McKenzie v Cash Converters International Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

McKenzie v Cash Converters International Ltd (No 2) [2018] FCA 487

File number: NSD 601 of 2016
Judge: MARKOVIC J
Date of judgment: 11 April 2018
Catchwords: COSTS – where applicant not successful on interlocutory application against respondents – whether applicant should be required to pay respondents’ costs of the interlocutory application
Legislation: Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 43
Cases cited:

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Australian Lending Centre Pty Ltd (No 2) (2011) 283 ALR 299; [2011] FCA 1057

DSE (Holdings) Pty Ltd v InterTAN Inc (2004) 51 ACSR 555; [2004] FCA 1251

Firebird Global Master Fund II Ltd v Republic of Nauru (No 2) (2015) 327 ALR 192; [2015] HCA 53

Mitic v OZ Minerals Limited [2015] FCA 1152

National Crime Authority v S (1991) 29 FCR 203

Qantas Airways Ltd v Lustig (No 2) [2015] FCA 782

Date of hearing: Determined on the papers
Date of last submissions: 14 March 2018 (Applicant)
2 March 2018 (Respondents)
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Regulator and Consumer Protection
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 22
Counsel for the Applicant: Ms R Francois
Solicitor for the Applicant: Maurice Blackburn
Counsel for the Respondents: Ms E Collins SC with Mr C McMeniman
Solicitor for the Respondents: Herbert Smith Freehills
Counsel for the National Credit Providers Association: Mr J Pearson

ORDERS

NSD 601 of 2016
BETWEEN:

KIM MCKENZIE

Applicant

AND:

CASH CONVERTERS INTERNATIONAL LTD ACN 069 141 546

First Respondent

CASH CONVERTERS (CASH ADVANCE) PTY LTD ACN 127 866 308

Second Respondent

CASH CONVERTERS (STORES) PTY LTD ACN 127 343 293 (and another named in the Schedule)

Third Respondent

NATIONAL CREDIT PROVIDERS ASSOCIATION LIMITED

Intervener

JUDGE:

MARKOVIC J

DATE OF ORDER:

11 APRIL 2018

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The applicant pay the respondents’ costs of the interlocutory application filed on 23 December 2016.

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

MARKOVIC J:

  1. On 21 December 2017 I made orders in relation to Kim McKenzie’s interlocutory application filed on 23 December 2016 (Interlocutory Application).  By that application, Ms McKenzie sought the production of documents which had been discovered by the respondents, who I shall refer to collectively as Cash Converters, but withheld from production because they were subject to claims for legal professional privilege by Cash Converters or the National Credit Providers Association Limited, formerly the National Financial Services Federation Limited (NFSF).  The effect of those orders was to:

    ·require the production to Ms McKenzie of unredacted copies of two documents and a copy of a third document omitting a part of the redaction made to that document which had been the subject of a claim for privilege by the NFSF; and

    ·otherwise dismiss the application. 

  2. In other words, Ms McKenzie enjoyed no success as against Cash Converters but enjoyed some limited success as against the NFSF.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McKenzie v Cash Converters International Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 487
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of McKenzie v Cash Converters International Ltd (No 2) involved an interlocutory application where McKenzie sought to compel Cash Converters to produce certain documents. The central issue was whether McKenzie should be required to pay Cash Converters' costs of the interlocutory application, given that McKenzie was not successful. McKenzie argued that she should not be liable for Cash Converters' costs due to various reasons, including Cash Converters' alleged overclaiming of privilege and inadequate evidence.

The court considered whether McKenzie would ordinarily be entitled to her costs of filing the Interlocutory Application and preparing her evidence due to Cash Converters' conduct in overclaiming privilege. The court found that there was no obligation on Cash Converters to properly substantiate its claims prior to the filing of the application. Furthermore, the court rejected McKenzie's argument that Cash Converters was obliged to substantiate its claims with affidavit evidence such that those costs were not recoverable. The court found that Cash Converters was required to substantiate its claims for legal professional privilege over the documents in issue, and the costs of preparing that evidence were part of Cash Converters' costs to which it would ordinarily be entitled.

In conclusion, the court found that McKenzie should pay Cash Converters' costs of the Interlocutory Application. The court held that McKenzie had not provided any cogent reason why the usual order, that costs follow the event, should be displaced. The court found that McKenzie had been wholly unsuccessful in relation to each issue she raised against Cash Converters. McKenzie was ordered to pay Cash Converters' costs of the interlocutory application filed on 23 December 2016.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant pay the respondents’ costs of the interlocutory application filed on 23 December 2016.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

This case concerns a dispute between Ms McKenzie and Cash Converters International Ltd regarding the costs of an interlocutory application. The application was filed by Ms McKenzie seeking the production of certain documents from Cash Converters, which Cash Converters resisted on the basis of legal professional privilege. Ms McKenzie argued that she should not be required to pay Cash Converters' costs of the interlocutory application due to certain conduct by Cash Converters, including over-claiming privilege and failing to properly substantiate its claims. Cash Converters submitted that Ms McKenzie was required to pay the costs of the interlocutory application as she was unsuccessful on all material issues.

