McDonald v The State of SA

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Appeal Against a Master's Decision)

MCDONALD v THE STATE OF SA

[2012] SADC 54

Judgment of His Honour Judge Rice

20 April 2012

PROCEDURE

Appeal by plaintiff against the refusal by a Master to allow plaintiff to file a Proposed Amended Draft Statement of Claim.

Appeal by defendant against a Master's refusal to strike out certain paragraphs of a Proposed Amended Draft Statement of Claim relating to a claim in defamation.

Appeal by plaintiff dismissed.

Appeal by defendant allowed - paragraphs relating to defamation also struck out.

District Court Act 1991 s 43(2)(b), referred to.
Roberts v Bass (2002) 77 ALJR 292, considered.

MCDONALD v THE STATE OF SA
[2012] SADC 54

Introduction

  1. In this matter the defendant applied before a Master that the pleadings of the second plaintiff, Mr F.T. McDonald, as contained in the Proposed Amended Draft Statement of Claim dated 3 November 2010, be struck out.  For reasons expressed by the Master, the plaintiff’s application to file the Proposed Claim, was refused.  The plaintiff now appeals against that refusal.

  2. The Master refused to strike out paragraphs 379, 380 and 381 of the Proposed Claim.  Those paragraphs relate to a claim in defamation linked to a document known as Document 16.  The defendant has now cross-appealed that refusal and submits the Master should have also struck out those paragraphs.

    A potted history of the proceedings

  3. These proceedings commenced on 12 January 2005.  The claim related to events at the Paringa Park Primary School during the period 1997-2000.  At the time, the proceedings were issued in the name of son, Brennan McDonald, with this plaintiff, the father, as his next friend.  As the Master put it, the Statement of Claim alleged the defendant was negligent, in breach of duty of care, was deceitful and defamed the son and caused him psychological injury, loss of dignity and reputation and discrimination in relation to his education.

  4. Then followed a long history of interlocutory hearings relating to the pleadings.  The Master also notes that, by August 2009, ten versions of the plaintiffs’ claims had been filed or lodged for consideration.  By orders dated 27 August 2009, the Master struck out various of the pleadings and the claim of the first plaintiff (the father).  The Master ordered that further particulars be supplied with respect to certain paragraphs and that an Amended Statement of Claim be filed on or before 6 November 2010.  An appeal to Judge Nicholson was allowed in limited respects but otherwise dismissed.

  5. On 3 November 2010, the plaintiffs filed a Proposed Amended Draft Statement of Claim, referred to by me as the Proposed Claim.  This is the document about which the appeal and cross-appeal relate (although the latter is restricted to paragraphs 379-381 and Document 16).

    The arguments before the Master

  6. As mentioned, the defendant sought to have the plaintiffs’ Proposed Claim struck out.  Various arguments were put forward that:

    •The plaintiffs had failed to supply further and better particulars pursuant to the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McDonald v The State of SA and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] SADC 54
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The District Court of South Australia heard an appeal by Mr. F.T. McDonald against the refusal by a Master to allow him to file a Proposed Amended Draft Statement of Claim. Concurrently, the State of South Australia cross-appealed the Master's decision not to strike out certain paragraphs related to a defamation claim. The core legal issues revolved around whether the proposed pleadings should be permitted and if the defamation claims were appropriately dismissed. The plaintiff sought to amend his claim with a new pleading, while the defendant argued for the dismissal of the entire pleading and specific paragraphs related to defamation. The court had to determine if the plaintiff had complied with procedural requirements and if the defamation claims were valid under the applicable law.

The court considered the procedural aspect first, granting the plaintiff an extension of time to appeal due to medical grounds. Regarding the defamation claim, the court found that the Master had correctly dismissed the claim based on documents 1-15 and 17 as they were out of time and did not relate to the original cause of action. However, the court reconsidered the dismissal of the defamation claim based on Document 16, noting that the limitation period was six years, not one year, and thus the claim was not out of time. The court also found that Document 16 was not defamatory and was protected by qualified privilege, concluding that the defendant was not actuated by malice. Consequently, the court dismissed the plaintiff's appeal and allowed the defendant's cross-appeal, striking out the relevant paragraphs.

The final orders of the court were that the plaintiff's appeal was dismissed, and the defendant's cross-appeal was allowed with respect to paragraphs 379-381 of the Proposed Amended Draft Statement of Claim, which related to the defamation claim based on Document 16. These paragraphs were struck out, and no further defamation claim based on this document could proceed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.