McIntyre v Eastern Prosperity Investments Pte Ltd (No 6)

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

McIntyre v Eastern Prosperity Investments Pte Ltd (No 6)
[2005] FCA 155

CORPORATIONS -  deregistered foreign corporation – respondent to proceedings – interlocutory costs order in favour of corporation – costs to be payable forthwith – whether recoverable by corporation – effect of prior deregistration – continued existence of corporation as legal entity – capacity to be sued – entitlement to be represented and to seek costs orders – re-registration of deregistered foreign corporation – application for re-registration as fresh registration application – not made as application for restoration to register – adequacy of procedures to monitor applications for fresh registration by deregistered companies

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 601CD(1)
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)

McIntyre v Eastern Prosperity Investments Pte Ltd (No 4) [2002] FCA 1133 cited
McIntyre v Eastern Prosperity Investments Pte Ltd (No 5) [2003] FCA 254 cited
Chaff and Hay Acquisition Committee v JA Hemphill & Sons Pty Ltd (1947) 74 CLR 375 cited
Russian Commercial and Industrial Bank v Comptoir D’Escompte de Mulhouse [1925] AC 112 cited
Feng v GMS Fulfilment Service Ltd (2004) 50 ACSR 527 cited
Hansen v Millars’ Karri & Jarrah Co (1905) WAR 266 cited
Concrete Engineering & Contracting Company Ltd v Hardie Trading Pty Ltd (1928) SASR 132 cited

DONALD COLIN MCINTYRE (FOR AND ON BEHALF OF HIMSELF AND PATRICIA ANN MCINTYRE AND AS A REPRESENTATIVE OF THE GROUP MEMBERS REFERRED TO IN THE APPLICATION) v EASTERN PROSPERITY INVESTMENTS PTE LTD and DBF PROPERTY HOLDINGS PTY LTD AS TRUSTEE FOR THE FREARSON FAMILY TRUST
WAD243 OF 2000

FRENCH J
1 MARCH 2005
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAD243 OF 2000

BETWEEN:

DONALD COLIN MCINTYRE (FOR AND ON BEHALF OF HIMSELF AND PATRICIA ANN MCINTYRE AND AS A REPRESENTATIVE OF THE GROUP MEMBERS REFERRED TO IN THE APPLICATION)
APPLICANT

DONALD COLIN MCINTYRE AND PATRICIA ANN MCINTYRE TRADING AS VICTORIA PARK TRAVELWORLD (SHOP 24)
First Group Member

PAUL STANLEY SCRUTTON AND BEVERLEY MAUREEN SCRUTTON TRADING AS PHOTOMAT VICTORIA PARK (SHOP 20)
Second Group Member

DENNIS BEAUMONT AS TRUSTEE FOR THE BEAUMONT FAMILY TRUST TRADING AS INNERSPIN COMPACT DISCS (SHOP 8)
Third Group Member

KERRY GEORGE AND FREDERICK WILLIAM GEORGE TRADING AS THE HEART COFFEE LOUNGE (SHOP 21)
Fourth Group Member

PHIMCHAI SMITH TRADING AS PHUKET THAI RESTAURANT (SHOP 44)
Fifth Group Member

KENNETH JECKS AND IRENE FUSSEL TRADING AS PLAYFUL PETS (SHOP 31)
Sixth Group Member

ARMIN PODGORNY AND SABINA PODGORNY TRADING AS GOURMET AVIGNON (SHOP 33)
Seventh Group Member

DAVID THAMBIPILLAI  AS TRUSTEE FOR THE NEW DAY TRUST TRADING AS CURRY BOWL INDIAN TAKEAWAY (SHOP 45)
Eighth Group Member

BRENDAN REIDY-CROFT CEASED TRADING AS ZIPPY MULTI SERVICES (SHOP 47)
Ninth Group Member

MILAN SIMIC AND ANNA SIMIC TRADING AS MARTINS SKEWERS (SHOP 10)
Tenth Group Member

