DECISION
CITATION: | McKenzie v Body Corporate for Kings Row Centre CTS 11632 [2010] QCATA 57 |
PARTIES: | McKenzie |
| v | |
| Body Corporate for Kings Row Centre CTS 11632 | |
APPEAL NUMBER: | APL056-10 |
MATTER TYPE: | Appeal |
HEARING DATE: | Determined on the papers |
HEARD AT: | Brisbane |
DECISION OF: | Kenneth Barlow |
DELIVERED ON: | 28 September 2010 |
DELIVERED AT: | Brisbane |
ORDERS MADE: | (1) The order of the adjudicator made on 22 February 2010 be set aside. (2) I declare that paragraph 11.1 of by-law 11, and the words “other than a dog or cat” in paragraph 11.2 of by-law 11, in the community management statement of the respondent, are invalid. (3) Within 21 days of the date of this order, the respondent body corporate lodge a request to record a new community management statement in which paragraph 11.1 of by-law 11 and the words, “other than a cat or dog” in paragraph 11.2 of by-law 11, are removed. |
CATCHWORDS: | Body Corporate and Community Management – appeal from order of adjudicator – by-law of the body corporate prohibiting keeping of cats and dogs - whether by-law unreasonable – whether by-law valid – Body Corporate and Community Management Act 1997 (Qld), ss 169, 180 |
APPEARANCES and REPRESENTATION (if any):
Decision heard on the papers in the absence of the parties.
Introduction
This proceeding constitutes an appeal, pursuant to section 289 of the Body Corporate and Community Management Act 1997 (Qld) (the “Act” or the “BCCM Act”), from an order of an adjudicator made under Part 9 of Chapter 6 of the Act concerning the respondent (“Kings Row Centre”). The applicant in this proceeding is a co-owner of one of the lots in the scheme and, together with her co-owner (her mother), was the applicant to the adjudicator.
The application concerns by-law 11 of the respondent’s by-laws forming part of its community management statement. The by-law reads as follows:
“11. Keeping of animals
11.1Subject to s143[1] of the Act, no dog or cat of any kind is allowed to be kept within a lot, with the exception of those animals currently registered as approved by the Committee as of 18 January 2004.
11.2If any owner makes a request to keep a pet, other than a dog or cat, the Committee is authorised to grant or deny permission upon the receipt of a written application.
11.3If permission is granted, the details of the pet shall be provided to the Resident Manager for inclusion on the authorised list.”
[1]s143 of the BCCM Act was renumbered to s181 on 1 December 2003. By-law 11 was inserted on 20 March 2004. As the adjudicator noted, this appears to be an erroneous reference to s143 instead of s181. I take it to refer now to s181, as did the adjudicator.
By her application for adjudication, the applicant and her mother sought an order that the applicant’s mother be allowed to keep her cat within their unit. That application appears to have been filed in the face of a notice of continuing contravention of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read McKenzie v Body Corporate for Kings Row Centre CTS 11632 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2010] QCATA 57
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the reasonableness of the by-law under section 169 of the Act, considering whether the by-law was necessary for the proper management of the property and whether it was proportionate to the purpose it sought to achieve. Additionally, the court scrutinized the validity of the by-law under section 180 of the Act, assessing whether the by-law was consistent with the provisions of the Act and the community management statement. The court found that the by-law was unreasonable as it did not permit any exceptions for special circumstances, such as medical needs, and it was overly broad in its prohibition of cats and dogs without considering individual situations.
The tribunal determined that the by-law was not reasonable as it failed to provide any flexibility for special circumstances and was excessively broad. Consequently, the tribunal set aside the adjudicator's order, declared the contested provisions of the by-law invalid, and ordered the respondent to amend the community management statement accordingly. The tribunal also mandated that the body corporate submit a new community management statement within 21 days, excluding the contested provisions. This decision emphasized the need for reasonable and flexible by-laws that consider individual circumstances within community property management.
Orders
Orders of the court
(1) The order of the adjudicator made on 22 February 2010 be set aside.
(2) I declare that paragraph 11.1 of by-law 11, and the words “other than a dog or cat” in paragraph 11.2 of by-law 11, in the community management statement of the respondent, are invalid.
(3) Within 21 days of the date of this order, the respondent body corporate lodge a request to record a new community management statement in which paragraph 11.1 of by-law 11 and the words, “other than a cat or dog” in paragraph 11.2 of by-law 11, are removed.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi