McKimm and Western Australian Planning Commission and Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

STREAM:   DEVELOPMENT & RESOURCES

ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)

CITATION:   McKIMM and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION & ANOR [2008] WASAT 128

MEMBER:   JUDGE J CHANEY (DEPUTY PRESIDENT)

MS R MOORE (SENIOR SESSIONAL MEMBER)

HEARD:   12 - 14 FEBRUARY 2008

DELIVERED          :   4 JUNE 2008

FILE NO/S:   DR 189 of 2007

BETWEEN:   ROGER McKIMM

Applicant

AND

WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION
First Respondent

CITY OF FREMANTLE
Second Respondent

Catchwords:

Town planning ­ Development application ­ Mixed use commercial and residential building ­ Proposal involving restoration and addition to heritage building ­ Whether proposed additions diminish heritage values of place ­ Impact of height, scale and design of additions ­ Proposal supported by Heritage Council subject to conditions ­ Heritage Council conditions requiring revision of design ­ Whether compliance with the Heritage Council conditions leads to substantially different purpose ­ Whether application capable of approval in present form ­ Adequacy of provision for parking

Legislation:

City of Fremantle Local Planning Scheme No 4, Schedule 12, cl 5.7.2, cl 5.7.3, cl 5.7.4, cl 10.5.1
City of Fremantle Town Planning Scheme No 3
Heritage of Western Australia Act 1990 (WA), s 11(3)(c)
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 124

Result:

Decision by First Respondent to refuse development set aside
Approval of proposed development granted subject to conditions

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant:     Mr MJ Hardy

First Respondent           :     Ms C Ide

Second Respondent      :     Mr C Slarke

Solicitors:

Applicant:     Hardy Bowen

First Respondent           :     State Solicitor's Office

Second Respondent      :     McLeods Barristers & Solicitors

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

McKimm and Western Australian Planning Commission & Anor [2007] WASAT 193

Phil Lukin Pty Ltd and Lowe Pty Ltd and Shire of Busselton [2006] WASAT 124

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL: 

Summary of Tribunal's decision

  1. Mr Roger McKimm applied to the Western Australian Planning Commission for approval of a mixed residential and commercial development on the site known as the Old Fremantle Synagogue on the corner of South Terrace and Parry Street in Fremantle. Buildings on the site are included on the permanent register of heritage places under the Heritage of Western Australia Act 1990 (WA). Mr McKimm's architect Mr Kirkness developed the proposal over a number of years. He engaged in detailed consultation with the Heritage Council of Western Australia and the City of Fremantle. Public consultation was also involved. Eventually, the proposal was supported by the Heritage Council subject to certain conditions. The Western Australian Planning Commission refused the application however, principally because of concerns expressed by the City of Fremantle. The City was concerned as to the bulk, height and scale of the proposed mixed use additions to the rear of the synagogue building. Although the City was not the decision maker for the purposes of the particular site, it was given leave to intervene in the proceedings because of its particular interest in the development of the heritage precinct within which the synagogue lies.

  2. The objections of the Western Australian Planning…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McKimm and Western Australian Planning Commission and Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] WASAT 128
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

McKimm sought approval for a mixed-use commercial and residential development involving the restoration and addition to a heritage building at 92 South Terrace, Fremantle. The Western Australian Planning Commission and others opposed the application, asserting that the proposed additions would diminish the heritage values of the place and the surrounding precinct. The dispute centred on whether the proposed development would adversely affect the significance of the heritage place, considering factors such as the level of heritage significance, measures proposed for conservation, structural condition, and the capacity for adaptation to a new use. The court examined whether the proposed additions would appropriately respond to the heritage values of the area, including the siting, scale, style, and form of the development.

The court considered the objectives of State Planning Policy 3.5 Historic Heritage Conservation, which aims to ensure that development does not adversely affect the significance of heritage places and areas. The court also evaluated the specific matters outlined in the policy, such as the heritage significance of the place, measures proposed to conserve its heritage significance, and the compatibility of the proposed development with the heritage values of the area. The primary concern expressed by the respondents was the effect of the height, scale, and visual complexity of the proposed addition on the heritage values of the synagogue and the precinct. Additionally, the court assessed the impact of certain elements of the proposal on the authenticity of the synagogue, the compatibility of the proposed use of the synagogue building as a restaurant with its cultural heritage significance, and the potential destruction of archaeological significance due to necessary excavations.

The court found that the application should be approved in accordance with the architectural drawings submitted, subject to certain conditions imposed by the Heritage Council. These conditions required revisions to the design to address concerns about the height, scale, and visual complexity of the proposed addition. The court determined that compliance with these conditions would not lead to a substantially different purpose for the development and that the application was capable of approval in its present form, provided that adequate provisions for parking were made. The court concluded that the proposed development, while involving alterations and additions to a heritage building, could be approved if it appropriately conserved and protected the heritage significance of the place and responded sympathetically to the heritage values of the area.

Orders

Orders of the court

For the forgoing reasons, we are of the view that the application to commence a mixed residential and commercial development involving conservation additions to existing heritage listed premises at lot 5, No 92 South Terrace Fremantle dated 2 May 2007 should be approved in accordance with the architectural drawings submitted with the application for planning approval entitled "McKimm Buildings (including former synagogue) 92 South Terrace

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

JUDGE J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: JUDGE J

State Planning Policy 3.5 Historic Heritage Conservation has amongst its objectives ensuring that development does not adversely affect the significance of heritage places and areas and to ensure that heritage significance is given due weight in planning decision‑making. It requires regard to be had to the conservation and protection of places registered under the HWA Act and to whether the proposal will adversely affect the significance of any heritage place or area, including any adverse effect resulting from the location, bulk, form or appearance of the proposed development. In addition, it specifies that regard should be had to the following specific matters:"Alterations, extensions, change of use or demolition affecting a heritage place (including a place within a heritage area)•the level of heritage significance of the place, based on the relevant heritage assessment.•measures proposed to conserve heritage significance of the place and its settings.•the structural condition of the place, and whether the place is reasonably capable of conservation;•whether the place is capable of adaptation to a new use which will enable its retention and conservation.Development within a heritage area•whether the proposed development responds sympathetically to the heritage values of the area as a whole and that part of the heritage area in the vicinity of the proposed development.•whether the siting, scale, style and form, materials and finishes of the proposed development responds sympathetically to the heritage values of the area. •the local planning policy for the heritage area including any places designated of heritage significance and the objectives and guidelines for conservation and enhancement of the heritage area." Clause 6.6 of SPP 3.5 identifies certain development control principles. It requires that development should preserve cultural significance based on respect for the existing building or structure. It requires that alterations or additions should not detract from heritage significance and should be compatible with the siting, scale, architectural style and form, materials and external finishes of the place. There was no issue between the parties, or the experts called by them, as to whether the type of considerations identified in SPP 3.5 should be applied, nor as to the importance of the preservation of the heritage significance of the subject site and the precinct in which it is located. The issue between the parties is as to whether there is an acceptable impact upon the heritage values of the place or the precinct in the proposed development. The respondents contend that the proposed development will have an adverse effect on the synagogue in particular and the area in general, in several respects. The primary concern expressed by the respondents is the effect of the height, scale and visual complexity of the proposed addition. A second concern relates to the effect of certain elements of the proposal upon the authenticity of the synagogue. A third issue is the compatibility of the proposed use of the synagogue building itself, namely as a restaurant, with the building's cultural heritage significance. Finally, there was an expression of concern that the archaeological significance of the convict elements may be destroyed by reason of the excavations necessary for the proposed basement to the synagogue building.