DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2000] AATA 416
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL )
) No Q00/229
GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION )
Re PAUL ALEXANDER McILVANEY
Applicant
And MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
RespondentDECISION
Tribunal Deputy President DP Breen, Presidential Member
Date29 May 2000
PlaceBrisbane
Decision The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and in substitution therefor determines that the discretion under Section 501 of the Migration Act 1958 be exercised in favour of the applicant and that he be allowed to remain in Australia.
(Sgd) DP Breen
PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER
CATCHWORDS
IMMIGRATION – Visa cancellation – expectations of the Australian community – best interests of the child – ties to Australia – interaction with Section 200 of the Migration Act 1958.
Migration Act 1958 s 501
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Gunner (1998) 156 ALR 306
REASONS FOR DECISION
29 May 2000 Deputy President DP Breen, Presidential Member
This is an appeal against a decision by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs dated 8 February 2000 to cancel the applicant's Transitional (Permanent) Visa under Section 501 of the Migration Act 1958.
This case was heard before me on 15 and 16 May 2000. The applicant, Paul Alexander McIlvaney, represented himself. Mr D Kirchhubel of the Australian Government Solicitor's Office represented the respondent Minister.
Oral evidence was taken from the applicant; Mrs Samantha McIlvaney, the applicant's wife; Mr John Thain, the applicant's stepbrother; Mrs Christine Thain, the applicant's stepmother, and Mrs Anne McPhail-Thain, the applicant's mother. Evidence was also given by Mr Michael Moore, a family friend and Mr Kevin McDonald, a Correctional Services Officer.
The following documents were taken into evidence.
Exhibit 1 "G" Documents
Exhibit 2 Dossier of documents prepared by the applicant
Exhibit 3 Reference of Robert Ayers dated 6.5.00
Exhibit 4 Statement of Michael John Moore dated 9.3.00
Exhibit 5 Affidavit of Melanie Peta Parkinson and attachments
Exhibit 6 Affidavit of William Orril Rodgers and attachments
Exhibit 7 Memorandum of Lizabeth Ann Penery dated 3.12.99
Exhibit 8 Statement of Samantha Jane McIlvaney
Exhibit 9 Statement of John McIlvaney
Exhibit 10A Statement of Christine Susan Thain dated 11.4.00
Exhibit 10B Statement of Christine Susan Thain dated 22.4.00
Exhibit 11 Letter of Ann Thain
Exhibit 12 Bundle of letters in support of the applicant
Mr McIlvaney is 36 years of age and he arrived in Australia from Scotland with his family at the age of 9 years. He has resided in Australia since that time. The applicant's criminal history involves a few theft offences between 1980 and 1984 and then an attempted theft in 1992. No convictions were recorded in respect of these matters. He was convicted of a change of resisting Police in 1993. The sentence for that offence was suspended. The offence which forms the basis of the cancellation of his visa occurred in 1996. He was convicted on one charge of indecent assault with circumstances of aggravation for which he was sentenced to 7 years and one…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read McIlvaney and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Aff... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] AATA 416
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue in this case was whether the Tribunal should exercise its discretion under Section 501 to cancel Mr McIlvaney's visa, despite his failure to meet the character test. The Tribunal was required to consider three primary factors under Ministerial Direction No 17: the protection of the Australian community, the expectations of the Australian community, and, if applicable, the best interests of any children involved. Given Mr McIlvaney's criminal history, which included convictions for serious crimes, the Tribunal had to assess whether cancelling his visa was necessary to protect the Australian community and uphold community expectations.
The Tribunal, in considering the protection of the Australian community, acknowledged the gravity of Mr McIlvaney's crimes, which involved a breach of trust within a family and the violation of a vulnerable individual. The Tribunal recognised the significant trauma these crimes caused to the victim and both families involved. Furthermore, the Tribunal emphasised the importance of upholding the expectations of the Australian community regarding the character of individuals allowed to reside in the country. Balancing these considerations against the best interests of the applicant's children, the Tribunal determined that cancelling Mr McIlvaney's visa was necessary to uphold the integrity of the community and protect its members.
