SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Full Court)
MCMAHONS TAVERN PTY LTD v SUNCORP METWAY INSURANCE LTD
Judgment of The Full Court
(The Honourable Justice Duggan, The Honourable Justice Besanko and The Honourable Justice Anderson)
13 August 2004
INSURANCE - GENERAL - POLICIES OF INSURANCE - CONSTRUCTION
Insurance - construction - proximate cause - riot causing damage to hotel - business interruption clause included - whether loss of trade caused by riot - whether interruption of business caused by insured event - contra proferentem rule discusssed - whether quantum of loss assessed correctly - no grounds for interference with trial Judge's findings - appeal and cross-appeal dismissed.
In Re An Arbitration Between Executor Trustee & Agency Company of South Australia Ltd & Anor and the Liverpool & London & Globe Insurance Company Ltd [1936] SASR 365; Maye v Colonial Mutual Life Assurance Society Ltd (1924) 35 CLR 14; Johnson v American Home Assurance Co (1998) 192 CLR 266, applied.
PMB Australia Ltd v MMI General Insurance Ltd & Ors [2000] QSC 329; PMB Australia Ltd v MMI General Insurance Ltd & Ors [2002] QCA 361, distinguished.
MCMAHONS TAVERN PTY LTD v SUNCORP METWAY INSURANCE LTD
[2004] SASC 237Full Court: Duggan, Besanko and Anderson JJ
DUGGAN J: In my view the appeal and cross-appeal should be dismissed. I agree with the reasons of Anderson J and the further comments made by Besanko J.
BESANKO J: In my opinion, the appeal should be dismissed. Subject to some observations I wish to make, I agree with the reasons for judgment of Anderson J.
The appellant submitted that the Judge erred in failing to apply the rule of construction embodied in the maxim, verba chartarum fortius accipiuntur contra proferentem. It has been said that the rule is a rule of the last resort (In re An Arbitration Between Executor Trustee and Agency Company of South Australia Ltd and Another, and the Liverpool and London and Globe Insurance Company Limited [1936] SASR 365 per Richards J at 374) but it cannot be said to be of no value. There are a number of conditions which must exist before this rule of construction may be applied. First, the relevant words must be words (or words in an instrument) proffered by one of the parties. In this case, it may be assumed that the Industrial Special Risks Insurance Policy and the words therein were proffered by the respondent insurer. This condition is met.
Secondly, it must be shown that the provision, when fairly read, is to use the words of Isaacs ACJ in Maye v Colonial Mutual Life Assurance Society Ltd (1924) 35 CLR 14 at 22, “doubtful or ambiguous and reasonably susceptible of two constructions”, or to use the words of Mr Sutton, “ambiguous or obscure, or uncertain in application or misleading” (K Sutton, Insurance Law in Australia 3rd ed (1999) at 755).
The relevant clause in the policy is as follows:
“SECTION 2
BUSINESS INTERRUPTION
THE INDEMNITY
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read McMahons Tavern Pty Ltd v Suncorp Metway Insurance Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] SASC 237
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues were whether the riot constituted an insured event under the policy, specifically if the loss of trade was caused by the insured event. Additionally, the court had to determine whether the trial judge correctly assessed the quantum of the loss and if there were any grounds to interfere with the trial judge's findings. The application of the contra proferentem rule, which interprets ambiguous insurance clauses against the insurer, was also considered.
The court held that the riot was an insured event as it directly caused the damage to the hotel, which in turn interrupted the business operations. The contra proferentem rule was applied, and the ambiguity in the business interruption clause was interpreted in favour of the insured. The court found no error in the trial judge's assessment of the quantum of the loss, concluding that there were no grounds to interfere with these findings. Consequently, the appeal and cross-appeal were dismissed.
The Supreme Court of New South Wales confirmed the trial judge's decision and dismissed both the appeal and the cross-appeal. The insurance company was ordered to pay the insured the amount assessed by the trial judge, including interest and costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi