McGowan and Telstra Corporation Limited (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

McGowan and Telstra Corporation Limited (Compensation) [2017] AATA 1053 (7 July 2017)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:           2015/5642

Re:Michael McGowan

APPLICANT

AndTelstra Corporation Limited

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:K. Parker, Member

Date:7 July 2017

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms the decision of Telstra Corporation Limited to deny liability under s 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) in respect of Mr Michael McGowan's claim for compensation for an injury to his cervical spine.

....................................[sgd]....................................

K. Parker, Member

WORKERS’ COMPENSATION – claim for injury to cervical spine – disease or injury – whether pre-existing degenerative condition was an ailment - whether there was an aggravation of an ailment - whether liability under s 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 to pay compensation – contribution to a significant degree – whether the exclusion in s 53 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1998 applies – whether employee gave notice of injury to employer as soon as practicable –  decision affirmed

Legislation      

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth); ss 14, 53

Cases

Comcare v Power (2015) 238 FCR 187

Frosch v Comcare [2004] FCA 1642

REASONS FOR DECISION

K. Parker, Member

7 July 2017

  1. Mr Michael McGowan (Mr McGowan) lodged a claim with Telstra Corporation Limited (Telstra) for compensation under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (the Act) on 1 May 2015 in respect of a reported injury to his cervical spine.

  2. On 14 July 2015, Telstra decided that Mr McGowan was not liable to pay compensation under s 14 of the Act, on the basis that “he was suffering from degenerative changes to the cervical spine which was an ailment” and “his employment with Telstra did not significantly contribute to his claimed condition”.  On 4 September 2015, Telstra reconsidered this decision at the request of Mr McGowan and affirmed it.

  3. Mr McGowan has applied to this Tribunal for a review of Telstra’s decision dated 4 September 2015. Telstra has also contended that the Act did not apply to Mr McGowan by operation of s 53 of the Act, because he did not give notice to Telstra as soon as practicable after he became aware of it. The Tribunal is not satisfied that this was so, for the reasons set out in this decision.

  4. The Tribunal is not satisfied that Mr McGowan’s claimed injury was an injury (other than a disease) or an aggravation of an injury (other than a disease). The Tribunal finds that Mr McGowan sustained an aggravation of an ailment. However, the Tribunal is not satisfied that his employment at Telstra contributed to such aggravation to a significant degree and for this reason, the claimed condition is not a disease as defined by s 5B of the Act.

  5. Consequently, the Tribunal affirms the decision of Telstra on 4 September 2016 to deny liability under s 14 of the Act regarding Mr McGowan’s claimed injury to his cervical spine.

    BACKGROUND

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McGowan and Telstra Corporation Limited (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 1053
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mr McGowan against Telstra Corporation Limited. Mr McGowan claimed he sustained a compensable injury to his cervical spine during his employment with Telstra, which resulted in pain radiating down his right arm. Telstra denied liability, and the Tribunal was required to determine whether Mr McGowan suffered an injury for which Telstra was liable to pay compensation under section 14 of the Act, and whether the Act was excluded from applying due to a failure to provide notice as soon as practicable.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether Mr McGowan suffered an injury, specifically whether his condition constituted a disease, an injury other than a disease, or an aggravation of an injury other than a disease. If it was a disease, the Tribunal had to consider if it was an ailment or an aggravation of an ailment. Furthermore, if it was an aggravation of an ailment, the Tribunal had to assess whether Mr McGowan's employment at Telstra contributed to it to a significant degree. A further issue was whether section 53 of the Act excluded its application due to Mr McGowan's alleged failure to provide timely notice of the injury.

The Tribunal found that Mr McGowan had a pre-existing degenerative cervical spondylosis, which had been aggravated by his work activities at Telstra, particularly the intense period of workstation use between 24 and 26 February 2015. However, the Tribunal concluded that while Telstra's work activities contributed materially to the aggravation of this ailment, this contribution did not reach the threshold of being "significant" as required by the Act. Consequently, Mr McGowan's claimed condition did not meet the definition of a compensable injury under the Act. The Tribunal also found that Mr McGowan had provided sufficient written notice to Telstra as soon as practicable after the injury, so section 53 did not exclude the Act's application.