ALLAN AND HELEN LAWRENCE CEASED TRADING AS HAVA LOOK DISCOUNTS (SHOP 23)
Eleventh Group Member

KIM LIEN LAM TRADING AS FAIRY PATISSERIE (SHOP 26)
Twelfth Group Member

THIONG AIK GAN AND BEE TIN…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McIntyre v Eastern Prosperity Investments Pte Ltd (No 6) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] FCA 155
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

McIntyre v Eastern Prosperity Investments Pte Ltd (No 6) was an application by the plaintiff, Mr McIntyre, seeking to set aside a costs order made in favour of Eastern Prosperity Investments Pte Ltd. The case involved Eastern Prosperity, a foreign corporation from Singapore, and DBF Property Holdings Pty Ltd, which managed the Heart of the Park Shopping Centre at Victoria Park. The dispute arose from an earlier litigation where Mr McIntyre had commenced proceedings against both Eastern Prosperity and DBF. The court had previously struck out the statement of claim and dismissed the application, ordering Mr McIntyre to pay the respondents' costs.

The legal issues in this case centred around the validity and enforcement of costs orders against deregistered foreign corporations. Specifically, the court had to determine whether a writ of fi fa, issued to enforce a costs order against a deregistered foreign corporation, could be stayed pending the outcome of the application to set aside the costs order. Additionally, the case questioned the adequacy of the law and procedures in place for the registration of foreign corporations whose names had been removed from the register.

The court held that the writ of fi fa was enforceable against Mr McIntyre, as the costs order it was based on was valid and enforceable. The court found that the writ of fi fa related to the costs order made on 12 September 2002, which had been properly taxed and assessed. The court dismissed the application to set aside the costs order, noting that the deregistration of Eastern Prosperity did not affect its existence as a legal entity under Singapore law. As such, the writ of fi fa remained enforceable. The court further held that Mr McIntyre had to pay the first respondent's costs of the motion.

Consequently, the court dismissed Mr McIntyre's application and ordered him to pay the first respondent's costs of the motion. This decision underscores the importance of adhering to court orders and the enforceability of writs of fi fa against deregistered foreign corporations, provided the underlying costs order is valid and enforceable.

Orders

Orders of the court

On the applicant’s motion filed 30 November 2004:

1. The motion be dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the first respondent’s costs of the motion.

Background

Background to the litigation

In my opinion the applicant’s challenge to the costs order made in favour of the first respondent must fail. The case does throw up a question about the adequacy of the law and procedures in place in relation to the registration of foreign corporations whose names have been removed from the register. Procedural Background These proceedings were commenced on 22 December 2000. They were brought against Eastern Prosperity Investments Pte Ltd (ACN 065 747 006) (Eastern Prosperity) named as first respondent and DBF Property Holdings Pty Ltd (ACN 082 702 103) (DBF) as trustee for the Frearson Family Trust, named as second respondent. Eastern Prosperity was the owner of the Heart of the Park Shopping Centre at Victoria Park. DBF was the centre manager. On 12 September 2002, I made an order that the statement of claim be struck out and that the applicant pay the respondents’ costs of motions filed on 31 May and 4 June 2002 forthwith – McIntyre v Eastern Prosperity Investments Pte Ltd (No 4) [2002] FCA 1133. On 25 March 2003, I made an order that the application as a whole be dismissed and that the applicant, Mr McIntyre, pay the respondents’ costs of the application – McIntyre v Eastern Prosperity Investments Pte Ltd (No 5) [2003] FCA 254. An application for leave to appeal against that order was made and came before the Full Court on 13 August 2003. On Mr McIntyre’s application the hearing of the application for leave to appeal was adjourned after some argument. The Full Court directed that there be a limited pro bono representation arranged for the applicant by the District Registrar to provide advice in relation to the application for leave to appeal, possible representation and to appear in a mediation proceeding in relation to the appeal itself. In the event pro bono counsel was engaged but subsequently ceased to act. I am informed by the District Registrar that a mediation conference is to occur shortly. The application for leave to appeal has not been relisted. The costs which had been awarded on 12 September 2002, on the basis that they were to be payable by the applicant forthwith, were taxed and assessed at $4,700. A certificate of taxation was signed by a Deputy District Registrar on 19 November 2003. On 2 July 2004, a Writ of Fi Fa issued against Mr McIntyre in relation to those costs. On 30 November 2004, Mr McIntyre filed a motion seeking, inter alia, the following orders: ‘2.The Order for Costs extracted by solicitors Karp Steadman (sic) & Ross-Adjie alleged in favour of the First Respondent pursuant to the Order of Justice French on 25 March 2003 be set aside. 3.The Warrant of Execution issued pursuant to the Order for Costs including the land seizure notice being Writ of FI FA 214/2004 be stayed pending the determination of the relief set out in paragraph 2 above. 4.Costs be in the cause. 5.Such further and other Orders as the Court deems meet.(sic)’The terms of the motion suggest a misunderstanding that the writ of fi fa related to the costs order of 25 March 2003. However those costs have not been taxed. I will treat that part of the motion, which seeks to set aside the order for costs backing the writ of fi fa, as referring to the costs order made on 12 September 2002.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH J

