McGuirk v The University of NSW

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

Appeal Panel - Internal

CITATION: McGuirk v The University of NSW [2010] NSWADTAP 66
PARTIES:

APPELLANT
Gerard Michael McGuirk

RESPONDENT
The University of New South Wales
FILE NUMBER: 089076
HEARING DATES: 9 November 2009, 1 February 2010, 3 May 2010, 11 June 2010
SUBMISSIONS CLOSED: 11 June 2010
 
DATE OF DECISION: 

6 October 2010
BEFORE: Callaghan P, SC, Deputy President; Molloy G - Judicial Member; Bolt M - Non-Judicial Member
CATCHWORDS: Application for recusal - Bias – Perceived and actual bias – Systemic or cultural bias - Procedural Fairness
DECISION UNDER APPEAL: McGuirk v. University of New South Wales, [2008] NSWADT302
FILE NUMBER UNDER APPEAL: 073277, 083002, 083009 & 083019
DATE OF DECISION UNDER APPEAL: 10/05/2010
LEGISLATION CITED: Administrative Decisions Tribunal Act 1997
Freedom of Information Act 1989
CASES CITED: ASIC v. Segalla [2001] NSWSC 570
Bakarich v. Commonwealth Bank of Australia [2010] NSWCA 43
British Tobacco Austral Services Services Ltd v Laurie [2009] NSWCA 414
Ebner v. Official Trustee in Bankruptcy [2000] HCA63; 205CLR 377; 176ALR 644; 75ALJR 277
Enron Australia Finance Pty Ltd v. Integral Energy Australia [2002] NSWSC 753
Law Society of NSW v. Doherty [2010] NSWCA 173
Lee v. Cha [2008] NSWCA13
Livesey v. NSW Bar Association [1983] HCA 17; (1983) 151 CLR 288
McGuirk v. University of New South Wales [2008] NSWADT 302
McGuirk v. University of NSW [2009] NSWSC 1058
Refugee Review Tribunal; Ex parte H [2001] HCA28; (2001) 179ALR 425; (2001) 75ALJR 982
Re: Renaud; ex parte CJL (1986) 60ALJR 528, 161 CLR 342
Torchia v. Swanton [2010] NSWADT 142
University of NSW v. McGuirk [2006] NSWSC 1362
REPRESENTATION:

APPELLANT
In person

RESPONDENT
P Singleton of Counsel instructed by C. Kirby, University’s Solicitor
ORDERS: 1. Leave to appeal is granted
2.The appeal is dismissed
3.The stay granted by Needham DP on 18 March 2009 is discharged
4.No order for costs; save that should either party file and serve an Application for costs coupled with supporting submissions within 21 days, then the other party is to file and serve its reply and supporting submissions within a further 21 days, and the Appeal Panel will make a decision on the papers as permitted by the Administrative Decisions Tribunal Act 1975, s.76, unless persuaded that there should be oral submissions.


Application for Recusal

1 On 25 September 2008 matters Nos 073277, 083002, 083009 and 083019 came before Judicial Member Higgins . The first matter was listed for the hearing of an interlocutory application by the Respondent and the other three were listed for directions. These were all matters in which the Appellant was the Applicant and the Respondent University the Respondent. They were all applications made under the Freedom of Information Act 1989 (the “FOI Act”). At the commencement of the hearing on 25 September 2008, the Appellant made “a formal application that (the Judicial Member) recuse (herself) for bias or in the alternative apprehended bias”. There was no such written or formal Application before the Judicial Member; rather, the application was announced orally, and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McGuirk v The University of NSW and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NSWADTAP 66
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of McGuirk v The University of NSW, the applicant, Dr. McGuirk, sought a review of the University's decision to terminate her employment. The dispute was heard and dismissed by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT), and Dr. McGuirk subsequently sought leave to appeal the decision. The legal issues in this case centred around whether the AAT decision-maker was biased and whether there was a failure to observe procedural fairness. The primary concern was whether the decision-maker exhibited actual or perceived bias and if there was systemic or cultural bias within the institution, impacting the decision-making process.

The court examined whether there was sufficient evidence to substantiate Dr. McGuirk's claims of bias. The argument for perceived bias relied on the decision-maker's prior involvement in the proceedings related to Dr. McGuirk's employment. The court considered the principles of both perceived and actual bias, as well as the concept of systemic or cultural bias within the institution. Additionally, the court assessed if procedural fairness was adhered to during the AAT process. After thorough analysis, the court determined that the evidence did not support a finding of bias and that procedural fairness was maintained.

Consequently, the court granted leave to appeal but dismissed the appeal on the merits. The court found that while Dr. McGuirk had raised legitimate concerns, they were not substantiated by the evidence presented. The court discharged the stay previously granted by the Deputy President, ensuring that the original decision of the AAT remained in effect. No costs were awarded, but the court left the door open for either party to apply for costs within a specified timeframe, subject to the provisions of the Administrative Decisions Tribunal Act 1975.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave to appeal is granted

2.The appeal is dismissed

3.The stay granted by Needham DP on 18 March 2009 is discharged

4.No order for costs; save that should either party file and serve an Application for costs coupled with supporting submissions within 21 days, then the other party is to file and serve its reply and supporting submissions within a further 21 days, and the Appeal Panel will make a decision on the papers as permitted by the Administrative Decisions Tribunal Act 1975, s.76, unless persuaded that there should be oral submissions.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established