McGuigan v Workers' Compensation Regulator

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:        

McGuigan v Workers' Compensation Regulator [2017] QIRC 036

PARTIES:   

McGuigan, Stephen
(Appellant)

v

Workers' Compensation Regulator
(Respondent)

CASE NO:

WC/2015/294

PROCEEDING:

Appeal against a decision of Workers' Compensation Regulator

DELIVERED ON:

28 April 2017

HEARING DATES: 

20 and 21 March 2017

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

MEMBER:

Industrial Commissioner Thompson
ORDERS:

1.   The Appeal is upheld.

2. The decision of the Respondent to reject the Appellant's application for compensation in accordance with s 32(5)(a) of the Act is set aside.

3.   The claim is one for acceptance.

4.   The Respondent is to pay the Appellant's costs of and incidental to the Appeal.

CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS' COMPENSATION ‑ APPEAL AGAINST DECISION ‑ Decision of Workers' Compensation Regulator ‑ Appellant bears onus of proof ‑ Standard of proof ‑ Balance of probabilities ‑ Witness evidence - Whether personal injury is excluded or otherwise from being a compensable injury through the provisions of s 32(5) (a) of the Act - Personal injury - Disciplinary process - Unreasonable change of status - Medical evidence - Causal connection with employment - Personal injury arose out of or in the course of employment - Employment was the major significant contributing factor - Personal injury is compensable - Unreasonable management action
- Appeal upheld - Decision of the Respondent to reject application for compensation is set aside - Claim is one for acceptance - Respondent to pay Appellant's costs of and incidental to the Appeal.

CASES:

Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003, s 11, s 32, s 550
Coal Mining Safety and Health Act 1999
Coal Mining Safety and Health Regulation 1999
Qantas Airways Limited v Q-COMP (2006) 181 QGIG 301
Labaj v WorkCover Queensland (2005) 174 QGIG 370
McDonald v Q-COMP (2008) 188 QGIG 180
Mission Australia v Q-COMP (unreported, Industrial Magistrates Court of Queensland, Lee IM, 26 July 2010)

MacArthur v WorkCover Queensland (2001) 167 QGIG 100

Nilsson v Q-COMP (2008) 189 QGIG 523
Lawnton v Simon Blackwood (Workers' Compensation Regulator) [2015] QIRC 99
Willie v Q-COMP (2009) 190 QGIG 233
Eric Martin Rossmuller v Q-COMP (C/2009/36) - Decision - < v Q-COMP (C/2009/29) - Decision - <

APPEARANCES:

Mr R. Myers of Counsel, instructed by Hall Payne Lawyers for the Appellant.
Mr J. Merrell, Counsel directly instructed by Workers' Compensation Regulator, the Respondent.

Amended Decision

  1. Stephen McGuigan (McGuigan) on 25 November 2015 lodged a Notice of Appeal with the Industrial Registrar pursuant to s 550 of the Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 (the Act) against a decision of the Workers' Compensation Regulator (the Regulator) released on 19 November 2015. The decision of the Regulator was to confirm the decision of Glencore [XtraCare] to reject McGuigan's application for compensation in accordance with s 32(5) of the Act.

    Relevant Legislation

  1. The Legislation pertinent at the time of this Appeal is s 32 of the Act:

    "32    Meaning of injury

    (1)An injury is personal injury arising out of, or in the course of, employment if -

    …

    (b)for a psychiatric or psychological…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McGuigan v Workers' Compensation Regulator and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] QIRC 36
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

McGuigan sought to appeal a decision by the Workers' Compensation Regulator, who had rejected his application for workers' compensation in relation to a personal injury he suffered on 1 September 2014. The Regulator had concluded that the personal injury was excluded from being a compensable injury because it arose out of reasonable management action taken in a reasonable way in connection with his employment. The appeal was heard by the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal.

The central legal issues in the appeal were whether the personal injury suffered by McGuigan was excluded from being a compensable injury under s 32(5)(a) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987, because the management action taken was reasonable and done in a reasonable way in connection with his employment, and whether the personal injury was excluded under s 32(5)(b) of the Act because McGuigan's perception of reasonable management action taken against him contributed to the injury. The appeal hinged on whether the Regulator's findings were supported by the evidence and whether the Regulator had properly applied the relevant statutory provisions.

The Tribunal found that the Regulator's decision was not supported by the evidence. The key evidence from McGuigan's treating psychiatrist, Dr Jenkins, established that the personal injury was directly caused by the event on 1 September 2014, when McGuigan was directed to undertake work at the coalface despite not having completed the necessary training. The Tribunal also found that the management action taken by the employer was unreasonable, given the potential safety risks involved. The Tribunal concluded that the personal injury was compensable because it arose out of or in the course of McGuigan's employment and the employment was a significant contributing factor.

The appeal was therefore upheld, and the Regulator's decision to reject McGuigan's application for compensation was set aside. The Tribunal ordered that McGuigan's claim was one for acceptance and that the Regulator was to pay McGuigan's costs of and incidental to the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Appeal is upheld.

