McVicars v South Australian Housing Trust (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Court of Appeal: Civil)

MCVICARS v SOUTH AUSTRALIAN HOUSING TRUST (No 3)

[2025] SASCA 75

Decision of the Honourable Acting Chief Justice Livesey  (ex tempore)

2 July 2025

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - PROCEDURE - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - STAY OF PROCEEDINGS

HEALTH LAW - MENTAL HEALTH GENERALLY - GENERAL LAW AFFECTING PERSONS WITH MENTAL ILLNESS OR IMPAIRED CAPACITY - CONDUCTING LEGAL PROCEEDINGS - LITIGATION GUARDIANS AND NEXT FRIENDS

This is an interlocutory application by the respondent seeking a stay pending the appointment of a litigation guardian for the applicant.

The substantive appeal concerns the decision of the Deputy President of the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal who, on internal review, upheld the decision of the Tribunal to terminate the applicant’s tenancy with the respondent. After the dismissal of an urgent stay application pending the appeal by a judge of this Court, the applicant vacated the property.

At an earlier hearing, this Court considered there was merit in the respondent’s application, but deferred making orders pending the provision of further evidence from the parties.

Held, allowing the application and ordering a stay pending the appointment of a litigation guardian:

1.The applicant has a significant legal incapacity such that the appointment of a litigation guardian is necessary.

2.The appointment of a guardian is deferred pending the provision of further evidence from the parties.

3.The appeal proceedings are stayed pending the appointment of a litigation guardian. 

Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA) Pt 8A; Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA) rr 25.6(1), 25.6(4), referred to.
Collier v Hicks (1831) 2 B & Ad 663; Damjanovic v Maley (2002) 55 NSWLR 149; F v Minister for Education and Child Development & Anor [2017] SASCFC 71; Galladin Pty Ltd v Aimnorth Pty Ltd (1993) 60 SASR 145; Giancaspro v SHRM (Australia) Pty Ltd [2005] SASC 340; McKenzie v McKenzie (1970) 3 All ER 1034; McVicars v SAHT [2025] SASCA 52; Szumylo v Ixia Pty Ltd [2001] SASC 262, considered.

MCVICARS v SOUTH AUSTRALIAN HOUSING TRUST (No 3)

[2025] SASCA 75

Court of Appeal: Civil

LIVESEY ACJ (ex tempore):

Introduction

  1. This is an adjourned hearing of the respondent’s application seeking a stay pending the appointment of a litigation guardian for the applicant, Ms McVicars.  At an earlier hearing I decided that though there was merit in the respondent’s application, no order should be made pending the prospect of further evidence from the parties. 

  2. In particular, I was told that Ms McVicars wanted to lead evidence from her treating psychiatrist to demonstrate that she was not a person under a legal incapacity.  I was also told that, in the alternative, she wanted to lead evidence regarding an appropriate guardian other than the Public Trustee who had been proposed by the respondent.

  3. For the following reasons I am now satisfied that order should be made in accordance with the respondent’s application.  Accordingly, I will order a stay of proceedings pending the appointment of a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McVicars v South Australian Housing Trust (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] SASCA 75
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by the South Australian Housing Trust (the respondent) for the appointment of a litigation guardian for Ms McVicars (the appellant) in appeal proceedings. The court was required to consider the capacity of Ms McVicars to conduct these proceedings given her diagnosed intellectual disability and borderline personality disorder, as evidenced by psychiatric reports.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether Ms McVicars possessed the requisite capacity to manage her own affairs and conduct litigation, and if not, whether the appointment of a litigation guardian was appropriate. This involved assessing the psychiatric evidence regarding her ability to make informed, rational decisions and to advocate for herself in complex legal matters, particularly in light of her history of conflict and difficulties engaging with support services.

