McElligott v Public Trustee of Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

McElligott v Public Trustee of Queensland & Ors [2013] QSC 314

PARTIES:

ADRIAN EDWIN McELLIGOTT (as Executor of the Estate of the Late Joyce Alice McElligott)
(applicant)
v
PUBLIC TRUSTEE OF QUEENSLAND (as Litigation Guardian for Takarli Joy McElligott and Tarson James McElligott)
(first respondent)
and
CHERYL ALICE McELLIGOTT
(second respondent)
and
OFFICIAL TRUSTEE IN BANKRUPTCY FOR THE BANKRUPT ESTATE OF LORAIN RONDA McELLIGOTT
(third respondent)
and
SHERLENE SANDRA TURNER
(fourth respondent)
and
GLORIA JANELL ROBERTS
(fifth respondent)
and
ADRIAN EDWIN McELLIGOTT

(sixth respondent)

FILE NO/S:

BS 6651 of 2013

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Originating Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland

DELIVERED ON:

12 November 2013

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

22 August 2013

JUDGE:

Philip McMurdo J

ORDERS:

It is declared that:

(a)   upon the sale of the property at 186 Collins Road, Ninderry, the grandchildren named in cl 6 of the will of the late Joyce Alice McElligott will have no entitlement to any of the proceeds of sale; and

(b)   upon the administration of the estate of the late Joyce Alice McElligott, the share of the residuary estate to which Lorain Ronda McElligott, but for her bankruptcy, would be entitled under cl 7 of the will, will be vested in the Official Trustee in Bankruptcy.

CATCHWORDS:

SUCCESSION – CONSTRUCTION AND EFFECT OF TESTAMENTARY DISPOSITIONS – WHAT INTEREST PASSES – LICENCE, LIFE INTEREST OR FEE SIMPLE – WHERE RIGHT TO USE RESIDENCE – LICENCE OR LIFE ESTATE – where the estate of the deceased included a freehold property – where the property was given on terms which provided some right or interest in favour of two of her grandchildren – where the property must be sold to pay the debts of the estate – whether the grandchildren were granted an equitable estate or a personal right to occupy the property – whether the grandchildren have any right to the proceeds of the sale of the property

SUCCESSION – CONSTRUCTION AND EFFECT OF TESTAMENTARY DISPOSITIONS – PARTICULAR TESTAMENTARY DISPOSITIONS – DESCRIPTION OF BENEFICIARIES OR PERSONS – OTHER WORDS AND PHRASES – where the will of the deceased provided that if a person “under a legal disability” is entitled to any gift under the will, then the executor should hold on trust the share to which that person is entitled – where one beneficiary is an undischarged bankrupt – whether the bankrupt beneficiary is “under a legal disability”

Binetter v Dunkel (Unreported, Supreme Court of New South Wales, Powell J, 28 May 1993), cited
Commissioner of Stamp Duties (Qld) v Livingston (1964) 112 CLR 12; [1965] UKPCHCA 2, cited
Ex parte Middleton
[1983] 1 Qd R 170, cited
Gosden v Dixon (1992) 107 ALR 329, cited
Hatzantonis v Lawrence
[2003] NSWSC 914, considered
Official Receiver in Bankruptcy v Schultz (1990) 170 CLR 306; [1990] HCA 45, cited
Re Hillier
(1939) 39 SR (NSW) 71, cited
Royal Melbourne Hospital v Equity Trustees Ltd (2007) 18 VR 469; [2007]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McElligott v Public Trustee of Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] QSC 314
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court was an action by the Public Trustee of Queensland, acting on behalf of the estate of Joyce Alice McElligott, seeking a declaration regarding the entitlements of certain beneficiaries under the deceased's will. The deceased had left a property at 186 Collins Road, Ninderry, to be sold to pay debts of the estate, with a specific provision for two grandchildren to have some right or interest in the property. The primary issue before the court was whether the grandchildren were granted an equitable estate or merely a personal right to occupy the property, and if they were entitled to any of the proceeds from its sale. Additionally, the court needed to determine whether an undischarged bankrupt beneficiary, Lorain Ronda McElligott, who was under a legal disability, would have her share of the estate held on trust.

The court considered the wording of the will and the specific clause that provided for the grandchildren to have some right or interest in the property. It was noted that the will did not provide for an equitable interest but rather a personal right to occupy the property. The court also examined the clause that directed the executor to hold on trust any share of the estate to which a beneficiary under a legal disability would be entitled. The court concluded that the grandchildren did not have an equitable estate in the property and were thus not entitled to any proceeds from its sale. Regarding the bankrupt beneficiary, the court found that an undischarged bankrupt is indeed under a legal disability within the meaning of the will, and her share of the estate would be vested in the Official Trustee in Bankruptcy.

