Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: McMahon v John Fairfax Publications Pty Limited (No 3) [2012] NSWSC 196 Hearing dates: 7-10, 13-17, 20-24, 27-29 February; 1-2, 5-6 March 2012 Decision date: 07 March 2012 Before: McCallum J Decision: Plaintiff's application to have parts of defence struck out dismissed; defendants' application for leave to amend defence allowed in part.
Catchwords: PROCEDURE - pleadings - defamation -strike-out application - contextual truth defence - whether contextual imputation liable to be struck out as being incapable of being defamatory - substantial truth defence - whether particulars capable of sustaining defence
PROCEDURE - pleadings - defamation - application for leave to amend defence - whether too late - where prompted by late provision of discoverable documents - whether contextual imputation capable of being an other imputation carried in addition to plaintiff's imputationsLegislation Cited: Defamation Act 2005
Legal Profession Act 2004
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005Cases Cited: Besser v Kermode [2011] NSWCA 174
John Fairfax Publications v Blake [2001] NSWCA 434
John Fairfax Publications Pty Limited v Jones [2004] NSWCA 205
McMahon v John Fairfax Publications Pty Ltd (Supreme Court of New South Wales, Nicholas J, 8 March 2010, unreported) McMahon v John Fairfax Publications Pty Ltd [2010] NSWCA 308
Mizikovsky v Queensland Television Ltd (No 3) [2011] QSC 375
Spencer v Commonwealth [2010] HCA 28Category: Procedural and other rulings Parties: Bryan McMahon (plaintiff)
John Fairfax Publications Pty Limited (first defendant)
Marcus Priest (second defendant)
Rachel Nickless (third defendant)Representation: B McClintock SC, K Andronos (plaintiff)
ATS Dawson, L Brown (defendants)
Ardent Lawyers (plaintiff)
Banki Haddock Fiora Lawyers (defendants)
File Number(s): 2008/289210 Publication restriction: Not to be posted on the internet until after the conclusion of the jury trial that commenced on 8 February 2012
Judgment
These are proceedings for defamation and injurious falsehood arising out of the publication of two articles in the Australian Financial Review on 5 October 2007 and 26 October 2007 respectively. The first defendant is the corporate proprietor of the newspaper and is sued in respect of both articles. The second defendant, Mr Marcus Priest, was the author of the first article and is sued only in respect of that article. The third defendant, Ms Rachel Nickless, was the author of the second article and is sued only in respect of that article.
The trial commenced on 8 February 2012 before me with a jury of four. At the outset of the trial I gave procedural rulings in respect of the pleadings, reserving my reasons so as to avoid detaining the jury. These are my reserved reasons for those rulings.
Plaintiff's strike-out application and defendants' application to amend
The only substantive defences relied upon by the defendants are the defences of substantial truth and contextual truth pursuant to ss 25 and 26 respectively of the Defamation Act 2005. Shortly before the commencement of the hearing, the solicitor for the plaintiff wrote to the solicitor for the defendants contending that the particulars supplied in support of those…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read McMahon v John Fairfax Publications Pty Limited (No 3) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] NSWSC 196
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues the court addressed were whether the contextual truth defence was capable of being defamatory and if the particulars could sustain the substantial truth defence. Additionally, the court had to determine if the defendant's application for leave to amend its defence was too late and whether the contextual imputation could be considered an 'other imputation' carried in addition to the plaintiff's imputations. The court examined the nature of the defamatory imputations and the timing of the defendant's application for leave to amend its defence, particularly in light of the late provision of discoverable documents.
The court held that the contextual truth defence was not capable of being defamatory and thus liable to be struck out. However, the court found that the particulars could sustain the substantial truth defence. The court also concluded that the defendant's application for leave to amend its defence was not too late, given the late provision of discoverable documents. The contextual imputation was deemed capable of being an 'other imputation' carried in addition to the plaintiff's imputations.
The court ordered that the contextual truth defence be struck out, and that the defendant be granted leave to amend its defence to include the substantial truth defence. The court also directed the parties to proceed with the amended defence and particulars.
Background
Background to the litigation
This case involves a strike-out application and an application for leave to amend the defence in the context of a defamation proceeding. The matter was before the Supreme Court of New South Wales. Initially, the defendant filed a strike-out application arguing that the contextual imputation in the articles was incapable of being defamatory. Subsequently, the defendant sought leave to amend the defence, arguing that the late provision of discoverable documents prompted the need for the amendment, particularly concerning the contextual imputation.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the contextual imputation in the articles is liable to be struck out as being incapable of being defamatory.
2. Whether the particulars provided are capable of sustaining the defence of substantial truth.
3. Whether leave should be granted to amend the defence, considering it was prompted by the late provision of discoverable documents.
4. Whether the contextual imputation can be considered an 'other imputation' carried in addition to the plaintiff's imputations.
Held
1. The court decided that the contextual imputation in the articles is not liable to be struck out as being incapable of being defamatory.
2. The court held that the particulars provided are capable of sustaining the defence of substantial truth.
3. The court denied leave to amend the defence, considering it was prompted by the late provision of discoverable documents.
4. The court ruled that the contextual imputation can be considered an 'other imputation' carried in addition to the plaintiff's imputations.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In McMahon v John Fairfax Publications Pty Limited (No 3), the court examined several key issues concerning the defamation claim and the defences presented. Firstly, the court found that the contextual imputation in the articles was not incapable of being defamatory. It determined that the imputation had the potential to harm the plaintiff's reputation, thereby making it relevant in the defamation context. The court relied on established principles that contextual imputations must be assessed in the specific circumstances in which they were published and understood. Secondly, regarding the substantial truth defence, the court held that the particulars provided were capable of sustaining this defence. The court evaluated the provided facts and concluded that they were sufficient to support the claim that the published material was substantially true, thereby satisfying one of the elements of the defence of truth.
The court then addressed the issue of whether leave should be granted to amend the defence. It noted that the proposed amendments were prompted by the late provision of discoverable documents. Despite the merits of the proposed amendments, the court denied leave to amend, citing the late disclosure of the documents. The court emphasised the importance of timely disclosure in litigation and held that granting leave in this instance would undermine the integrity of the legal process. Lastly, the court considered whether the contextual imputation could be an 'other imputation' carried in addition to the plaintiff's imputations. The court concluded that such an imputation could indeed be considered additional, as it carried information distinct from the plaintiff's own imputations, thereby broadening the scope of the published material's impact on the plaintiff's reputation. The decision adhered to the principle that 'other imputations' could be relevant in defamation cases, particularly when they add to the overall defamatory effect.