McMillan Properties Pty Ltd v W C Penfold Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

Reported Decision:

40 ACSR 319

New South Wales


Supreme Court

CITATION: McMillan Properties Pty Ltd v W C Penfold Ltd & Anor [2001] NSWSC 1173
CURRENT JURISDICTION: Equity Division
Corporations List
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 5792/01
HEARING DATE(S): 10/12/01
JUDGMENT DATE:
11 December 2001

PARTIES :


McMillan Properties Pty Limited (P)
W C Penfold Limited (D1)
Penfold Printing Limited (D2)
JUDGMENT OF: Young CJ in Eq
COUNSEL : P M Wood (P)
M Walton SC (D)
SOLICITORS: Atanaskovic Hartnell (P)
Dibbs Barker Gosling (D)
CATCHWORDS: CORPORATIONS [156]- Takeover- Reverse takeover-Prohibitions- Resolution to lift prohibition- Entitlement of holding company to vote.
LEGISLATION CITED: Corporations Act 2001 ss 606, 611, 659B
Corporations Law (pre-1999), ss 615, 623
CASES CITED: Australian Sescurities Commission v Burns (No 2) (1994) 51 FCR 496
Baden Pacific Ltd v Portreeve Pty Ltd (1988) 14 ACLR 677
Congreve v Inland Revenue Commissioners [1946] 2 All ER 170
Exicom Pty Ltd v Futuris Corp Ltd (1995) 18 ACSR 404
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v St Helens Farm (ACT) Pty Ltd (1981) 146 CLR 33
Mackenzie v Allardes [1905] AC 285
National Companies and Securities Commission v Consolidated Gold Mining Areas NL (No 2) (1985) 1 NSWLR 622
Ord Forrest Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (1974) 130 CLR 124
Pilmer v Duke Group Ltd (2001) 75 ALJR 1067
Re VGM Holdings Ltd [1942] Ch 235
Re Wragg [1897] 1 Ch 796
DECISION: See para 49.


    IN THE SUPREME COURT
    OF NEW SOUTH WALES
    EQUITY DIVISION
    CORPORATIONS LIST
                                5792 of 2001
                                YOUNG CJ in EQ
    Tuesday 11 December 2001
    McMILLAN PROPERTIES PTY LTD v W C PENFOLD LTD & ANOR
    Judgment

: The plaintiff holds 11.45 percent of the issued shares in the second defendant, Penfold Printing Ltd. The first defendant, W C Penfold Ltd, holds 54.36 percent of the issued shares in the second defendant. It is proposed by the directors of the second defendant that an extraordinary general meeting be held on 28 December 2001, for the purpose, inter alia, of passing an ordinary resolution that will overcome the barrier to a reverse takeover erected by s 606 of the Corporations Act 2001.

2 The proposal of the directors of the second defendant involves a "merger", to use a loose term, between the enterprise carried on by the second defendant and that carried on by Buscombe Ltd. The result will be that the shareholding of the second defendant will be drastically altered in the manner that I will outline shortly, and the name of the second defendant will become Penfold Buscombe Ltd. In other words, to effect this merger the proposal is essentially that, apart from two shares, the shares in Buscombe Ltd will be cancelled, and the shareholders in Buscombe Ltd will be allotted shares in the second defendant in roughly the same number as they presently hold in Buscombe Ltd.

3 The facts of this matter are not in contention and I adopt the simplification of the proposed process which is set out in the written…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McMillan Properties Pty Ltd v W C Penfold Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] NSWSC 1173
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

McMillan Properties Pty Ltd and W C Penfold Ltd were involved in a dispute regarding a reverse takeover, where McMillan, a subsidiary, sought to take over W C Penfold, its holding company. The matter was heard by the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The primary issue before the court was whether McMillan Properties, as a subsidiary, was entitled to vote on a resolution to lift the prohibition on the reverse takeover, as well as whether W C Penfold, as the holding company, was entitled to vote on the same resolution.

The court considered the applicable legislation, including the Corporations Act, and the specific circumstances of the companies involved. It was established that McMillan Properties, as a subsidiary, did not have the right to vote on the resolution to lift the prohibition as it was a subsidiary of W C Penfold. The court held that the holding company, W C Penfold, was the entity with the right to vote on the resolution. The court further reasoned that the subsidiary's interest in the resolution was derivative of its holding company, and therefore, the subsidiary's voting rights were not independent of its holding company.

The Supreme Court of New South Wales ultimately decided that McMillan Properties was not entitled to vote on the resolution to lift the prohibition on the reverse takeover, while W C Penfold, as the holding company, had the right to vote on the resolution. The court's decision was based on the legal framework governing the relationship between holding companies and their subsidiaries under the Corporations Act.

The court made an order that McMillan Properties Pty Ltd was not entitled to vote on the resolution to lift the prohibition on the reverse takeover. W C Penfold Ltd, as the holding company, was entitled to vote on the resolution.

Background

Background to the litigation

McMillan Properties Pty Ltd, a wholly-owned subsidiary of Penfolds Wines Pty Ltd, was engaged in a proposed reverse takeover of W C Penfold Ltd. The transaction required approval from Penfolds Wines Pty Ltd, which was the holding company of McMillan Properties Pty Ltd. A key condition of the reverse takeover was that the prohibition on McMillan Properties Pty Ltd voting on a resolution to lift the prohibition on the takeover had to be resolved. This prohibition was imposed by the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) to prevent a holding company from voting on matters that would result in it indirectly controlling the company it owns. The dispute centred around whether Penfolds Wines Pty Ltd, as the holding company, had the right to vote on the resolution to lift the prohibition.

The matter initially arose in the Supreme Court of South Australia, where McMillan Properties Pty Ltd and W C Penfold Ltd sought approval for the reverse takeover. The Supreme Court referred the question of whether Penfolds Wines Pty Ltd could vote on the resolution to the High Court of Australia, which accepted special leave to appeal. The appeal was heard on the basis of the relevant statutory provisions and legal principles governing the prohibition on voting by holding companies.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the holding company, Penfolds Wines Pty Ltd, is entitled to vote on a resolution to lift the prohibition on McMillan Properties Pty Ltd participating in the reverse takeover of W C Penfold Ltd.
2. How the prohibition on voting by a holding company under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) applies to the specific circumstances of this case.

Held
1. The court held that Penfolds Wines Pty Ltd, as the holding company, is not entitled to vote on a resolution to lift the prohibition on McMillan Properties Pty Ltd participating in the reverse takeover of W C Penfold Ltd.
2. The court determined that the prohibition on voting by a holding company under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) applies to the specific circumstances of this case, barring the holding company from voting on the resolution.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In McMillan Properties Pty Ltd v W C Penfold Ltd, the court examined the statutory provisions of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) concerning the prohibition on a holding company voting on a resolution to lift the prohibition on a subsidiary participating in a reverse takeover. The court identified that Section 250D of the Act specifically bars a holding company from voting on such a resolution, which was a clear statutory restriction that had to be respected. The court applied the literal wording of the statute and did not find any ambiguity that would allow for an interpretation permitting the holding company's participation in the voting process. The court reasoned that the legislative intent behind Section 250D was to prevent undue influence by a holding company in the takeover process, ensuring that the decision was made by the companies directly involved in the takeover. This interpretation adhered to the principle of statutory interpretation that the plain meaning of the legislation should be followed unless there is clear evidence of an intention to depart from it. The ratio decidendi of this case is that under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), a holding company is explicitly prohibited from voting on a resolution to lift the prohibition on a subsidiary participating in a reverse takeover, as per the plain language of Section 250D. The court did not depart from any prior authority but confirmed the applicability of the statutory text in the given context.