McGinness v Road Transport Authority (Administrative Review)

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

MCGINNESS v ROAD TRANSPORT AUTHORITY (Administrative Review) [2023] ACAT 79

AT 59/2023

Catchwords:               ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW – review of decision requiring applicant to undertake a medical assessment prior to renewal of driver licence – whether the respondent is to bear the costs of medical assessment – whether the respondent erroneously relied on administrative policies – whether the applicant should be required to put forward reasons that a policy should not be applied – application of policy leaves no room for discretion and is arbitrary – in considering the correct and preferable decision, the respondent is obliged to consider a policy and the applicant’s individual situation – when considering whether to exercise its discretion, the decision maker must consider the cost of the test and the impact on the income earning ability of the applicant if deprived of his license – decision maker must balance the public risk against an individual right – decision set aside

Subordinate

Legislation cited:        Road Transport (Driver Licensing Regulation 2000 ss 11, 78

Cases cited:Re Minister for Resources: Ex parte Cazaly Iron Pty Ltd [2007] WASC 175

BHP Billiton Direct Reduced Iron Pty Ltd v Duffus, Deputy Commissioner of Taxation [2007] FCA 1528
Drake v Minster for Immigration & Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634

List of

Texts/Papers cited:     Austroads, Assessing fitness to drive for commercial and private vehicle drivers (2022 edition)

Tribunal:Senior Member S Lancken

Date of Orders:  30 October 2023

Date of Reasons for Decision:      11 December 2023

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY          )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL     )          AT 59/2023

BETWEEN:

PETER MCGINNESS

Applicant

AND:

ROAD TRANSPORT AUTHORITY

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:Senior Member S Lancken

DATE:11 December 2023

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

  1. The decision of the respondent of 26 April 2023 to require the applicant to provide a passed driver assessment under regulation 78(2) (a) of the Road Transport (Driver Licensing) Regulation2000 is set aside.

……………………………

Senior Member S Lancken

REASONS FOR DECISION

Background

  1. Mr McGinness, the applicant in these proceedings, was born on 10 April 1950 and is 73 years old. He turned 70 on 10 April 2020.

  2. The applicant has held a motor vehicle licence in the ACT since 1967.

  3. Since 22 November 2016, the applicant’s licence has included condition D allowing him to drive a “rideshare vehicle”.[1]

    [1] See Road Transport (Driver Licensing Regulation 2000 s 11, Table 11

  4. The applicant relies on his conditional license to drive for rideshare company “Uber”.

  5. On 28 March 2023, the applicant was notified by the respondent that he was required to undertake a medical assessment prior to the renewal of his Public Vehicle Driver Licence (PVDL).[2] The applicant subsequently undertook the assessment, known as a Commercial Drivers Health Assessment (CDHA). The medical practitioner who completed the CDHA concluded that, at that time, Mr McGinness met “the relevant criteria for an unconditional licence”.[3]

    [2] Document 4 – ‘Commercial Drivers Health Assessment Completed by Dr Yeung’ dated 28 March 2023 of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McGinness v Road Transport Authority (Administrative Review) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] ACAT 79
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of McGinness v Road Transport Authority (Administrative Review), the respondent, the Road Transport Authority, sought to enforce a policy requiring drivers over 70 to undergo a driver assessment annually. The applicant contested this requirement, arguing it was arbitrary and not based on individual competence or risk assessment. The case was heard and determined by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The central legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the policy of mandatory annual assessments for drivers over 70 was lawful and properly justified. The respondent argued that the policy was guided by administrative considerations and aimed at ensuring driver safety. However, the Tribunal found that the policy lacked individualised assessment and did not account for the actual competence or risk posed by drivers over 70. Additionally, the respondent did not provide sufficient evidence to justify the blanket requirement for annual assessments for drivers over 70, especially given the low volume of such decisions.

The Tribunal concluded that the policy was arbitrary and not well-founded in evidence or reasoning. The requirement for annual assessments was not supported by any demonstrated correlation between age and driver competence or risk. The Tribunal found that the respondent failed to provide a cogent reason for the policy and set aside the decision to require the applicant to provide a passed driver assessment. The Tribunal's decision emphasised the need for policies to be evidence-based and individualised rather than applying arbitrary age-based mandates.

The Tribunal ordered that the decision of the respondent to require the applicant to provide a passed driver assessment under regulation 78(2)(a) of the Road Transport (Driver Licensing) Regulation 2000 be set aside.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal orders that:

1.

The decision of the respondent of 26 April 2023 to require the applicant to provide a passed driver assessment under regulation 78(2) (a) of the Road Transport (Driver Licensing) Regulation 2000 is set aside.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The respondent argues that:Where the Parliament has conferred wide discretions on an official decision-maker, particularly in relation to high volume decision-making, it is entirely consistent with the legislative intention in conferring such a discretion that its exercise will be guided by administrative policies.[11][11] BHP Billiton Direct Reduced Iron Pty Ltd v Duffus, Deputy Commissioner of Taxation [2007] FCA 1528 at [103] (emphasis added) The evidence in relation to the volume of decision making of this type is that, in the year between 1 October 2022 and 30 September 2023, the respondent made 14 decisions in relation to the renewal of a public vehicle driver’s license of persons “70 and over”. Fourteen decisions per year is hardly high volume. The respondent further argues that it is for the applicant to put forward reasons why the policy should not be applied,[12] relying on Drake v Minster for Immigration & Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (Drake).[13][12] Respondent’s submissions dated 20 September 2023, page 5 at [23][13] (1979) 2 ALD 634 In Drake, Bennan J identifies that the policy or guideline in that case involved a complex range of considerations that were generally set out in a “Ministers Policy Statement.”[14] The Ministers Policy Statement was not proscriptive, rather guiding the making of the decision. The present case is quite different.[14] Drake, pages 637, 638 In the present case, the requirement for a person of age 70 to provide a “passed PVDL or TISC driver assessment certificate” leaves no room for exercise of discretion and is arbitrary. Given there was no evidence before the Tribunal about the relative competence of persons aged less than 70 and those who have reached that age, and the fact that the number of decisions made in those circumstances is negligible in any year, the respondent has not demonstrated a cogent reason for requiring additional testing every year of drivers who are aged beyond their 70th birthday. The decision in Drake does not stand for the proposition that if a guideline or policy is published, those challenging the application of the guideline must put forward reasons and satisfy the Tribunal why the policy “should not be applied in the circumstances of a case.”[15][15] Respondent’s submissions dated 20 September 2023, page 5 at [23], citing Drake Further, the respondent’s submission addresses the lack of any evidence or reasoning behind the guideline. There, the respondent says:(a)commercial drivers spend considerable time on the road and that creates a higher risk;(b)the risk is increased by the need to monitor in-vehicle communication and work-related systems, and(c)the policy ensures medical fitness for commercial vehicle license holders is more stringent for a driver not involved in commercial activities.[16][16] Respondent’s submissions dated 20 September 2023, page 5 at [24] Such reasoning does not address the submission of the applicant that the mere fact that a driver has reached their 70th or 71st birthday, affects a person’s medical fitness to hold such a license.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established