McMahon v Donnelly

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

McMahon v Donnelly [2024] QCAT 502

PARTIES:

LEICHELLE MCMAHON

(applicant)

v

ROBERT LYNDON GRAY DONNELLY

(respondent)

STEVEN SCOTT DONNELLY

(respondent)

KYLIE AMANDA DONNELLY

(respondent)

TRISHIA ANN DONNELLY

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

RSL011-23

MATTER TYPE:

Retail shop leases matter

DELIVERED ON:

8 November 2024

HEARING DATE:

On the papers

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member Howe

ORDERS:

The application for a retail tenancy dispute is dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

LANDLORD AND TENANT – RETAIL AND COMMERCIAL TENANCIES LEGISLATION – JURISDICTION, POWERS AND APPEALS OF COURTS AND TRIBUNAL – JURISDICTION GENERALLY – where the applicant applied to the Tribunal for determination of a retail tenancy dispute – where there had been mediation at the Queensland small business Commissioner but there had been no referral from the mediation to the Tribunal – where the retail shop lease had ended more than one year prior to the mediation – where the Tribunal therefore had no jurisdiction to determine the dispute

Retail Shop Leases Act 1994 (Qld), s 63, s 64, s 103

Stremo Pty Ltd v Opal Collections Pty Ltd [2011] QCATA 129

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

This matter was heard and determined on the papers pursuant to s 32 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act2009 (Qld)

Applicant:

Self-represented

Respondents:

Self-represented

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. The applicant Ms McMahon leased commercial premises at Kallangur from the respondents as lessors under a lease commencing 10 October 2015 and expiring on 9 October 2025.

  2. Though it is not clear, it appears Ms McMahon vacated the premises on or about 31 July 2019.

  3. On 15 February 2023 Ms McMahon filed a notice of dispute concerning a retail shop lease in the Tribunal. By the application she sought $77,846 from the lessors in respect of a number of items of claim.

  4. The application in the Tribunal was not referred by a mediator to the Tribunal pursuant to s 63 of the Retail Shop Leases Act 1994 (Qld) (‘the Act’).

  5. The Tribunal made the following directions on 18 September 2023:

    The Tribunal notes the existence of an email from Leichelle McMahon dated 27 June 2019 to Robert Donnelly reporting to terminate the lease with effect from close of business on 31 July 2019. The parties must file in the Tribunal and give to each other a copy of any submissions as to why the Notice of Dispute should not be dismissed having regard to the provisions of sections 63 (1b) and 64 (1b) of the Retail Shop Leases Act 1994, which requires any dispute in the Tribunal to have been Commenced not more than one (1) year after the retail shop lease has ended, by:  4:00pm on 15 November 2023.

  6. Ms McMahon filed submissions on 15 November 2023 in which she stated the lease was cut short when the building was robbed and burnt on 18 November 2018. She was asked by “Bob”, presumably Robert Lyndon Gray Donnelly, whether she wanted to continue with the lessor ended. Ms McMahon said she could not continue…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McMahon v Donnelly and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QCAT 502
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of McMahon v Donnelly involved a dispute over a retail tenancy in Queensland. The applicant, Ms McMahon, applied to the Tribunal for a determination of a dispute concerning a retail tenancy. The dispute arose after mediation at the Queensland Small Business Commissioner, but there had been no referral from the mediation to the Tribunal. Furthermore, the retail shop lease had ended more than one year prior to the mediation. The central issue for the court was whether the Tribunal had jurisdiction to determine the dispute.

The court found that the Tribunal did not have jurisdiction to determine the dispute. Section 64 of the QCAT Act specifies that a party to a retail tenancy dispute may apply to QCAT for an order to resolve the dispute, but only if the retail shop lease has not ended more than one year before the dispute notice was lodged. In this case, the lease had ended on 31 July 2019, and Ms McMahon applied to the Queensland Small Business Commissioner for mediation on 4 August 2021, which was two years after the lease had ended. The correspondence between the solicitors after July 2019 was on the basis that the lease had ended. The court referenced a similar problem in Stremo Pty Ltd v Opal Collections Pty Ltd, where the Appeal Tribunal had held that the Tribunal had no jurisdiction to deal with the matter if the lease had expired more than one year before the dispute notice was lodged.

The court concluded that the Tribunal did not have jurisdiction to determine the dispute because the application to the Queensland Small Business Commissioner was made more than one year after the lease ended, and therefore, the Commission could not refer it to the Tribunal.

ORDERS:
The application for a retail tenancy dispute is dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

The application for a retail tenancy dispute is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

By s 64:64 Application to QCAT—by party (1) A party to a retail tenancy dispute may apply, as provided under the QCAT Act, to QCAT for an order to resolve the dispute if— (a)any of the following provisions apply—(i)the party claims that another party to a mediation agreement has not complied with the agreement within the time stated in it or, if no time is stated, within 2 months after the agreement is signed; (ii)a mediator refuses to refer the dispute to QCAT because the mediator is of the opinion that the dispute is not within QCAT’s jurisdiction; (iii)a court has ordered that a proceeding started in the court for the dispute be removed to QCAT or another tribunal; and (b)the retail shop lease has not ended (whether by expiry, surrender or termination) more than 1 year before the dispute notice was lodged.(Emphasis added)Consideration In the matter at hand the lease ended on 31 July 2019. Ms McMahon applied to the Queensland Small Business Commissioner for mediation on 4 August 2021. That was two years after the lease had ended. Ms McMahon does not argue that the lease remained on foot after she vacated on about 31 July 2019. In responding to the direction to show cause why the application for a retail tenancy dispute should not be dismissed she said “the lease at … Kallangur was tragically cut short when the building was robbed and arsoned (sic) 18 November 2018.” The correspondence between the solicitors after July 2019 was on the basis the lease had ended. A similar problem arose in the matter of Stremo Pty Ltd v Opal Collections Pty Ltd [2011] QCATA 129 where the Appeal Tribunal said:[21] On a plain construction of the words in s 63(1)(b), the dispute must be referred to the Tribunal by a mediator if the section applies. Where the requirements of the section are not met, relevantly, when the lease has ended more than one year before the dispute notice was lodged, the section does not apply. There is no residual discretion which allows a mediator to refer the proceeding to the Tribunal if the section is not met. The provision is mirrored in 64(1)(b), whereby a party must apply to the Tribunal for orders to resolve a dispute either during the term of a lease, or within one year of it coming to an end.[22] In this case, there is no dispute between the parties that the lease expired on 10 September 2005. The dispute notice was filed by Stremo in the Tribunal in 2010. That is, the lease between the parties had expired more than one year before the dispute notice was lodged. The mediator referred the dispute to the Tribunal although s 63 did not apply because the lease had expired more than one year before the dispute notice was lodged. The mirror provision in s 64(1)(b) supports an interpretation that outside of these time frames, the Tribunal has no jurisdiction to deal with the matter. It is my view that the Tribunal does not have jurisdiction to determine the dispute before it. As mentioned, there has been no referral of the dispute from the Queensland Small Business Commissioner to the Tribunal. That is because the application to the Queensland Small Business Commissioner was made by Ms McMahon more than one year after the lease ended. The Commission could not refer it.