McCullin v Crawford

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read
29 CLR 186

RESPONDENT,

CRAWFORD AND OTHERS

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF Licensing-Adjustment of rent-Determination of Licences Reduction Board-Appeal

to Court of Petty Sessions-Jurisdiction on appeal-Rehearing-Order less favourable to appellant-Licensing (Rents and Fees Adjustment) Act 1915 (Vict.) MELBOURNE,

(No. 2776), sec. 4*-Licensing Act 1919 (Vict.) (No. 3028), sec. 13. May 17, 18,

Held, that sec. 13 of the Licensing Act 1919 confers on a Court of Petty Sessions power to rehear the whole case, to deal with it de noro as a Court of first instance, and to make any order which might have been made by the

Held, therefore, that on an appeal under that section where the respondent had given no notice of appeal the Court of Petty Sessions had jurisdiction to make an order less favourable to the appellant than the order against which the appeal was brought.

Decision of the Supreme Court of Victoria: R. v. Berriman; Ex parte Crawford, (1920) V.L.R., 609; 42 A.L.T., 107, reversed. Sec. 4 of the Licensing (Rents and

premises shall be adjusted as from the Fees Adjustment) Act 1915 (Vict.) pro-

commencement of the said Act until vides that (1) In the case of any

the expiration thereof or until the said licensed premises of which the owner is not also the occupier

(whichever first happens). (2) (a) If occupier may

the said occupier and the said owner notice in writing that

do not agree as to such adjust- because of pecuniary loss sustained

ment the said occupier by him by reason of the restriction by

make application in writing to the the Intoxicating Liquor (Temporary

Licences Reduction Board to adjust Restriction) Act 1915 of the hours for the sale or disposal of liquor the occu-

The Board shall entertain inquire into pier desires that the amount of the

and determine the matter of the appli- payable under any

cation and in any such determination existing at the com-

may make such adjustment (if any) of which the occupier holds the said

opinion of the Board having regard to

29 CLR 187

APPEAL from the Supreme Court of Victoria.

At all material times George Hunter Crawford, Robert Edington Crawford and Elizabeth Eleanor Byrne (hereinafter called 'the owners were the owners of the City Family Hotel at Bendigo, and Bryan McCullin was the occupier of the hotel under a lease from the owners for a term of twelve years commencing on 1st May 1913, at a yearly rental of £780.

On 15th February 1916 McCullin applied to the Licences Reduc- tion Board for an adjustment of the rent in pursuance of the pro- visions of sec. 4 of the Licensing (Rents and Fees Adjustment) Act 1915, and on 16th March 1916 the Board ordered that the rent should be reduced as from 6th July 1915 by the sum of £4 weekly during the period provided for by that Act. After the passing of the Licensing Act 1916 McCullin applied for a further adjustment of the rent, and the Licences…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McCullin v Crawford and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1921] HCA 22
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned an appeal from the Supreme Court of Victoria to the High Court of Australia. The dispute arose from an appeal to the Court of Petty Sessions by the owners of the City Family Hotel, Bendigo, against orders made by the Licences Reduction Board that reduced the rent payable by the occupier, Bryan McCullin. The owners contended that the rent reductions were excessive.

The legal issue before the High Court was whether, on an appeal under section 13 of the Licensing Act 1919, the Court of Petty Sessions had the jurisdiction to make an order that was less favourable to the appellant than the order against which the appeal was brought, particularly when the respondent had not given notice of appeal. The Supreme Court had previously held that such an order was beyond the jurisdiction of the Court of Petty Sessions.

The High Court determined that section 13 of the Licensing Act 1919 conferred upon the Court of Petty Sessions the power to rehear the entire case *de novo*, acting as a court of first instance. The Court reasoned that the language of the section, particularly the grant of power to do all such matters and things relating to the appeal in the same manner and to the same extent as it is empowered in its ordinary jurisdiction, indicated an intention for a broad rehearing. Furthermore, the absence of requirements for formal notice of appeal or grounds of appeal suggested that the appellate court was not confined to reviewing errors in the original determination but could make any order that the Licences Reduction Board could have made.

Consequently, the High Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the order of the Supreme Court. The Court held that the Court of Petty Sessions had the jurisdiction to make orders less favourable to the appellant than the original Board orders, and therefore the rule nisi for certiorari should have been discharged. The owners were ordered to pay McCullin's costs in both the Supreme Court and the High Court.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established