The court made a declaration that the grandchildren named in clause 6 of the will would have no entitlement to any of the proceeds of the sale of the property at 186 Collins Road, Ninderry. Furthermore, the share of the residuary estate to which Lorain Ronda McElligott would be entitled, but for her bankruptcy, would be vested in the Official Trustee in Bankruptcy. This decision clarified the nature of the interests granted to the grandchildren and the effect of the bankruptcy on the distribution of the estate.

Orders

Orders of the court

It is declared that:

(a) upon the sale of the property at 186 Collins Road, Ninderry, the grandchildren named in cl 6 of the will of the late Joyce Alice McElligott will have no entitlement to any of the proceeds of sale; and

(b) upon the administration of the estate of the late Joyce Alice McElligott, the share of the residuary estate to which Lorain Ronda McElligott, but for her bankruptcy, would be entitled under cl 7 of the will, will be vested in the Official Trustee in Bankruptcy.

Background

Background to the litigation

The estate of the deceased, Joyce Alice McElligott, included a freehold property located at 186 Collins Road, Ninderry. The will of Joyce Alice McElligott provided that the property must be sold to pay the debts of her estate. Clause 6 of the will granted some right or interest in the property to two of her grandchildren, while clause 7 provided for the distribution of the residue of the estate. The grandchildren, who were named in clause 6, were uncertain about whether they had any interest in the proceeds from the sale of the property. Additionally, one of the beneficiaries under clause 7 of the will, Lorain Ronda McElligott, was an undischarged bankrupt. The will also contained a clause stating that if a person "under a legal disability" was entitled to any gift under the will, then the executor should hold on trust the share to which that person is entitled.

The matter came before the court as a result of an application by the Public Trustee of Queensland, who was appointed as the executor of Joyce Alice McElligott's estate. The Public Trustee sought a declaration regarding the entitlement of the grandchildren to any proceeds from the sale of the property and the disposition of the share of the residuary estate that would have been entitled to Lorain Ronda McElligott, but for her bankruptcy. The court heard the application and provided its decision in the form of a declaration.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the grandchildren named in clause 6 of the will of the late Joyce Alice McElligott have any entitlement to the proceeds of the sale of the property at 186 Collins Road, Ninderry.
2. Whether, upon the administration of the estate of the late Joyce Alice McElligott, the share of the residuary estate to which Lorain Ronda McElligott, but for her bankruptcy, would be entitled under clause 7 of the will, will be vested in the Official Trustee in Bankruptcy.
3. Whether an undischarged bankrupt is considered to be "under a legal disability" within the meaning of the will of the late Joyce Alice McElligott.

Held
1. The grandchildren named in clause 6 of the will of the late Joyce Alice McElligott have no entitlement to the proceeds of the sale of the property at 186 Collins Road, Ninderry.
2. Upon the administration of the estate of the late Joyce Alice McElligott, the share of the residuary estate to which Lorain Ronda McElligott, but for her bankruptcy, would be entitled under clause 7 of the will, will be vested in the Official Trustee in Bankruptcy.
3. An undischarged bankrupt is considered to be "under a legal disability" within the meaning of the will of the late Joyce Alice McElligott.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined clause 6 of the will, which provided certain rights to the grandchildren to use the residence at 186 Collins Road, Ninderry. The court held that the clause did not grant the grandchildren an equitable estate or a personal right to occupy the property but rather a personal right to use the residence. Given that the property had to be sold to pay the debts of the estate, the court concluded that the grandchildren had no entitlement to any of the proceeds of sale. The court found that the grandchildren were granted a personal right to use the property, not a proprietary interest, and therefore, they were not entitled to any share of the sale proceeds.

Turning to clause 7 of the will, the court determined that Lorain Ronda McElligott, who is an undischarged bankrupt, is considered to be "under a legal disability" within the meaning of the will. As a result, the share of the residuary estate to which she would be entitled, but for her bankruptcy, should be vested in the Official Trustee in Bankruptcy. The court relied on the definition of "under a legal disability" in the will and concluded that the term included undischarged bankrupts, which aligned with the court's interpretation of the will's language.

The court distinguished between the personal right to use the residence granted to the grandchildren and the proprietary interest that would pass to them if they were not "under a legal disability". It applied the principle that the language of the will determines the nature of the interest granted, and it was clear that the grandchildren were granted a personal right, not a proprietary interest. The ratio decidendi of this case is that a personal right to use a property does not entitle the beneficiary to any proceeds from the sale of the property, and an undischarged bankrupt is considered to be "under a legal disability" within the meaning of a will.