McPharlin v Police No. Scgrg-99-266 Judgment No. S190

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

McPHARLIN  v  POLICE
[1999] SASC 190

Magistrates Appeal
Nyland J

  1. This is an appeal against sentence. The appellant was charged on complaint with two counts of intentionally or recklessly damaging property, contrary to s85 of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935. It was alleged that on 29 August 1998 at Smithfield Plains he intentionally or recklessly, without lawful authority, damaged a motor vehicle the property of Janice Lisa Marsh (count 1) and a wooden door, a screen door, door frame and latch, driveway gates and posts the property of the South Australian Housing Trust (count 2).

  2. The matter came on for hearing before a stipendiary magistrate in the Elizabeth Magistrates Court on 18 September 1998.  At that time the appellant appeared in person.  He pleaded guilty to both counts and was remanded for sentence.  The magistrate requested that a pre-sentence report and a psychiatric report be prepared before sentencing.  The matter was then adjourned until 26 November 1998.  On that date, Ms O’Leary appeared as counsel for the appellant.  There were some further adjournments until 26 February 1999 when the magistrate heard submissions as to penalty and imposed sentence.  During the period of the adjournment an issue arose with respect to the ownership of the damaged vehicle which was the subject of count 1.  Consequently, upon the application of Ms O’Leary, the magistrate struck out the plea to count 1 and dismissed the charge.  The magistrate then sentenced the appellant on the second count to three months imprisonment which was not suspended.  He also ordered the appellant to pay $875 by way of compensation to the victim.  The sole ground of appeal against sentence is that it was manifestly excessive.

  3. The circumstances surrounding the commission of this offence are set out in the affidavit of Francis Ranger, the police prosecutor, as follows:

    “... a witness in this matter is Janice Marsh.  At about 10.30pm on Saturday the 29th of August, 1998 she was sitting in her kitchen at her home with two friends making coffee.  She heard a car pull up into the driveway and collide with her vehicle that was parked in the driveway.  She heard a male voice yelling something.  The male was the [appellant].  The [appellant] banged on the front door wanting to get inside.  He wanted to enter to speak to a male inside.  Marsh went to ring the police, and could still hear banging on the front door and also pulling on the front security screen door.  She then heard the [appellant’s] car start up, and a car drove into the rear of her vehicle, which was pushed through the side fence of the premises.  She could hear the side fence fall down.  She then hard the vehicle reverse out of her driveway and leave her address.  There was $875.00 damage to the property which is owned by the South Australian Housing Trust.  Compensation is sought in that amount.”

  4. The prosecutor then provided the magistrate with a copy of the appellant’s criminal history which is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McPharlin v Police No. Scgrg-99-266 Judgment No. S190 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] SASC 190
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of McPharlin v Police, the appellant was appealing a sentence imposed by the Elizabeth Magistrates Court. The appellant was charged with two counts of damaging property without lawful authority, contrary to the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935. The first count was later dismissed due to an issue with the ownership of the damaged vehicle. The magistrate sentenced the appellant to three months imprisonment, which was not suspended, and ordered him to pay $875 in compensation for the damage caused to the South Australian Housing Trust's property. The appeal was against the sentence, claiming it was manifestly excessive.

The court had to determine whether the sentence imposed by the magistrate was appropriate considering the appellant's history of offending and the circumstances of the offence. The court also had to decide whether the failure to suspend the sentence rendered it manifestly excessive. The court noted that the appellant had a long history of offending, averaging almost five offences per year between 1982 and 1996. However, there was a break of about two and a half years between the commission of the present offences and those previously committed, suggesting some progress with respect to the appellant's rehabilitation. The pre-sentence and psychiatric reports also indicated the appellant's prospects for rehabilitation.

The court held that the magistrate had failed to sufficiently take into account the appellant's prospects for rehabilitation, particularly in light of the pre-sentence and psychiatric reports. The court found that the sentence was manifestly excessive in all the circumstances, as the failure to suspend the sentence did not foster the appellant's ongoing rehabilitation. The court allowed the appeal and ordered that the term of imprisonment imposed by the magistrate be suspended on condition that the appellant enter into a bond in the sum of $200 to be of good behaviour for a period of two years. The conditions of the bond required the appellant to be under the supervision of a probation officer throughout the period of the bond and undertake such counselling in the areas of substance abuse, anger management and cognitive skills and psychological counselling as the probation officer may recommend from time to time.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established