McMahon v Mount Isa City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:  

McMahon v Mount Isa City Council [2023] QIRC 346

PARTIES:

McMahon, Clair
(Applicant)

v

Mount Isa City Council
(Respondent)

CASE NO:

TD/2020/21

PROCEEDING:

Application for reinstatement

DELIVERED ON:

30 November 2023

HEARING DATE: 

22 February 2021
23 February 2021
24 February 2021

MEMBER:

Hartigan DP

HEARD AT:

Mount Isa

ORDER:

The application in proceedings TD/2020/21 is dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

INDUSTRIAL LAW – APPLICATION FOR REINSTATEMENT – where applicant seeks reinstatement – where applicant claims she was constructively dismissed – where the respondent raises a jurisdictional objection that the applicant was not dismissed – consideration of relevant factors – application is dismissed.

LEGISLATION:

CASES:

Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld), s 316 and 317

State of Queensland (South West Hospital and Health Service) v Crews-Bradley [2016] QIRC 34

APPEARANCES:

Ms C. McMahon, the Applicant.

Mr T. Wild of the Local Government Association of Queensland for the Respondent.

Reasons for Decision

Introduction

  1. Ms Clair McMahon seeks reinstatement to her former position as Human Resource Officer at the Mt Isa City Council ('the Council'). In the alternative to reinstatement, Ms McMahon seeks compensation and other ancillary relief.

  2. Ms McMahon's employment with the Council was terminated on 4 February 2020 following Ms McMahon forwarding an email to Ms Marshall, Manager, People and Culture[1] in the following terms:

    …

    Good morning

    I submit my resignation from Mount Isa City Council, giving 4 weeks notice which is 3 March 2020.

    Regards Clair McMahon

    [1] Exhibit 1 – Bundle of 18 Documents.  

    …
  1. The Council raises a jurisdictional objection to the application for reinstatement on the basis that Ms McMahon was not dismissed by the Council and accordingly, the termination of employment is not a 'dismissal' for the purpose of the Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld) ('the IR Act'). Relevantly, the Council contends that Ms McMahon's employment terminated at her own initiative.

  2. In addressing the jurisdictional objection, regard will also be had to the relevant factual matrix leading up to the termination of employment in order to objectively analyse the employer's conduct.

  3. Only if it is found that Ms McMahon was constructively dismissed by the Council, will it then be necessary to determine whether the dismissal was unfair, and if so, the remedy (if any) that should be granted.

  4. On 24 November 2023, an order was issued dismissing the proceedings. These are the reasons for that order.

Statutory framework and relevant principles

  1. As noted above, it is necessary to consider whether Ms McMahon was constructively dismissed. The term 'constructively dismissed' is not referred to or defined in the IR Act. The common law has developed a number of principles to be applied in determining whether a termination of employment amounts to a constructive dismissal.

  1. In State of Queensland (South West Hospital and Health Service) v Crews-Bradley[2] Deputy President O'Connor (as His Honour then was) applied the decision of Cook v CFP Management Pty Ltd where Williams JA (with who de Jersey CJ and Helman J concurred) at [17] wrote:

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McMahon v Mount Isa City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QIRC 346
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of McMahon v Mount Isa City Council involved Ms McMahon, an applicant who sought reinstatement to her employment position with the respondent, Mount Isa City Council. The dispute centred around Ms McMahon's claim that she was constructively dismissed from her position and subsequently sought reinstatement. The matter was heard in the relevant court which dealt with employment disputes.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether Ms McMahon's employment had been constructively dismissed, which would entitle her to reinstatement. This involved a consideration of whether the Council's actions amounted to a repudiation of the employment contract, thereby justifying a claim of constructive dismissal. Additionally, the court needed to address the Council's jurisdictional objection that Ms McMahon had not been dismissed and thus did not have standing to seek reinstatement.

The court carefully examined the evidence and the conduct of both parties. It concluded that there was no evidence to support the claim that Ms McMahon was constructively dismissed. The court found that Ms McMahon still had the opportunity to participate in the investigation and provide evidence in her defence, indicating that no impediment prevented her from continuing her employment. Furthermore, the court determined that the Council's conduct did not demonstrate an intention to terminate the employment relationship. Consequently, the court dismissed Ms McMahon's application for reinstatement.

In light of the findings, the court made an order dismissing the application in proceedings TD/2020/21. This decision underscored that Ms McMahon's claims did not meet the legal threshold for constructive dismissal, and thus, the application for reinstatement was not successful.

Orders

Orders of the court

The application in proceedings TD/2020/21 is dismissed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For completeness, it is also noted that Ms McMahon raised allegations with respect to the calculation of the termination payment. Given that this occurred after the termination of employment, it is unnecessary for me to consider whether such conduct amounted to a constructive dismissal. Conclusion In objective terms, I find that there was no impediment to Ms McMahon being able to continue with her employment at Council. Ms McMahon still had avenues open to her to participate in the investigation process and to provide evidence in support of her position. It follows that I do not consider that Ms McMahon was constructively dismissed. Relevantly, I do not find that the Council engaged in conduct that evinced an intention that it no longer wished to be bound to the contract of employment. Order Accordingly, I make the following order: