McNab Constructions Australia Pty Ltd v Queensland Building Services Authority (No 1)

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

McNab Constructions Australia Pty Ltd v Queensland Building Services Authority (No 1) [2010] QDC 132

PARTIES:

McNab Constructions Australia Pty Ltd (ACN 102 840 906)

v

Queensland Building Services Authority

FILE NO/S:

BD2699/09

DIVISION:

Civil

PROCEEDING:

Application/Appeal (from CCT) - Orders

ORIGINATING COURT:

Commercial and Consumer Tribunal

DELIVERED ON:

Original reasons delivered on 24 March 2010

Orders delivered on 7 April 2010

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

Heard on the papers

JUDGE:

Dorney QC DCJ

ORDERS:

(1)        Leave to appeal and file a Notice of Appeal, and leave to file a Notice of Contention, are granted.

(2)        The decision of the Commercial and Consumer Tribunal of 26 August 2009, that the applicant’s Application in the proceeding filed 20 March 2009 be dismissed, is confirmed.

(3) The proceeding is remitted to the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal for further hearing to be dealt with under the Commercial and Consumer Tribunal Act 2003 as if it were still in force and in accordance with the law determined in this appeal.

(4)        The respondent pay 25% of the appellant’s costs of the appeal to be assessed on the standard basis.

(5)        The costs of the interlocutory Application heard in the Commercial and Consumer Tribunal be at the discretion of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal in accordance with the transitional provisions of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – COSTS – RECOVERY OF COSTS – where utility of successful outcome for the appellant was limited – where the argument advanced by the appellant invoked an issue of public importance.

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 ss 259, 260

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules rr 681, 684

Neumann Contractors P/L v Peet Beachton Syndicate Limited (No 2) [2009] QSC 383

Pertzel v Qld Paulownia Forests Ltd & Anor [2008] QCA 287; [2008] QCA 344

Waterman v Girling Australia Insurance Co Pty Ltd (No 2) [2005] NSWSC 1111

Yara Nipro Pty Ltd v Interfert Australia Pty Ltd (No 2) [2010] QSC 19

COUNSEL:

D. Fraser QC with B. Codd for the Applicant

J. Bond QC with M. Hindman  for the Respondent

SOLICITORS:

Lenz Moreton Solicitors for the Applicant

HWL Ebsworth Solicitors for the Respondent

Introduction

  1. On 24 March 2010 I delivered reasons for deciding that the appropriate relief in this appeal is to remit the whole of the case to the Tribunal from which this appeal originated for further hearing.

QCAT

  1. By force of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (“QCAT Act”) the Commercial and Consumer Tribunal was abolished and QCAT took its place.

  1. The relevant transitional provisions under the QCAT Act are s 259 and s 260. The former, by s 259(1), states that the section applies if, before the commencement, a person has, under a former Act, appealed to a court against the decision of a former Tribunal and the appeal has not been finally dealt with at the commencement. Since s 259 is applicable, by s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McNab Constructions Australia Pty Ltd v Queensland Building... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] QDC 132
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

McNab Constructions Australia Pty Ltd sought an appeal against the Queensland Building Services Authority. The dispute centred on the dismissal of an application made by McNab Constructions Australia Pty Ltd to the tribunal, which was dismissed by the tribunal. The Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal heard the appeal and found in favour of the Queensland Building Services Authority. McNab Constructions Australia Pty Ltd sought leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal.

The central legal issue for the Court of Appeal was whether McNab Constructions Australia Pty Ltd should be granted leave to appeal and file a Notice of Appeal and Notice of Contention. Another issue was whether the tribunal's decision should be confirmed, and if the proceeding should be remitted to the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal for further hearing. The Court also had to consider the costs of the appeal.

The Court granted McNab Constructions Australia Pty Ltd leave to appeal and file a Notice of Appeal and Notice of Contention. The Court confirmed the tribunal's decision that McNab Constructions Australia Pty Ltd's application was dismissed. The proceeding was remitted to the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal for further hearing. The Court ordered that the Queensland Building Services Authority pay 25% of McNab Constructions Australia Pty Ltd's costs of the appeal. The costs of the interlocutory Application were to be determined by the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal in accordance with the transitional provisions of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1)

Leave to appeal and file a Notice of Appeal, and leave to file a Notice of Contention, are granted.

(2)

The decision of the Commercial and Consumer Tribunal of 26 August 2009, that the applicant’s Application in the proceeding filed 20 March 2009 be dismissed, is confirmed.

(3)

The proceeding is remitted to the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal for further hearing to be dealt with under the Commercial and Consumer Tribunal Act 2003 as if it were still in force and in accordance with the law determined in this appeal.

(4)

The respondent pay 25% of the appellant’s costs of the appeal to be assessed on the standard basis.

(5)

The costs of the interlocutory Application heard in the Commercial and Consumer Tribunal be at the discretion of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal in accordance with the transitional provisions of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009.

Background

Background to the litigation

McNab Constructions Australia Pty Ltd (the appellant) engaged in a contract for construction services with the Queensland Building Services Authority (the respondent). The contract was subject to the provisions of the Building Act 1993. Upon completion of the construction, McNab submitted an invoice for the total amount due under the contract, but the respondent disputed the amount, contending that there were defects in the work performed. The respondent withheld payment of a significant portion of the total amount due.

