DISTRICT COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Civil)
MCCRAE v NOMINAL DEFENDANT & ORS
Judgment of His Honour Judge Herriman
11 May 2005
TORTS - NEGLIGENCE - ROAD ACCIDENT CASES - ACTIONS FOR NEGLIGENCE - APPORTIONMENT OF DAMAGES
Plaintiff sues three defendants for damages for personal injury arising out of separate motor vehicle accidents. Involvement of the first and second defendants in particular accidents not established. Claims dismissed. Negligence admitted by third defendant but dispute as to accident dynamics. Claim of contributory negligence not made out. Causation - prior injuries and findings as to which injuries attributable to or aggravated by third accident. Damages awarded for non-economic and past economic loss.
Wrongs Act 1936 (SA) s.24B, referred to.
March v Stramere (1990-91) 171 CLR 506, applied.
PERSONAL INJURY MATTERS
Soft tissue injuries causing 2.5% neck disability with headaches, 4% thoracic disability.
Law Type: Wrongs Act s 35A up to 30/11/02
Wrongs Act Scale: 5
Total Assessment: $24,001.80
MCCRAE v NOMINAL DEFENDANT & ORS
[2005] SADC 42INTRODUCTION
In this action, the plaintiff sues three defendants for damages for negligence arising out of separate motor vehicle accidents which he says caused him personal injury and loss.
In the first of those, on 6 December 1999 (“the first accident”), he was the driver of a Mitsubishi sedan which was allegedly struck from behind by a vehicle driven by an unknown driver (the Nominal Defendant) whilst in a line of traffic approaching traffic lights at the intersection of Portrush Road, Cross Road and Glen Osmond Road. In consequence, he says, his vehicle was pushed into a further collision with a BMW sedan in front of him and he suffered injuries including a loss of consciousness, dizziness, nausea and headaches, damage to his neck and left shoulder and, later, anxiety and depression.
On 26 April 2000 (“the second accident”), the plaintiff was leaning on the passenger’s side of a stationary Ford motor vehicle parked at the kerb of Commercial Road, Port Adelaide, when it was allegedly struck on its off‑side by a bus driven by a Mr Fraser. The blow was a glancing one, causing minor damage to the outside of the vehicle’s rear vision mirror, but its effect was to cause the plaintiff to be thrown or otherwise to throw himself away from the Ford and onto the footpath. As a result, he aggravated the injuries suffered in the first accident and, further, injured his right foot and right shoulder.
On 23 September 2000 (“the third accident”), the plaintiff was driving his Mitsubishi sedan in the car‑park of the Campbelltown Shopping Centre, when it was struck by a reversing vehicle driven by a Mr Borgas. In an unsuccessful attempt to avoid that collision, he accelerated and, after being hit by Borgas’ vehicle, collided with bollards in the car‑park. In consequence, he says, he aggravated his previous injuries and also injured his upper back.
Each of the defendants has denied liability.
In the case of the first accident, the nominal defendant denies that any vehicle…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Mccrae v Nominal Defendant & Ors and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2005] SADC 42
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues that the court addressed included the establishment of the defendants' liability, the dynamics of the accident involving the third defendant, the extent of the plaintiff's contributory negligence, and the causation of the plaintiff's injuries. The court had to resolve whether the injuries claimed by the plaintiff were indeed caused by the accident with the third defendant or were pre-existing or exacerbated by other factors. Additionally, the court needed to determine the appropriate apportionment of damages for non-economic and past economic losses.
The court found that the third defendant was negligent but did not accept the plaintiff's claim of contributory negligence. The court detailed the injuries attributable to the third defendant's accident and those that were pre-existing or aggravated by other factors. The court awarded damages for non-economic and past economic loss based on the injuries caused by the accident with the third defendant. The court's decision provided clarity on the causation of injuries and the appropriate damages for the plaintiff.
The court dismissed the claims against the first and second defendants due to insufficient evidence of their involvement in the respective accidents. The third defendant was held liable for the injuries caused by the accident and damages were awarded accordingly. The plaintiff was not found to have contributed to their injuries, and thus no reduction in damages was made on this basis. The final orders included a dismissal of claims against the first and second defendants, a finding of negligence on the part of the third defendant, and an award of damages for non-economic and past economic losses.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi