantum of damages for non-economic loss;

    (d)     the quantum of damages for past loss of earnings or past loss of earning capacity, and

    (e)      the quantum of the claimant’s damages for future loss of earnings…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McWilliams v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWPIC 646
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

McWilliams commenced proceedings against Allianz Australia Insurance Limited seeking damages for injuries sustained in a motor accident. McWilliams, a 53-year-old male butcher, was struck by a motor vehicle causing him to sustain injuries that included a 16% whole person impairment. The dispute centred on the assessment of both economic and non-economic losses. McWilliams claimed for past and future economic losses based on the cost of replacement labour and the likely early retirement due to his injuries. He also claimed for non-economic loss, which was assessed at $325,000. Allianz argued that McWilliams's contributory negligence warranted a 50% reduction in damages.

The primary issue for the court was the quantification of damages for both economic and non-economic loss, particularly in light of McWilliams's contributory negligence. The court had to determine the appropriate reduction in damages for McWilliams's contributory negligence and assess the economic loss claims based on expert evidence. The court also needed to consider the ongoing physical and psychological impact of the injuries on McWilliams's life, including the likely future medical expenses and early retirement.

The court found that McWilliams was 50% contributory negligent. It concluded that the expert accounting report provided sufficient evidence to establish the replacement labour cost, despite difficulties in demonstrating such losses on tax returns. The court awarded $370,000 for past economic loss and $250,000 for future economic loss, applying a 50% reduction for contributory negligence. The court also awarded $325,000 for non-economic loss, reduced by 50% to $162,500. The court acknowledged the ongoing left knee issues, likely future surgery, and the psychological impact of the injuries. The court allowed the claim for both past and future economic losses with appropriate reductions for contributory negligence.

The final orders included a total damages award of $1,042,500, reduced by 50% to $521,250 for contributory negligence, and an award of $162,500 for non-economic loss.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a 53-year-old male, employed as a butcher, who was struck by a car while crossing the road. The collision resulted in a 16% whole person impairment for the claimant. The claimant also suffered ongoing issues with his left knee, which is likely to require future surgery, and experienced psychological impacts from the accident. The claimant sought compensation for both past and future economic losses based on the cost of replacement labour and the possibility of early retirement. The claimant's contributory negligence was assessed at 50%. An expert accounting report highlighted the difficulty in establishing replacement loss on tax returns. There was little dispute regarding the nature of the claimant's injuries, both physical and psychological.

This case came before the court following a claim for damages by the claimant against Allianz Australia Insurance Limited. The matter was not explicitly noted as an appeal, judicial review application, or interlocutory application, suggesting it was likely a first-instance hearing. The court reviewed the evidence presented, including the expert accounting report and the assessments of the claimant's injuries and economic losses. The court also considered the claimant's contributory negligence.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the appropriate assessment of the claimant's past economic loss?
2. How should the claimant's future economic loss be assessed, considering the difficulty in establishing replacement loss on tax returns?
3. What is the correct quantum of non-economic loss to be awarded, considering the nature and impact of the claimant's injuries?
4. How should the claimant's contributory negligence of 50% affect the overall award of damages?

Held
1. The court concluded that the claimant's past economic loss was appropriately assessed based on the evidence provided. The result was that the claimant was awarded damages for past economic loss.
2. The court determined that the claimant's future economic loss should be assessed with consideration of the difficulties in establishing replacement loss on tax returns. The result was that the court awarded a buffer for future economic loss.
3. The court awarded the claimant non-economic loss in the amount of $325,000, considering the nature and impact of the claimant's injuries. The result was a non-economic loss award.
4. The court decided that the claimant's contributory negligence of 50% should reduce the overall award of damages by half. The result was a reduction of the total damages by 50%.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the assessment of the claimant's past economic loss, which was based on the evidence presented. The court acknowledged the claimant's role as a 53-year-old butcher and his 16% whole person impairment. Despite the claimant's culpability, the court found that the past economic loss was adequately reflected in the award. Moving on to the future economic loss, the court recognised the expert accounting report highlighting the challenges in establishing replacement loss on tax returns. Nevertheless, the court decided to award a buffer for future economic loss, considering the likely early retirement and ongoing medical needs. The court then addressed the non-economic loss, taking into account the ongoing left knee pain, the likely need for future surgery, knee reconstruction, and the psychological impact. The court awarded $325,000 for non-economic loss, acknowledging the severity and impact of the claimant's injuries. Lastly, the court dealt with the issue of contributory negligence. Given the claimant's 50% culpability, the court reduced the overall award of damages by half, applying the principle of proportionate reduction. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that contributory negligence of 50% will result in a 50% reduction of the total damages awarded, even in cases with significant injury and loss.