The matter came before the court on an interlocutory application filed by Ms McKenzie against Cash Converters on 23 December 2016. The application sought the production of certain documents from Cash Converters, which Cash Converters resisted on the basis of legal professional privilege. The interlocutory application was heard, and the court found in favour of Cash Converters, ruling that Ms McKenzie was required to pay Cash Converters' costs of the application.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Further:(1)contrary to Ms McKenzie’s submissions it is not the case that she would ordinarily be entitled to her costs of, and incidental to, the filing of the Interlocutory Application and the preparation of her evidence because Cash Converters over claimed privilege. There was no obligation on Cash Converters to “properly substantiate” its claims prior to the filing of the Interlocutory Application;(2)the submission made by Ms McKenzie that, whatever the outcome of the Interlocutory Application, Cash Converters was obliged to substantiate its claims of privilege with affidavit evidence such that those costs are not recoverable is misconceived. For the purposes of the Interlocutory Application, Cash Converters was required to substantiate its claims for legal professional privilege over the documents in issue. For example, in National Crime Authority v S (1991) 29 FCR 203, one of the cases upon which Ms McKenzie relies, Lockhart J said at 211:When questions of legal professional privilege arise in proceedings before courts there are well established procedures for dealing with them. The claim is asserted on oath and it is open to the court or the person who seeks access to the document or the answer to the question to cross-examine the person who makes the claim. …But it does not follow that the costs of preparing that evidence are then not recoverable on a “costs follow the event” analysis. Once an application challenging a party’s claim for privilege is made, the party whose documents are the subject of the challenge may wish to defend the claim and for that purpose provide evidence justifying the claim for privilege. That evidence is prepared and provided expressly for the purpose of the Interlocutory Application. That is what occurred here. That evidence is a part of a party’s costs to which it would, in the absence of some disentitling conduct not present here, ordinarily be entitled on a costs follow the event analysis; and(3)of the documents in issue between Ms McKenzie and Cash Converters there were only two documents in relation to which Ms McKenzie submitted that the Court would not exercise its discretion to inspect. I concluded that the evidence and, in particular, Mr Cooke’s evidence, sufficiently established Cash Converters’ claims for privilege, including in relation to those two documents. Having made that finding I inspected all of the documents as I considered it appropriate to do so. CONCLUSION For the reasons set out above, in my opinion, Ms McKenzie should pay Cash Converters’ costs of the Interlocutory Application. I will make orders accordingly.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ms McKenzie also submitted that a brief analysis of what might be thought to be the “usual” costs entitlement on an issue by issue basis supported her proposed approach. In summary, the matters she relied on to support that submission are:(1)that she would ordinarily be entitled to her costs of and incidental to the filing of the Interlocutory Application and the preparation of her evidence due to Cash Converters’ conduct in over claiming privilege. She said that, despite correspondence emanating from her solicitors since May 2016 and the filing of the Interlocutory Application on 23 December 2016, it was not until 28 March 2017 that Cash Converters filed an affidavit purporting to properly identify the basis of the claims for privilege;(2)whatever the outcome of the Interlocutory Application, Cash Converters was obliged to substantiate its claims for privilege with affidavit evidence such that those costs were required to be incurred by it in the ordinary course of being required to justify its claims and are not recoverable on a “costs follow the event” analysis;(3)in terms of the necessity of the hearing, there were real issues about the adequacy of Cash Converters’ evidence such that the Court had to inspect the documents because the evidence was not sufficient. This is not a cost that Ms McKenzie should bear. In other words, Ms McKenzie contends that a hearing was necessary due to “the less than adequate evidence filed in support” of Cash Converters’ claims for privilege; and(4)Ms McKenzie accepts that she did not have success on the most significant question the subject of the hearing being that of issue waiver. Accordingly, she submitted that, while it could be argued that Cash Converters is entitled to its costs on the question of issue waiver and Mr Cooke’s dominant purpose, it is not entitled to its costs of the argument about its inadequate evidence which required the Court to inspect the documents. CONSIDERATION Taking all of the relevant factors into account, contrary to Ms McKenzie’s submissions, this is not a matter in which I would order that there be no order as to costs. Ms McKenzie has not provided any cogent reason why the usual order, that costs follow the event, should be displaced. In my opinion, Ms McKenzie should be ordered to pay Cash Converters’ costs of the Interlocutory Application. First, while some of the documents the subject of the Interlocutory Application were provided to Ms McKenzie following its filing, Ms McKenzie pressed her application for production of the remainder of the documents. It was the issue of whether the balance of the documents were privileged which was before the Court for determination. Insofar as those documents were concerned, Ms McKenzie was wholly unsuccessful in relation to each issue she raised as against the claims made by Cash Converters. The documents that were the subject of an order for production, although discovered by Cash Converters, were subject to a claim for privilege by the NFSF, not Cash Converters.