McGrath and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

McGrath and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 3719 (14 November 2023)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):2021/6434      

Re:Erin McGrath

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:The Honourable Pru Goward AO, Senior Member

Date:14 November 2023

Place:Sydney

Pursuant to subsection 43(1)(b) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), the Tribunal varies the decision under review of the Chief Executive Officer of the National Disability Insurance Agency (dated 23 May 2023) to include the following reasonable and necessary supports in the Applicant’s plan:

a)     2 hours of psychology and counselling therapy a week;

b)    4 hours per month for yard maintenance in the Applicant’s current living circumstances;

c)    3 hours per week of domestic cleaning;

...............................[SGD].....................................

The Honourable Pru Goward AO, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – application for recusal – reasonable and necessary supports – value for money – effective and beneficial – reimbursement – specialist disability accommodation – medium term accommodation – decision varied

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) s 43(1)(b)
National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) ss 34, 100
National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013 (Cth)

CASES

BIJD and National Disability Insurance Agency [2018] AATA 2971
McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency (2017) 252 FCR 121
Mulligan v National Disability Insurance Agency (2015) 233 FCR 201
National Disability Insurance Agency v WRMF (2020) 378 ALR 449

SECONDARY MATERIALS

NDIS Operational Guidelines Planning

REASONS FOR DECISION

The Honourable Pru Goward AO, Senior Member

14 November 2023

INTRODUCTION

  1. Ms Erin McGrath (the Applicant), is a thirty-six year old woman with a diagnosis of secondary progressive multiple sclerosis (MS), Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD), psycho-social disability (PTSD and major depressive disorder with anxious distress) and Attention-Deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD).

  2. The Applicant has been a participant of the National Disability Insurance Scheme (the Scheme) since 2020. The National Disability Insurance Agency (the Respondent) approved a Statement of Participant’s Supports (SOPS) for the Applicant on 31 August 2021. She requested an internal review of that decision under s 100(2) of the NDIS Act on 10 September 2021 and also sought review by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) on the same day. On 23 September 2021, the Tribunal remitted the matter to the Respondent and pursuant to this order, a plan was approved on 1 October 2021, which included the specification that all supports other than a financial intermediary would be plan managed.

  3. Over the following eighteen months, the parties negotiated further supports. On 12 May 2023, the Respondent filed s 42D Terms of Agreement with the Tribunal, agreed to by the Applicant. On 23 May 2023, the Respondent made a decision on remittal under s 42D of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (the AAT Act) to provide additional supports.

  4. The Applicant sought review by the Tribunal of the 23 May 2023 decision pursuant to s 42D(3) (b) of the AAT Act, the decision under review. There were 19 requested supports contended.

  5. On 21 August…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McGrath and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 3719
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Ms Erin McGrath against the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) regarding the NDIA's decision to refuse funding for 18 requested supports. The dispute centred on whether these supports were "reasonable and necessary" within the meaning of section 34(1) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth). The Tribunal considered various documentary evidence and heard oral evidence from the applicant, her counsellor, general practitioner, support person, and occupational therapist.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were to determine, for each of the 18 refused supports, whether they met the criteria of being reasonable and necessary. This involved assessing whether the supports were for a disability-related need, whether they represented value for money, whether they were effective and beneficial, and whether they duplicated other supports or were simply day-to-day living costs. Specifically, the Tribunal had to consider the NDIA's contention that an internet connection for a seizure camera was duplicative of existing SIL funding and that cheaper alternatives might exist, as well as the NDIA's argument that internet access is a general living cost.

The Tribunal reasoned that for the internet connection, while the applicant's seizure-like activity was a genuine concern, the evidence did not sufficiently establish the necessity of this specific support. The NDIA argued that the applicant's SIL funding already covered 24/7 active overnight support for seizure activity and that no evidence of cheaper alternatives or an epilepsy management plan had been provided. The Tribunal also noted the lack of a formal epilepsy diagnosis, with medical professionals describing the condition as "seizure-like" or "migraine associated epilepsy type disorder." Furthermore, the Tribunal considered the internet connection to be a day-to-day living cost, which is excluded from NDIS funding under Rule 5.1(d) of the NDIS Support Rules.

