McKenzie and Civil Aviation Safety Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

McKenzie and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2018] AATA 4258 (14 November 2018)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2018/5989

Re:Clinton McKenzie

APPLICANT

AndCivil Aviation Safety Authority

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Mark Hyman, Member

Date:14 November 2018

Place:Canberra

The application for a stay of the decision under review is refused.

........................................................................

Mark Hyman, Member

Catchwords

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – stay application – civil aviation - decision to suspend a class 2 medical certificate – dural arteriovenous fistula - neurological procedure – complex case management – considerations governing a stay - prospects of success – hardship – whether hearing would be nugatory – public safety – stay refused

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, ss 37, 41
Civil Aviation Act 1988, ss 3A, 30, 31A, 98

Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998

Cases

AMT Helicopters Pty Ltd and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2006] AATA 314
Griffiths, Grif-Air Helicopters Pty Ltd and Civil Aviation Authority [1993] AATA 274
Hodgson and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2009] AATA 632

McPherson v Civil Aviation Authority (1991) 22 ALD 754

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mark Hyman, Member

14 November 2018

  1. This decision is about whether a decision by the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA), the respondent, suspending the Class 2 medical certificate held by Mr Clinton McKenzie, the applicant, should be stayed. CASA suspended the medical certificate in a reviewable decision dated 16 October 2018. Mr McKenzie applied for review of the decision on 17 October 2018. On 21 October 2018 Mr McKenzie sought a stay order. The suspension decision prevents Mr McKenzie from flying; the effect of a stay, if granted, would be to allow him to fly pending his review being heard and determined.

  2. The tribunal held a hearing on 9 November 2018. Mr McKenzie, who is legally trained, appeared in person; Mr Anthony Carter appeared in person representing the respondent. He was accompanied by Dr Sanjiv Sharma, a Senior Medical Officer with CASA. Dr Sharma gave evidence to assist the tribunal to assess some of the medical evidence.

  3. The tribunal had available to it the documents submitted under section 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (the AAT Act) (these are known as the “T-documents”); various emails and letters between applicant and respondent; medical reports; a statement by Dr Sharma with an attachment summarising medical literature; a statutory declaration by Mr McKenzie, with attachments; and submissions by both parties.

    ISSUE

  4. The only issue before the tribunal is whether the stay sought by Mr McKenzie should be granted.

    LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK

  5. Section 41 of the AAT Act deals with the operation of a decision that is the subject of an application for review by the tribunal. Subsection 41(1) provides that, subject to the provisions that follow, an application for review does not affect the operation of the decision for which review is sought. Subsequent subsections allow departure from that outcome. Subsection 41(2) allows the making of an order staying or otherwise affecting the operation of the decision to be reviewed, in the following terms:

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McKenzie and Civil Aviation Safety Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 4258
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mr McKenzie applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal for a stay of a decision by the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) to suspend his class 2 medical certificate. The suspension was related to a dural arteriovenous fistula and a subsequent neurological procedure.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether to grant a stay of CASA's decision, considering the applicant's prospects of success, any hardship that might result from refusing a stay, and the public interest in air safety. The Tribunal also noted that while the suspension decision was reviewable, CASA's direction for Mr McKenzie to submit to a medical examination was not.

The Tribunal reasoned that Mr McKenzie's prospects of success were uncertain, despite a recent CT scan report suggesting no residual dural fistula. The Tribunal found that refusing a stay would not cause Mr McKenzie hardship or render the hearing nugatory. Crucially, the Tribunal considered there to be real questions of public safety involved, and that the utility of a stay was limited.

Consequently, the Tribunal refused the application to stay the decision under review.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The parties have raised the possibility that a stay might be granted with conditions, for example, that Mr McKenzie’s flying might be limited to daylight hours or that he might only fly passengers who have given consent after being informed of his medical history. There was discussion of these matters at the hearing. An outcome along those lines would clearly be second best for Mr McKenzie, but would allow him to keep flying. CASA appeared to put forward such an option only where for other reasons I might be inclined to grant a stay. As I am not so inclined, I have not considered the advantages and disadvantages of those options at any level of detail.CONCLUSION I regard Mr McKenzie’s prospects of success as uncertain, the refusal of a stay would not cause him hardship or prevent an effective hearing, there are real questions of public safety, and the utility of a stay is limited. Taking all the above matters into consideration, I refuse the application to stay the decision under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr McKenzie undertook further consultation with Drs Mews and Lalloo. Shortly before the hearing he provided a statutory declaration which included as an annex a report by Dr Lalloo of a CT scan (including both “limited CTB” and “dynamic CTA”), taken on 6 November 2018. In the report Dr Lalloo notes that “Limited CTB does not demonstrate any ICH [intracranial haemorrhage], left frontal infarction or hydrocephalus” and “Dynamic CTA demonstrates no evidence of residual AV shunt in the anterior cranial fossa.” The conclusion was “High quality dynamic CTA suggests no residual dural fistula”. I understand that “dynamic CTA” offers higher resolution and much more information than other forms of CT.CONSIDERATION CASA has argued that the tribunal’s jurisdiction extends to the suspension decision but not to the direction to Mr McKenzie to submit to a medical examination. That is indeed so: section 31 of the CA Act and regulation 201.004 of the regulations make it clear that the suspension decision is reviewable and the direction is not. Mr McKenzie has pointed out that an element of the decision to require a medical examination is legally somewhat dubious: the statement that CASA will be unable to take a decision until 12 months have elapsed would appear to have the effect that CASA has attempted to bind decision-makers in the future regardless of what evidence might be before them. Further, that appears to be at odds with the wording of subregulations 67.240(4) and (5), which contemplate that a person might bring forward information at any time and by so doing would oblige CASA to assess whether in those circumstances the suspension of a medical certificate should be lifted or maintained. As the direction is not reviewable, however, that is a matter for CASA. Applications for a stay take on a different character depending on the legislative context of the decision under review, and even under a single piece of legislation, in the different contexts of each matter. But in the aviation safety context it is well established[1] that an application for a stay comes to be considered in the light of three general considerations:a)the applicant’s prospects of success in the substantive review;b)any hardship that may result to those affected by the decision in the absence of a stay; andc)the public interest in air safety.[1] AMT Helicopters Pty Ltd and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2006] AATA 314; Hodgson and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2009] AATA 632; Griffiths, Grif-Air Helicopters Pty Ltd and Civil Aviation Authority [1993] AATA 274. The above matters contribute to determining whether or not a stay is “desirable”, as specified in subsection 41(2) of the AAT Act; that subsection also requires that the stay decision is one that the tribunal considers appropriate “for the purpose of securing the effectiveness of the hearing and the determination of the application for review”. Where the denial of a stay would render the review itself nugatory, that would provide a clear basis to consider the grant of a stay.