2. The decision of the Respondent to reject the Appellant's application for compensation in accordance with s 32(5)(a) of the Act is set aside.

3. The claim is one for acceptance.

4. The Respondent is to pay the Appellant's costs of and incidental to the Appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Regulator argued that the transfer option was reasonably open to the employer and any causal connection between the injury and McGuigan's employment was as a result of his perception of reasonable management action taken against him.Medical Evidence Dr Jenkins the treating psychiatrist of McGuigan having first seen him on 17 October 2014. A diagnosis of an adjustment disorder with anxiety was made by him with the incident causative of the personal injury occurring on 1 September 2014. In the course of consultations McGuigan had discussed other stressors that had caused him some difficulty however Dr Jenkins remained of the view that the "trigger" for his decompensation was the 1 September 2014 event. In correspondence [Exhibit 7] (dated 6 November 2015) Dr Jenkins stated the following: The Regulator based on the content of McGuigan's statement [Exhibit 6] had grounds to question whether there were other stressors in play other than the 1 September 2014 event however the unchallenged medical evidence of Dr Jenkins is significant in the circumstances to allow for acceptance by the Commission that the causal connection between McGuigan's decompensation and his employment is confined to the event of 1 September 2014. Dr Jenkins whose evidence remained largely undisturbed in the course of cross-examination, did in the course of that facet of his evidence acknowledge there were other workplace issues that contributed to McGuigan's condition but they were not the final precipitating factors. Dr Jenkins findings were based upon information provided to him by McGuigan with acknowledgement of no independent verification however as his treating psychiatrist since October 2014 he was well placed to make findings based upon clinical evidence and the information provided by McGuigan. In the course of the proceedings certain factual matters were established that included: In essence taking into account the abovementioned factual evidence the question is whether it was reasonable management action taken in a reasonable way for McGuigan to be directed by his supervisor to undertake work at the coalface despite the fact that he had declined to complete a No Go Zone assessment, which was in effect a mandatory requirement for undertaking such work, because the training package contained inaccurate information pertaining to the minimum distances that must be observed when a shuttle car is in the operation. Further was it reasonable management action to direct McGuigan to initial the paperwork acknowledging that the No Go Zone information in the training package provided by the employer was incorrect but to complete the assessment in any event. In an industry where workplace health and safety is considered paramount to the extent there exists legislation in the form of the Coal Mining Safety and Health Act 1999 that specifically regulates the health and safety of the coal mining industry on a standalone basis, and in this particular case where the consequences of being provided with inaccurate information by the employer regarding the minimum distances to be observed when working in proximity to shuttle cars could lead to injury or possibly death surely the more appropriate approach would have been to obtain the correct information applicable to the distances in question and have the assessment completed under those circumstances.

Decision

Reasons for decision

McGuigan had in his evidence linked the disciplinary action and transfer to the D3 crew to his stress and decompensation. The question of whether the injury is withdrawn because of reasonable management action taken in a reasonable way in connection with his employment becomes a mixed question of fact and medicine.Conclusion The Regulator in the course of the proceeding conceded that in the case of McGuigan: The matter for determination was of relatively short compass being whether the personal injury suffered by McGuigan is excluded or otherwise from being a compensable injury through the provisions of s 32(5)(a) of the Act in that the management action taken was reasonable management action taken in a reasonable way in connection with the employment. Alternatively excluded or otherwise through the provisions of s 32(5)(b) of the Act being McGuigan's expectation or perception of reasonable management action taken against him. The case prosecuted by McGuigan related solely to his decompensation occurring on 1 September 2014 following a direction from his immediate supervisor (Gulliver) that he was to proceed to the coalface to undertake work despite not having completed No Go Zone authorisation refresher training for that specific area. McGuigan had taken issue with training material [Exhibit 1] provided to him that was in conflict with the content of the assessment documentation he was required to complete and the eventual instruction from management was to initial that he understood the distances in the training paperwork were incorrect and effectively commence work underground without having been properly assessed as competent in No Go Zone distances. The assessment document [Exhibit 2] defined competent as being: The Regulator accepted that the event of 1 September 2014 when McGuigan was directed to undertake work at the coalface had a causal connection to the personal injury suffered by him however notwithstanding the inconsistencies with the No Go Zone paperwork as it applied to the shuttle car, proffered the management action was reasonable and taken in a reasonable way in connection with the employment. The Regulator's view on the causal connection between work and the personal injury included the 1 September 2014 event and also encompassed both the disciplinary process of early August 2014 and the transfer to the D3 crew at the end of that month. In respect of the additional events the Regulator cited a statement [Exhibit 6] prepared by McGuigan (dated 10 June 2015) as part of the workers' compensation claim process in which he made reference to the cause of his stress having been a combination of factors that had occurred over time including some just prior to the cessation of work on 1 September 2014. The report identified three events as distal factors he considered had contributed to his stress over time. Those being:· use of house;· investigation into the multigrip safety event; and· allegations regarding company sensitive information.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.