Accordingly, the Tribunal affirmed Telstra's decision to deny liability under section 14 of the Act in respect of Mr McGowan's claimed injury to his cervical spine.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Consequently, the Tribunal affirms the decision of Telstra on 4 September 2016 to deny liability under s 14 of the Act regarding Mr McGowan’s claimed injury to his cervical spine. BACKGROUND Mr McGowan is a 52 year old right-hand dominant man. Mr McGowan holds a Bachelor of Engineering from the University of Melbourne. After he completed his engineering degree he worked as a patent attorney for one year. Subsequently, Mr McGowan worked as a project engineer, quality engineer and quality manager for various companies, up until the age of 37. In 2001, Mr McGowan moved to King Island, Tasmania, and built a house. He also did some contracting work while on King Island for a cheese factory; worked on an environmental program and also worked for Coles Myer Pty Ltd. In 2006, Mr McGowan moved back to Melbourne and did some contracting work for the Department of Defence. He was also the owner builder of his own home. He commenced work for PricewaterhouseCoopers Australia in 2011. In 2012/2013 for a short period, Mr McGowan performed contract work for Telstra. Subsequently, on 28 July 2014, Mr McGowan commenced employment in a full-time permanent position at Telstra, in the procurement area, in the role of Continuous Improvement Lead (Band 2). Mr McGowan’s role at Telstra was essentially office-based work, involved people management, preparing documents on a computer and attending meetings. He reported to Mr Isaac McFadzean. Mr McGowan’s base salary (excluding superannuation) was $140,000 per annum. Mr McGowan gave evidence that his work at Telstra was particularly busy in December 2014 leading up to Christmas. He said that he was required to work intensely at his workstation for a three-day period from Tuesday, 24 February 2015 to Thursday, 26 February 2015 inclusive, to prepare a power point presentation for a strategy proposal to be presented to Telstra’s senior management team. Mr McGowan claimed that he woke up on the morning of Friday, 27 February 2015 and felt severe pain in his neck radiating down to his right arm. Mr McGowan contended that he sustained a compensable injury at this time, for which he registered the incident with Telstra on 6 March 2015 and lodged a claim for compensation on 1 May 2015. Mr McGowan did not cease work as a consequence of the claimed injury. Subsequently, he resigned from this position at Telstra with effect from 1 May 2015. STATUTORY FRAMEWORK AND ISSUES Section 14(1) of the Act provides that liability to pay compensation in accordance with the Act arises in respect of an injury suffered by an employee, if the injury results in death, incapacity for work, or impairment. “Injury” is defined in s 5A of the Act. It means:(a)A disease suffered by an employee; or(b)An injury (other than a disease) suffered by an employee, that is a physical or mental injury arising out of, or in the course of, the employee’s employment; or (c)An aggravation of a physical or mental injury (other than a disease) suffered by an employee (whether or not that injury arose out of, or in the course of, the employee’s employment), that is an aggravation that arose out of, or in the course of, that employment.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Relevantly, the Tribunal considers that the issues for determination in this application are:(a)Whether Mr McGowan suffered an injury that resulted in incapacity for work or impairment for which Telstra was liable to pay compensation in accordance with s 14 of the Act in respect of his cervical spine. The following sub-issues arise:(i)Was the claimed condition a disease, an injury other than a disease or an aggravation of an injury other than a disease?(ii)If it was a disease, was it an ailment or aggravation of an ailment?(iii)If it was an aggravation of an ailment, was it contributed to, to a significant degree, by Mr McGowan’s employment at Telstra?(b)Whether the Act is otherwise excluded from applying to Mr McGowan by operation of s 53 of the Act, because he did not give notice to Telstra as soon practicable after he became aware of it.MR MCGOWAN’S EVIDENCEPre-existing neck condition Mr McGowan gave evidence that he had previously experienced stiffness in his neck almost 20 years ago. He said it had been a randomly occurring thing which he had addressed with physiotherapy treatment. Mr McGowan said that it was exacerbated by stress and “multiple” periods of time sitting at a work station. He said the last major episode he had experienced was before he started work at Telstra in 2014. He said that by the end of June 2014, it had totally disappeared. He said it did not reoccur until December 2014. He said that he had “learnt what to look out for”.Work environment in 2014/2015 Mr McGowan gave evidence that he had two “direct reports” when he was working at Telstra in 2014/2015. He said his first direct report started working with him at the end of November 2014 and his second direct report started working with him in the second week of December 2014. He said that in the period leading up to December 2014 an employee, who was supporting him, was required to move to another work area. Mr McGowan said he spoke to Mr McFadzean about the stress levels in December 2014 and told him that he was experiencing a sore jaw from grinding his teeth. He said Mr McFadzean’s response was, in effect, that he needed to “suck it up” and that he reminded Mr McGowan that he was on probation and needed to focus on giving a good impression. Mr McGowan said that later in December, Mr McFadzean was “not generally available for catch ups”.Emergence of general neck stiffness in December 2014 Mr McGowan gave evidence that in the fortnight before the Christmas break in December 2014, he noticed “a slight pain in his neck”.[4] He said his work commitments at that time did not allow him to make a physiotherapist’s appointment.