Ultimately, the Tribunal found that while the applicant's concerns were genuinely held, some of her requested supports were not sufficiently evidenced as reasonable and necessary. However, the Tribunal did find that specific supports, namely psychology and counselling therapy for two hours per week, four hours per month of yard work, and three hours per week of cleaning, met the criteria of being reasonable and necessary under section 34(1) of the Act, accepting evidence of some deterioration in the applicant's health. The Tribunal also concluded that the applicant's claim for reimbursement of rent was not substantiated, finding that the NDIA had de facto paid her rent through other means, and that the amount claimed was not demonstrably accurate.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Tribunal has had regard to various material before it, including: (a)Respondent’s Updated Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions (filed 1 September 2023)(b)Respondent’s Joint Tender Bundle (filed 1 September 2023)(c)Statement of Kelly Watson dated 12 September 2023(d)Email correspondence between Applicant and Respondent regarding medium term accommodation filed 13 September 2023(e)Letter from Associate Professor Chris Plummer dated 19 October 2020(f)Letter from Associate Professor Chris Plummer to Dr Sabyan Hardjo dated 1 March 2023(g)Compilation of electricity and gas bills from Applicant filed 17 September 2023 (h)Respondent’s submissions in response to Tribunal’s request for further information filed 12 October 2023 (i)Email from Respondent containing further submissions filed 25 October 2023(j)Applicant’s closing arguments filed on 1 November 2023(k)Invoices for Applicants rent filed on 31 October 2023(l)Email correspondence between Applicant and Tribunal regarding rent (1 November 2023)Oral evidence The Tribunal heard oral evidence from the following witnesses:a)Ms Erin McGrath, the Applicantb)Ms Sally Cooper, Counsellor c)Dr Sabyan Hardjo, General Practitionerd)Ms Kelly Watson, Support Person, e)Ms Amber Joules, Occupational TherapistCONSIDERATION There were 18 requested supports which the Respondent considered were not reasonable and necessary and therefore did not meet the requirements of s 34 (1) of the Act. The Tribunal examines the evidence and makes findings on each proposed support in the paragraphs which follow.Internet connection at property-$1,425 ($75 per month for 19 months). The Applicant has sought ongoing funding for an internet connection on the basis that this was required for a seizure camera linked to an IPad. The Applicant stated that the seizure camera allows her support team to monitor her and reduce risk. She requires the camera whilst support staff are doing active overnights to prevent harm and to be able to assist immediately in case of emergency, without being in the bedroom with her while she slept. The Respondent contended this support duplicates other supports (Rule 5.1 (c) because the Applicant’s SIL funding already provides 24/7 active overnight support for seizure activity. Furthermore, that no evidence of whether cheaper and alternative supports, for example, seizure alerts that do not require internet access, have been considered. Since the Applicant’s reported increase in seizure-like activity arose frequently in the proceedings as a ground for the requested supports, the Respondent also made the point in cross examination of the Applicant, that medical advice recommending the seizure monitor, which the Applicant advised had been purchased on the advice of her doctor, Dr Sabyan Hardjo, had not been provided to the Tribunal and the more general point that: “at present, there’s no epilepsy emergency management plan, or other evidence that would assist in understanding the applicant’s support needs…regarding her secondary seizure disorder”.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal finds that the Applicant’s claim for reimbursement of rent of $27,000 to be, at best, the result of confusion about the sources of funding in her plan and possible miscommunication with, or mismanagement by, her plan manager. In any case, the Respondent’s failure to properly research this claimed support in advance of the hearing, and the Applicant’s failure to provide adequate documentation, both added considerably to the delay in finalising this decision. The Tribunal finds, based on the additional information provided, that despite the Respondent’s confused reasoning for not paying rent, they had, de facto, paid the Applicant’s rent through the provision of STA and MTA. Moreover, the Respondent appears to have paid a much higher amount than the rent actually incurred by the Applicant, if the Applicant’s screen shot invoices represent her total rent. While in these circumstances the fate of any balance of the money provided for rent less the money actually expended is not the business of this decision, it is clear that there is no case for reimbursement to the Applicant of $27,000. CONCLUSION The Tribunal has listened carefully to the concerns of the Applicant and her request for additional supports. Overall, there was limited medical evidence of epilepsy of the kind that would require the level of supervision sought, such as nursing care, her neurologist preferring to describe her condition as a migraine associated epilepsy type disorder and her general practitioner advising