In conclusion, the Tribunal upheld the Minister's decision to cancel Mr McIlvaney's visa. The Tribunal found that the serious nature of his crimes, the significant trauma caused to the victim and both families, and the importance of maintaining the expectations of the Australian community justified the cancellation. The Tribunal's decision underscores the importance of protecting the community and upholding the character standards expected of those residing in Australia, even in cases where the applicant has personal ties, such as a parental relationship with children.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the court following the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs' application to cancel Mr McIlvaney's visa under Section 501 of the Migration Act 1958. The Tribunal was required to consider whether to exercise the discretion in favour of Mr McIlvaney, despite his failure to pass the character test. The Tribunal's decision followed the principles set out in the decision of Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Gunner (1998) 156 ALR 306. The Tribunal examined the relevant Ministerial Direction No 17 – Visa Refusal and Cancellation under Section 501, which outlines the three primary considerations for exercising the discretion to cancel the visa. These considerations include the protection of the Australian community, the expectations of the Australian community, and, where applicable, the best interests of any children involved in a parental relationship with the applicant.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Tribunal should exercise its discretion under Section 501 of the Migration Act 1958 to cancel Mr McIlvaney's visa, despite his failure to pass the character test.
2. What weight should be given to the Ministerial Direction No 17 – Visa Refusal and Cancellation under Section 501 in exercising the Tribunal's discretion.
3. How the three primary considerations outlined in Ministerial Direction No 17 – protection of the Australian community, expectations of the Australian community, and best interests of the children – should be balanced in making the decision.
Held
1. The Tribunal should exercise its discretion under Section 501 of the Migration Act 1958 to cancel Mr McIlvaney's visa, despite his failure to pass the character test. The court held that Mr McIlvaney's substantial criminal record and the nature of his crimes warranted the exercise of this discretion.
2. Ministerial Direction No 17 – Visa Refusal and Cancellation under Section 501 should be given considerable weight in exercising the Tribunal's discretion. The court found that this Direction provides clear guidance on how to balance the competing considerations in this case.
3. The three primary considerations outlined in Ministerial Direction No 17 – protection of the Australian community, expectations of the Australian community, and best interests of the children – should be balanced in a manner that gives significant weight to the protection of the Australian community and the expectations of the Australian community. The best interests of the children were considered but did not outweigh the other considerations in this case.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Mr McIlvaney's visa was cancelled under Section 501 of the Migration Act 1958. Section 501 is in the following terms:"(2) The Minister may cancel a visa that has been granted to a person if:(a)the Minister reasonably suspects that the person does not pass the character test; and(b)the person does not satisfy the Minister that the person passes the character test.…..(6) For the purposes of this section, a person does not pass the character test if:(a)the person has a substantial criminal record (as defined by subsection (7)); or(b)the person has or has had an association with someone else, or with a group or organisation, whom the Minister reasonably suspects has been or is involved in criminal conduct; or(c)having regard to either or both of the following:(i)the person's past and present criminal conduct;(ii)the person's past and present general conduct;the person is not of good character; or(d)in the event the person were allowed to enter or to remain in Australia, there is a significant risk that the person would:(i)engage in criminal conduct in Australia; or(ii)harass, molest, intimidate or stalk another person in Australia; or(iii)vilify a segment of the Australian community; or(iv)incite discord in the Australian community or in a segment of that community; or(v)represent a danger to the Australian community or to a segment of that community, whether by way of being liable to become involved in activities that are disruptive to, or in violence threatening harm to, that community or segment, or in any other way.Otherwise, the person passes the character test.(7)For the purposes of the character test, a person has a substantial criminal record if:(a)the person has been sentenced to death; or(b)the person has been sentenced to imprisonment for life; or(c)the person has been sentenced to a term of imprisonment of 12 months or more; or(d)the person has been sentenced to 2 or more terms of imprisonment (whether on one or more occasions), where the total of those terms is 2 years or more; or(e)the person has been acquitted of an offence on the grounds of unsoundness of mind or insanity, and as a result the person has been detained in a facility or institution." Mr McIlvaney's two convictions in 1996, which attracted sentences of 7 and 8 years imprisonment respectively, mean that he has a substantial criminal record and so fails the character test. Therefore, the Tribunal must consider whether to exercise the discretion in favour of the applicant, notwithstanding that he fails the character test. Ministerial Direction No 17 – Visa Refusal and Cancellation under Section 501 applies to the exercise of the discretion. There are three primary considerations under this Direction – protection of the Australian community, expectations of the Australian community and, where the applicant is involved in a parental relationship with any children, the best interests of those children. Considering, firstly, the protection of the Australian community, it is acknowledged that the crime the applicant was convicted of is a serious crime. It involved a breach of trust by a family member and the violation of a woman who was unable to defend herself. It is a crime which has caused significant trauma to the victim and to both families involved.