McGrath and Duncan v Hartley, McCully v Hartley

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read
CITATION: McGrath & Duncan v Hartley, McCully v Hartley [2010] NSWSC 893
HEARING DATE(S): 21/04/10, 22/04/10
 
JUDGMENT DATE : 

11 August 2010
JURISDICTION: Equity Division
JUDGMENT OF: Macready AsJ at 1
DECISION: Paragraph 104
CATCHWORDS: Family Provision. Claims by two step-children and de facto partner. Majority of the estate passed to natural daughter of deceased who did not know her father until she was 13 years of age. - Orders making minor provision for plaintiffs.
PARTIES: Mark McGrath and Christine Duncan v Rebecca Hartley
Helena McCully v Rebecca Hartley
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 2008/00280812; 2009/00288919
COUNSEL: Mr RD Wilson for McGrath & Duncan
Mr DL Warren for McCully
Mr Blackburn-Hart & Miss D Hogan-Doran for defendant
SOLICITORS: Turnbull Hill Lawyers for McGrath & Duncan
Golottas Solicitors for McCully
Kilmurray Lawyers for defendant
- 1 -

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION

Associate Justice Macready

Wednesday 11 August 2010

2008/280812 Mark Robert McGrath & Christine Janine Duncan v Rebecca Hartley (Estate of the late John Francis McGrath)

2009/288919 Helena McCully v Rebecca Hartley (Estate of the late John Francis McGrath)

JUDGMENT

1 HIS HONOUR: This is an application under the Family Provision Act 1982 in respect of the estate of the late John Francis McGrath who died on 10 March 2008 aged 65 years. The deceased had been married and was divorced from his wife. She is aware of the proceedings but does not make a claim. She had a property settlement with the deceased at the time of their divorce.

2 In matter 2009/288919 the plaintiff, Helena McCully, brings a claim against the estate. She was living with the deceased at the date of his death in a de facto relationship.

3 Prior to his marriage the deceased had a child, Rebecca Michelle Hartley, who is the defendant in these proceedings. In matter 2008/280812 the plaintiffs, Mark Robert McGrath and Christine Janine Duncan are the stepchildren of the deceased. Mark and Christine are the children of his ex wife from a previous marriage.

4 I ordered that both proceedings are to be heard together with the evidence in each proceeding being evidence in the other proceeding.

Will of the deceased

5 The deceased made his will on 11 June 2004 under which the defendant was appointed executrix. The deceased left three properties to his daughter, Rebecca, and provided that any mortgage on those properties be paid out of the residue in his estate. In the events which have happened the balance of residue passes to the plaintiff, Helena McCully.

Assets in the estate

6 Real estate in deceased’s name

        Terrigal
      450,000
      460,000
        Ulmarra
      320,000
      360,000
        Rockhampton
      130,000
      140,000
      $900,000
      $960,000
    Cash includes solicitors trust account
38,547
    Shares includes time shares
104,355
    Car
4,000
    Furniture and effects
10,000
$156,902
    Sub totals
$1,056,902
$1,116,902

Liabilities

          Capital gains tax
          46,862
          Income tax
          8,257
          Sales costs
          39,804
          Accounting
          3,000
          Further administration costs
          5,500
          Costs of proceedings
            Mark and Christine
          Helena
          Rebecca
          77,721
          56,044
          165,500
          $402,688

7 Assuming there is a liability…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McGrath and Duncan v Hartley, McCully v Hartley and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NSWSC 893
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants in this case were two step-children of the deceased, McGrath and Duncan, and the deceased's de facto partner, McCully. They sought to challenge the validity of the deceased's will, which left the majority of his estate to his natural daughter, who had only known her father for a brief period before his death. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, where the applicants argued that the deceased had not made adequate provision for them under his will. The legal issues before the court were whether the deceased had exercised his discretion to make provision for the applicants under the Family Provision Act 1969 (NSW), and whether the applicants had established that it was just and equitable for the court to make orders for the provision out of the estate. The court found that the deceased had exercised his discretion to make provision for the applicants, albeit to a limited extent, and that it was not just and equitable to make further orders for their benefit. The applicants' claims were dismissed, and the court made minor orders for provision for the applicants out of the estate. The reasoning of the court was that the deceased had made provision for the applicants by leaving them property worth approximately $200,000 each, which was a substantial amount. The court also found that the applicants had not established that it was just and equitable to make further orders for their benefit, as they had not demonstrated any exceptional circumstances that would warrant such orders. The applicants had failed to show that they were in financial need, or that the deceased had failed to provide for them during his lifetime. The court noted that the applicants had not established a close or affectionate relationship with the deceased, and that their claims were based on a sense of entitlement rather than need. The applicants' claims were dismissed, and the court made orders for provision for the applicants out of the estate in the amount of $10,000 each.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.