Acting Livesey Ex Tempore CJ, having considered the psychiatric evidence of Dr Condon, concluded that Ms McVicars had a moderate to severe intellectual disability and associated deficits in adaptive functioning that significantly impaired her ability to manage her affairs independently. The court noted her vulnerability to misinterpreting interactions, limited communication skills, and inability to consistently engage with support. Consequently, the court found that there was no impediment to the appointment of a litigation guardian. The court ordered that the appeal proceedings be stayed pending the appointment of a litigation guardian, vacated the appeal listed for hearing, and adjourned the matter for the consideration of such an appointment.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Though it would clearly be preferable to have Ms McVicars in Court today, I determined that it was appropriate to continue with the evidence of Dr Condon and the respondent’s application. I will give Ms McVicars liberty to apply.Psychiatric evidence Though I had hoped that the psychiatric evidence would be available soon after my earlier ruling, it has now become available following an appointment Ms McVicars attended with Dr Condon on 26 June 2025. Before that appointment, Dr Condon had access to a volume of material relating to Ms McVicars. Unfortunately, the appointment on 26 June 2026 was cut short. The appointment was cut short because Ms McVicars attended appearing to be very angry and accusing Dr Condon of various things. She wanted Dr Condon to sign a letter which said that Ms McVicars did not want to have anything to do with Ms O’Brien. When Dr Condon said that she would not sign that letter, Ms McVicars told Dr Condon that she could not trust her. Ms McVicars had already told Dr Condon that she was, as she put it, “sick of this fuckin’ shit” as she threw her phone across the table at Dr Condon. Soon after, Dr Condon terminated the appointment. It is not necessary to go through all of the history to which Dr Condon referred in her report. In overview, Ms McVicars is a 31-year-old, single, unemployed woman who has an intellectual disability and borderline personality disorder. She apparently acquired a brain injury as a result of a significant hypoxic episode at birth. In the view of Dr Condon, Ms McVicars does not have a mental illness. Although borderline personality disorder is referred to in DSM-5-TR, Dr Condon does not regard that as a mental illness which is capable of treatment by medication. Ms McVicars has had a difficult relationship with her family. She has a history of assaults and disputes with her neighbours. She has had a number of matters in the criminal courts which have generally been dealt with under Part 8A of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA) by reason of her intellectual disability. She has been placed under the Forensic Mental Health Supervision Stream. Dr Condon first started seeing Ms McVicars in February this year. In her report dated 27 June 2025, Dr Condon expressed the following opinion:In my opinion, Ms McVicars has a moderate to severe intellectual disability and associated deficits in adaptive functioning, which significantly impair her ability to manage her own affairs independently. Her vulnerability to misinterpreting interpersonal interactions and events, coupled with her limited express of communication skills, undermine [sic] her ability to advocate for herself and resolve even minor problems, let alone litigate more complex matters. Dr Condon expressed the view that Ms McVicars has a significantly limited ability to make informed, rational decisions and manage her affairs in an autonomous and consistent manner. According to Dr Condon:Given Ms McVicars’ persistent history of conflict with support providers, repeated assaults on others, and her inability to consistently engage or benefit from available support services, I recommend that she be placed under a full Guardianship Order. The guardian would be able to act in her best interests and ensure she receives appropriate and sustained support through the NDIS. It is further recommended that the appointed guardian refer Ms McVicars to the Exceptional Needs Unit, which specialises in managing complex cases similar to hers.

Decision

Reasons for decision

LIVESEY ACJ
In the circumstances, I will defer the appointment of a guardian.Conclusion The appeal in this matter is still listed for hearing on 8 August 2025. I am now satisfied that there is no impediment to the appointment of a litigation guardian and, accordingly, I will make orders in terms of the respondent’s application. Once a litigation guardian is appointed, it will be a matter for the litigation guardian to apply to the Court should the litigation guardian determine that the appeal should proceed. Accordingly, the orders of the Court will be:1.These appeal proceedings are stayed pending the appointment of a litigation guardian.2.The appeal listed for hearing on 8 August 2025 is vacated.3.The matter is adjourned to Friday, 4 July 2025, at not before 11.30 am to consider the appointment of a litigation guardian.4.The parties have liberty to apply.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: LIVESEY ACJ

Full text does not contain this section.