Part 5A.1 deals with deregistration generally. It authorises ASIC to deregister a company if its annual return is at least six months late, it has not lodged any other document within the preceding 18 months and ASIC has no reason to believe it is carrying on business (s 601AB(1)). Section 601AD(1) provides that ‘... a company ceases to exist on deregistration’. That, however, has no application to a foreign corporation which owes its existence to the laws of another country. That conclusion is consistent with the authorities to which reference is made below. The Effect of Deregistration It may be assumed for present purposes that Eastern Prosperity, the first respondent, was deregistered on 28 February 2001 and has not validly been re-registered since. That assumption involves no finding about whether it is possible for a deregistered foreign corporation to get back on the register simply by lodging a new application for registration and obtaining a new ARBN. No finding about the validity of the fresh registration is necessary. That is because the existence of the first respondent as a legal entity derives from its incorporation under the laws of Singapore. It does not derive from the fact of registration under the Corporations Law or the current Corporations Act. As a matter of comity its existence as a legal entity by reason of Singapore law entitles it to recognition as such in this jurisdiction. In Chaff and Hay Acquisition Committee v JA Hemphill & Sons Pty Ltd (1947) 74 CLR 375, Latham CJ referred to the well established principle with respect to foreign corporations that a legal entity in one jurisdiction is by comity recognised as a legal entity elsewhere. He said (at 385): ‘The same principle is applied to the recognition of bodies created by foreign law which have rights and liabilities distinct from those of the natural persons who constitute them.’ Williams J said, at 396, quoting Lord Wrenbury in Russian Commercial and Industrial Bank v Comptoir D’Escompte de Mulhouse ([1925] AC 112 at 148-149):‘There is no question but that according to private international law and according to the comity of nations a foreign corporation is for many purposes recognized as a corporation here. It may sue and be sued here in its corporate name.’ In Feng v GMS Fulfilment Service Ltd (2004) 50 ACSR 527, a plaintiff sought re-registration of a deregistered New Zealand company so that he could sue it for damages for personal injuries. The application for restoration of the company to the register was made under Div 2 of Pt 5B.2 of the Corporations Act. In dismissing the application Barrett J held that the registration of the New Zealand company under the Australian Act was not a prerequisite to taking action against it. He said (at [12]):‘... it is simply not the case that the plaintiff’s ability to proceed against the defendant for damages is precluded or prejudiced by the absence of the defendant’s name from the register of foreign corporations kept under Div 2 of Pt 5B.2 of the Corporations Act. The defendant is a “legal entity in its own right” according to the law of New Zealand ... Such a corporate entity may be made a defendant in our courts whether or not registered under Australian statutory provisions with respect to foreign companies.’