[4] Refer paragraph [1.5] of the Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions dated 15 September 2016 (Mr McGowan’s Statement). Mr McGowan said that he did not report the stiffness he was experiencing in December 2014 because at that stage, it was “only minor stiffness”. He said he had four weeks off work (on leave), due to commence at Christmas, which he spent on King Island. He said his neck became worse and he saw a physiotherapist on King Island. He said that when he returned to Melbourne, he went to his usual Melbourne physiotherapist, Mr Darren Jenkins, for continued treatment.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal considers that there are no other factors affecting Mr McGowan’s health that are relevant to whether his work activities at Telstra contributed to, to a significant degree, the claimed injury.CONCLUSION The Tribunal concludes that the Act is not excluded from applying to Mr McGowan in respect of his claimed injury by operation of s 53, as the Tribunal is satisfied that Mr McGowan gave sufficient notice to Telstra in writing of the claimed injury and its connection with his employment as soon as practicable after the injury. The Tribunal considers that Mr McGowan suffered an aggravation of an ailment. The ailment was Mr McGowan’s pre-existing degenerative cervical spondylosis, as diagnosed by Mr Powell, which Mr McGowan had experienced for at least the past 15 years. The aggravation to this ailment was the episode of brachialgia experienced by Mr McGowan at the end of the week commencing 23 February 2015. Based on Mr Powell’s evidence, and upon taking into account the considerations set out in paragraphs [74] to [83], the Tribunal is satisfied that the work activities at Telstra performed by Mr McGowan leading up to and in particular, from 24 to 26 February 2015, contributed to the aggravation of his ailment. While the Tribunal considers that the extent of this contribution was material, it was not “substantially greater than material”[18] and as such, did not reach the required threshold of contributing to the aggravation of Mr McGowan’s ailment to a significant degree as required by the Act. For this reason, the Tribunal concludes that Mr McGowan’s claimed condition does not meet the definition of a disease under s 5B of the Act. [18] See s 5B(3) of the Act. Accordingly, the Tribunal affirms the decision by Telstra to deny liability under s 14 of the Act in respect of Mr McGowan’s claimed injury to his cervical spine.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 29 May 2015, Mr Jenkins also reported as follows:[17]Mr McGowan had been away over the Christmas/New Year break and reported increasing year end neck pain. He had sought treatment from a local physiotherapist on King Island. This was in a worsening state when I first reviewed Mr McGowan in January on his return, and over the subsequent treatments, progressed to include arm pain and neurological change by March 2015. This was a new symptom for Mr McGowan. His previous presentation prior to this presentation was 4 July 2014 for upper thoracic stiffness. CONSIDERATION[17] Refer T-Documents T17/58.Section 53 – was notice of the injury given to Telstra as soon as practicable? Telstra contended that the Act was excluded from applying to Mr McGowan’s injury by operation of s 53 of the Act, because Mr McGowan did not give notice in writing of the injury to Telstra as soon as practicable after he became aware of the injury. In the decision of Frosch v Comcare [2004] FCA 1642, the Federal Court (Whitlam J) held as follows: There is no prescribed form of notice for the purposes of s 53 of the Act. The specification required for such a notice is dictated by the words ‘injury’ and ‘employee’, which are defined respectively in s 4(1) and s 5 of the Act. In turn, those definitions direct attention to the definition of ‘disease’ in s 4(1), the extended meaning given by s 6 to ‘an injury arising out of or in the course of employment’, and the provisions relating to diseases in s 7. It is not necessary to set out the terms of those provisions. Their effect is that the essential information to be imparted under s 53 will be the nature of an injury or ailment and its connection with the employment. Assessing whether the contents of a document meet those requirements involves, in my opinion, a question of law. (emphasis added) The Tribunal considers that Mr McGowan first gave notice in writing of the injury to Telstra when he lodged a HIRO incident/hazard report on Telstra’s intranet on 6 March 2015. There is some uncertainty as to when the injury occurred. Mr McGowan contends that his claim related to the severe pain he experienced when he woke up on the morning of 27 February 2015 giving rise to symptoms when moving his head upward or downward and radiating into his arm. However, the Tribunal notes that Mr McGowan did not give a history to Mr Powell of this sudden onset of severe pain on 27 February 2015 when he was examined by him, nor were there any notes suggesting that this occurred in Mr Jenkins’s clinical notes. Notably, Mr McGowan did not mention the sudden onset of pain on 27 February 2015 in the HIRO report completed by him a short time after on 6 March 2015. The Tribunal finds that Mr McGowan experienced intense symptoms at the end of the week commencing 23 February 2015 which further intensified over the weekend to follow (28 February 2015 and 1 March 2015), causing him to see his physiotherapist on Monday, 2 March 2015. The Tribunal finds that there was not a sudden onset of pain on the morning of 27 February 2015 as subsequently claimed by Mr McGowan although the Tribunal does not consider that a lot turns on the precise date that Mr McGowan first experienced those symptoms. The Tribunal is satisfied that Mr McGowan verbally reported those new symptoms to his supervisor and Mr Smith as soon as he could after they arose. As soon as Telstra’s online reporting system was operational (or back online); he completed and lodged a written HIRO incident/hazard report on Telstra’s intranet on Friday, 6 March 2015.