McKay v Mosman Municipal Council

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

Land and Environment Court


of New South Wales


CITATION:

McKay v Mosman Municipal Council [2005] NSWLEC 468

PARTIES:

APPLICANT
McKay

RESPONDENT
Mosman Municipal Council

FILE NUMBER(S):

10319 of 2005

KEY ISSUES:

Development Application :- alteration and additions to an existing semi
impact of setbacks and form on adjoining semi and conservation area
impact on privacy

LEGISLATION CITED:

Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979
Mosman Local Environmental Plan 1998

CASES CITED:

Galea v Marrickville Council [2005] NSWLEC 113

DATES OF HEARING: 26/07/2005
 
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 


08/31/2005

LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES:

APPLICANT
Mr G Newport, Barrister
SOLICITORS
Bowen & Gerathy

RESPONDENT
Ms J Walsh, solicitor
SOLICITORS
Pike Pike & Fenwick


JUDGMENT:

      THE LAND AND
      ENVIRONMENT COURT
      OF NEW SOUTH WALES

      Tuor C

      31 August 2005

      10319 of 2005 Makay v Mosman Municipal Council

      JUDGMENT

1 COMMISSIONER: This is an appeal against the refusal by Mosman Municipal Council (the council) of a development application (8.2003.321.1) for alterations and additions to an existing house at 28 Shadforth Street, Mosman (the site).

The site and its context

2 The site is rectangular in shape with a frontage of 6.96m to Shadforth Street, a depth of about 54.73m and an area of 290.6sqm. It also has a rear frontage of 6.0m to Somerset Street. The site has a single storey semi detached house which adjoins a semi to the north at 28A Shadforth Street. A two storey house, 26 Shadforth Street, adjoins the site to the south.

3 The character of the surrounding area is a mixture of one and two storey houses with some residential flat buildings of different architectural styles and periods. The majority are detached houses on larger sites in landscaped settings.

Background and the proposal

4 The application was lodged on 12 September 2005. Council notified the application and 8 submissions were received. The application was refused on 19 April 2004 and a request for reconsideration under s82A of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (the Act) was refused on 7 April 2005. The development application was amended prior to the hearing to delete the proposed garage and increase the landscape area.

5 The proposal is described by Mr M Robinson, the Court Appointed Expert, as:

          The DA seeks approval for demolition of the rear portion of the existing semi on the subject site retaining only the two front bedrooms, the entry corridor and a section of side wall, and construction of a new larger two-storey split-level rear extension. The site narrows slightly towards the rear, and the ground floor of the rear section of the extension is proposed to extend to both side boundaries to better utilise the narrow site. The new upper floor would sit in behind and slightly below the ridgeline of the existing roof, stepping down the slope of the site within the height plane in the RDCP and set in from the side boundaries and the rear of the ground floor. A small light court is proposed on the northern side of the cottage.

Planning Framework

6…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McKay v Mosman Municipal Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NSWLEC 468
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Land and Environment Court of New South Wales considered an appeal by McKay against the Mosman Municipal Council's refusal of a development application to alter and add to an existing semi-detached house at 28 Shadforth Street, Mosman. The proposal included a two-storey split-level rear extension, and the site is within the Shadforth Street Conservation Area. The primary issue was whether the proposal constituted an appropriate addition to a semi-detached dwelling within a conservation area, focusing on the side and rear setbacks, the form of the addition, and its impact on the privacy of adjoining properties.

The court heard evidence from two experts, Mr Mark Robinson and Mr Kim Jones, who provided differing opinions on the setbacks and the compatibility of the proposal with the adjoining semi and the surrounding area. Mr Robinson argued that the nil setbacks to both property boundaries and the reduced upper-level setbacks resulted in visual crowding and adverse visual impacts on adjoining properties, violating the objectives of the side setback control. Conversely, Mr Jones believed the proposal met the criteria for nil setbacks due to the site's constraints and the nature of semi-detached dwellings. The court ultimately found that while the proposal met the criteria for a nil setback to the adjoining semi, the nil setback to the detached house to the south was unjustified and resulted in overlapping windows, which was beyond the separation anticipated by planning controls.

Regarding privacy impacts, the experts agreed that the proposed measures would mitigate the privacy issues arising from the windows, balconies, and deck. However, the court found that the balcony off bedroom 3 had the potential to overlook the rear garden and swimming pool area of the adjoining property, which should be minimized. The court also considered the impact of the proposal on the adjoining semi and the conservation area. While the experts agreed that the proposal had no impact on the appearance of the semis from Shadforth Street, they differed on the compatibility of the proposal with the adjoining semi and the character of the surrounding area when viewed from the rear. The court concluded that the proposal's narrowness, asymmetrical, stepped, and flat roof forms, lack of side setback, and complex fenestration pattern made it incompatible with the adjoining semi and the conservation area, as it did not respond to the simple form of the adjoining semi or maintain the existing domestic character of the area.

The court dismissed the appeal and upheld the council's refusal of the development application, finding that the proposal was an inappropriate addition to the semis and would have an adverse impact on the Conservation Area. The orders included dismissing the appeal, refusing the development application, and allowing the exhibits to be returned, with no order as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established