that her monitoring, transport and care-worker training were sufficient to meet her current needs with respect to her seizure-like activity. The Applicant embellished the medical advice but was unable to provide evidence of the frequency of her seizure-like activity or its seriousness, notwithstanding that she was medicated with drugs prescribed for seizures and her support workers’ advice that she had three seizures a night. But the Tribunal did not find the Applicant to be dishonest or deliberately misleading; it was clear her concerns about the seriousness of her impairments and their effects upon her were genuinely held and that this perception, while often unrealistic, imposed significant limitations upon her. The Tribunal concludes, overall, that there was little evidence, including cost estimates and other details, provided for some of the supports requested that would enable the decision maker to be “positively satisfied”, as established in the matter of National Disability Insurance Agency v WRMF (2020) 378 ALR 449. The Tribunal also concludes that the Applicant may have been able to demonstrate that some of the requested therapy supports were reasonable and necessary, if she had availed herself of the hours for each therapy already provided to her. It remains open to the Applicant to access the therapy hours provided in her plan in future and then to demonstrate the benefit or otherwise of additional hours. However, the Tribunal accepts evidence of some deterioration in the Applicant’s health resulting from her MS and, as the Applicant described it, the impact of her PTSD and other psycho-social conditions as well as her seizure-like activity. In the absence of evidence to the contrary, the Tribunal has, accordingly, found some of the additional supports requested by the Applicant to be reasonable and necessary. For completion, the Tribunal concludes that the requested supports of: psychology and counselling therapy for two hours per week; four hours per month of yard work; and three hours per week of cleaning, to meet the requirements of s 34 (1) of the Act, reasonable and necessary.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal heard oral evidence from the following witnesses:a)Ms Erin McGrath, the Applicantb)Ms Sally Cooper, Counsellor c)Dr Sabyan Hardjo, General Practitionerd)Ms Kelly Watson, Support Person, e)Ms Amber Joules, Occupational TherapistCONSIDERATION There were 18 requested supports which the Respondent considered were not reasonable and necessary and therefore did not meet the requirements of s 34 (1) of the Act. The Tribunal examines the evidence and makes findings on each proposed support in the paragraphs which follow.Internet connection at property-$1,425 ($75 per month for 19 months). The Applicant has sought ongoing funding for an internet connection on the basis that this was required for a seizure camera linked to an IPad. The Applicant stated that the seizure camera allows her support team to monitor her and reduce risk. She requires the camera whilst support staff are doing active overnights to prevent harm and to be able to assist immediately in case of emergency, without being in the bedroom with her while she slept. The Respondent contended this support duplicates other supports (Rule 5.1 (c) because the Applicant’s SIL funding already provides 24/7 active overnight support for seizure activity. Furthermore, that no evidence of whether cheaper and alternative supports, for example, seizure alerts that do not require internet access, have been considered. Since the Applicant’s reported increase in seizure-like activity arose frequently in the proceedings as a ground for the requested supports, the Respondent also made the point in cross examination of the Applicant, that medical advice recommending the seizure monitor, which the Applicant advised had been purchased on the advice of her doctor, Dr Sabyan Hardjo, had not been provided to the Tribunal and the more general point that: “at present, there’s no epilepsy emergency management plan, or other evidence that would assist in understanding the applicant’s support needs…regarding her secondary seizure disorder”. The Tribunal also notes that there is no medical diagnosis of epilepsy or seizures, her doctor, based on the advice of her neurologist, preferring to describe it as “seizure-like” and “a migraine associated epilepsy type disorder that’s been caused by the MS”. The Applicant’s OT, Ms Amanda Joules, told the Tribunal, reliant on evidence of her support workers, that:“I am aware that there’s a seizure monitoring camera that’s currently in [the Applicant’s] room, and she is having a minimum of three seizures per night, as reported back by her support workers” The Respondent also contended that internet access is a day to day living cost which does not meet the requirements of Rule 5.1 (d), Day to day living cost – Rule 5.1(d.) and would be incurred regardless of the Applicant’s disability (r 5.1(d) of the NDIS Support Rules). The Applicant explained that a camera has been set up in her bedroom and the internet access was to enable her support workers to:“keep me alive. Their monitoring is used on an IPad. The iPad is watched by my support workers, both overnight and also during the day when I need to lie down, need to rest. They watch that camera…and if I’m having a seizure they come in and assist me as needed”’.