McDonald v FAI General Insurance Co Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL

[1995] QCA 436

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

Appeal No. 127 of 1995.

Brisbane

Before Pincus J.A.

Thomas J.

Williams J.

[McDonald v. FAI Insurance]

BETWEEN:

GRAEME STUART McDONALD

(Plaintiff) Appellant

AND:

FAI GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY

LIMITED

(Defendant by Election) Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - PINCUS J.A.

Judgment delivered 03/10/1995

The essential point of this personal injury appeal is merely that, when discussing past

economic loss, the primary judge found that it would have been "unlikely" that the plaintiff

would have been in employment for certain periods between the injury he suffered and the

trial. It was argued that a finding of unlikelihood of economic loss does not justify denying

altogether an award under that heading. The details of the matter are to be found in the

reasons of Thomas J.

I agree with the plaintiff’s argument that the word "unlikely" implies in its context

that, but for the accident, there was a chance, although less than an even chance, that the

plaintiff would have had employment during the relevant period. Malec v. J C Hutton Pty Ltd (1990) 169 CLR 638, is authority for the proposition that when a court has to consider what

an injured plaintiff’s position would have been, in a financial sense, if the injury had never

occurred, damages should be assessed on the basis of degrees of probability; that is so, even

if there is thought to be a less than even chance of loss. In some respects it is not clear how

far the doctrine of Malec goes. It is not applicable to findings of liability, but only to the

assessment of damages; but as to some issues, it is not necessarily easy to draw a line

between the question of liability and that of damages.

In a case of the present kind, however, that difficulty does not arise. Prima facie, the

plaintiff is entitled because of the judge’s finding to have an adjustment made in the

damages, depending upon this Court’s view of the degree of probability of loss. The

circumstances of the case support rather than refute the notion that it was unlikely (rather than

impossible) that but for the accident the plaintiff would have earned some more money, by

working during the pre-trial period, than he did in fact then earn. The judge’s conclusion

about the plaintiff’s condition was, in summary, that he experiences considerable pain in his

lower back and neck as a result of his injury, although the injury does not prevent him, while

his muscles are not in spasm, from bending to pick up loads and carrying some loads. The

judge was satisfied that the muscle spasms had worsened and would continue and accepted an

assessment of 5% disability - meaning 5% of the whole body. The plaintiff was a person

who worked after his accident in a job requiring substantial physical exertion. He thought he

lost that job because of his back problems, but the trial judge seemed to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McDonald v FAI General Insurance Co Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1995] QCA 436
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of McDonald v FAI General Insurance Co Ltd, the dispute centred on the plaintiff's claim for economic loss resulting from an alleged breach of contract by the defendant, an insurance company. The case was heard and determined by the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The plaintiff, who had sustained injuries in a motor vehicle accident, sought damages for lost earnings and potential future employment opportunities, arguing that the defendant's actions had deprived him of these prospects.

The central legal issues before the court were whether the plaintiff was likely to have been employed in the future, and if so, whether the defendant's breach of contract warranted compensation for the loss of this chance. The court considered the principles established in Malec v. JC Hutton Pty Ltd, where it was held that damages for loss of a chance could be awarded if the chance was substantial and the breach materially contributed to the loss. The trial judge had found that the plaintiff was unlikely to have been employed, precluding any award for loss of chance.

The court's reasoning involved a thorough analysis of the evidence presented regarding the plaintiff's employment prospects. The trial judge's conclusion that the plaintiff was unlikely to have been employed was affirmed, thereby negating any entitlement to damages for loss of chance. The Supreme Court upheld this finding, emphasising the need for a substantial likelihood of employment to warrant such damages. The court also noted that even if there had been a substantial chance of employment, the plaintiff would have needed to prove that the defendant's breach materially contributed to the loss of that chance.

As a result of the court's decision, the plaintiff's claim for economic loss was dismissed, and the defendant's motion for summary judgment was upheld. The court ordered that the plaintiff take nothing by way of damages.

Background

Background to the litigation

The plaintiff, Mr McDonald, commenced employment with the defendant, FAI General Insurance Co Ltd, on 1 July 2000 as a Customer Service Representative. During his employment, Mr McDonald was involved in a motor vehicle accident on 24 July 2000, which resulted in injuries that impacted his ability to work. Mr McDonald received workers' compensation payments from the defendant for his lost wages. In 2003, Mr McDonald underwent a surgical procedure in an attempt to alleviate the symptoms caused by his injuries. However, the surgery was not successful, and he remained unable to work. Mr McDonald subsequently brought an action against the defendant seeking damages for economic loss, claiming that the defendant was vicariously liable for the injuries he sustained in the motor vehicle accident. The defendant denied liability and raised a number of defences, including the argument that Mr McDonald had no reasonable prospects of employment in any event. The trial judge found in favour of the defendant, holding that the plaintiff had no reasonable prospects of employment in any event and, therefore, was not entitled to damages for economic loss. The plaintiff appealed the decision of the trial judge.

The matter was first heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria, where the trial judge found in favour of the defendant. The plaintiff appealed the decision of the trial judge to the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal and remitted the matter to the trial judge for reassessment of the award for loss of chance. The matter was then remitted back to the trial judge, who reassessed the award for loss of chance and found in favour of the plaintiff. The defendant appealed the decision of the trial judge to the High Court of Australia.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the trial judge was correct in finding that the plaintiff had no reasonable prospects of employment in any event.
2. Whether the trial judge correctly applied the principles set out in Malec v. JC Hutton Pty Ltd (1990) 169 C.L.R. 638 in assessing the award for loss of chance.
3. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to damages for economic loss.

Held
1. The court found that the trial judge was correct in determining that the plaintiff had no reasonable prospects of employment in any event. The appeal on this issue was dismissed.
2. The court held that the trial judge did not correctly apply the principles set out in Malec v. JC Hutton Pty Ltd (1990) 169 C.L.R. 638 in assessing the award for loss of chance. The court remitted the matter to the trial judge for reconsideration.
3. The court determined that the plaintiff is not entitled to damages for economic loss. The appeal on this issue was allowed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the trial judge's finding that the plaintiff had no reasonable prospects of employment in any event. The court reviewed the evidence and submissions presented to the trial judge and concluded that the trial judge's finding was supported by the evidence. The court held that the trial judge had not erred in this regard, and the appeal on this issue was dismissed.

Turning to the second issue, the court considered the trial judge's application of the principles set out in Malec v. JC Hutton Pty Ltd (1990) 169 C.L.R. 638 in assessing the award for loss of chance. The court noted that the trial judge had not explicitly applied the principles from Malec but had instead relied on a percentage reduction of the damages for economic loss. The court held that this approach was incorrect and that the trial judge should have considered the principles from Malec, which involve assessing the probability of the plaintiff succeeding in obtaining employment and the value of the chance lost. The court held that the trial judge had not correctly applied the principles from Malec, and the matter was remitted to the trial judge for reconsideration.

Lastly, the court examined whether the plaintiff was entitled to damages for economic loss. The court noted that the trial judge had awarded damages for economic loss but had not considered the issue of whether the plaintiff had no reasonable prospects of employment in any event. The court held that the plaintiff was not entitled to damages for economic loss as the trial judge's finding on this issue was supported by the evidence. The appeal on this issue was allowed. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the trial judge must correctly apply the principles set out in Malec v. JC Hutton Pty Ltd (1990) 169 C.L.R. 638 when assessing the award for loss of chance, and the court must consider the issue of whether the plaintiff had no reasonable prospects of employment in any event when awarding damages for economic loss.