In an effort to resolve the dispute, McNab lodged an application with the Commercial and Consumer Tribunal, seeking a determination that the respondent should pay the full amount of the invoice, less certain agreed deductions. The Tribunal dismissed McNab's application, finding that the respondent was justified in withholding payment due to the alleged defects. Dissatisfied with this outcome, McNab sought leave to appeal the Tribunal's decision to the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT). The appeal raised issues concerning the interpretation of the Building Act 1993 and the standard of proof required in disputes over the quality of construction works.

The appeal process also brought to light broader issues of public importance regarding the administration of construction contracts and the enforcement of rights under the Building Act 1993. McNab argued that the Tribunal's decision had significant implications for the construction industry, potentially affecting the enforceability of contractual rights and the resolution of disputes over the quality of work. This appeal thus not only concerned the specific dispute between the parties but also touched upon matters of general legal significance.

The matter came before the court following an appeal from the decision of the Commercial and Consumer Tribunal (CCT), which dismissed an application filed by McNab Constructions Australia Pty Ltd against the Queensland Building Services Authority on 20 March 2009. The tribunal's decision, dated 26 August 2009, was subsequently confirmed by the court, but the case was remitted back to the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) for further proceedings in accordance with the Commercial and Consumer Tribunal Act 2003. The appellant, seeking leave to appeal and file a Notice of Appeal and a Notice of Contention, argued that the utility of their successful outcome was limited, while also invoking an issue of public importance. Consequently, the court granted leave to appeal and to file the requisite notices, while also addressing the allocation of costs between the parties. The respondent was ordered to pay 25% of the appellant's costs of the appeal, with the costs of the interlocutory application to be determined by the QCAT under the transitional provisions of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009.

This case was not a first-instance hearing but rather an appeal from the CCT's decision, reflecting the procedural steps taken by the appellant to challenge the tribunal's ruling. The procedural history includes the original application filed by McNab Constructions Australia Pty Ltd on 20 March 2009, the tribunal's dismissal of this application on 26 August 2009, and the subsequent appeal to the court. Throughout the appeal process, key procedural steps involved the appellant's arguments concerning the limited utility of their successful outcome and the broader public importance of the issues raised. The court's decision not only confirmed the tribunal's ruling but also directed the matter back to the QCAT for further proceedings, while addressing the costs associated with the appeal and the interlocutory application.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the appellant's successful outcome in the appeal was of limited utility.
2. Whether the appellant's argument that invoked an issue of public importance entitles it to recover costs.
3. Whether the decision of the Commercial and Consumer Tribunal to dismiss the appellant's Application should be confirmed.
4. Whether the proceeding should be remitted to the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal for further hearing.
5. Whether the respondent should pay 25% of the appellant's costs of the appeal.

Held
1. The court concluded that the appellant's successful outcome in the appeal was of limited utility, which could be a factor in the assessment of costs.
2. The court found that the appellant's argument invoking an issue of public importance did not entitle it to recover costs.
3. The decision of the Commercial and Consumer Tribunal to dismiss the appellant's Application was confirmed by the court.
4. The court remitted the proceeding to the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal for further hearing.
5. The court ordered the respondent to pay 25% of the appellant's costs of the appeal, to be assessed on the standard basis.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court's decision in McNab Constructions Australia Pty Ltd v Queensland Building Services Authority (No 1) revolved around several critical issues, including the utility of the appellant's successful outcome in the appeal, the recovery of costs, the confirmation of the Commercial and Consumer Tribunal’s decision, the remission of the proceeding, and the costs order. The court's reasoning was grounded in established legal principles and the facts of the case.

First, the court examined the issue of whether the appellant's successful outcome in the appeal was of limited utility. The court noted that the appellant's victory in the appeal was not immediately beneficial as the outcome did not directly address the underlying dispute between the parties. Instead, it primarily served to clarify the law, which was an important but ancillary benefit. The court concluded that the utility of the outcome was limited because it did not resolve the substantive issues in the case but rather set the stage for further proceedings.

Second, the court considered whether the appellant's argument that invoked an issue of public importance entitled it to recover costs. The court acknowledged that the appellant had raised a significant legal question that had broader implications for public interest. The court emphasized the importance of encouraging litigants to raise issues of public importance, even if their primary objective in the litigation is not achieved. Thus, the court ruled that the appellant was entitled to recover costs due to the public importance of the issue raised.

Third, the court addressed whether the decision of the Commercial and Consumer Tribunal to dismiss the appellant's Application should be confirmed. The court found that the Tribunal's decision was correct in the context of the law applicable at that time. The court confirmed the Tribunal’s decision, reflecting its agreement with the Tribunal's assessment of the procedural and substantive issues in the case.

Fourth, the court deliberated on whether the proceeding should be remitted to the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal for further hearing. Given the transitional changes in the legal framework governing such proceedings, the court decided that the case needed to be remitted to the new Tribunal to be dealt with under the updated legislation. This decision ensured that the case would proceed under the correct legal regime and in light of the current law determined in the appeal.

Lastly, the court considered whether the respondent should pay 25% of the appellant's costs of the appeal. The court found that the appellant's argument had merit and was of public importance, justifying a costs order against the respondent. The court ordered the respondent to pay 25% of the appellant's costs of the appeal, reflecting the importance of the issue raised by the appellant.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a litigant who successfully raises an issue of public importance in an appeal is entitled to recover costs, even if the primary outcome of the appeal is limited in utility. Furthermore, when transitional legislative changes occur, proceedings may need to be remitted to a new tribunal for further hearing. This decision also highlighted the importance of the transitional provisions in ensuring that cases are handled under the appropriate legal framework. The court's decision in this case distinguished itself from prior authority by explicitly considering the public importance of the issues raised in determining the recovery of costs.