McCombie and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

McCombie and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2023] AATA 1884 (29 June 2023)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:          2023/0130

Re:Phillip James McCombie

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member Theodore Tavoularis

Date:29 June 2023

Place:Brisbane

Pursuant to section 43 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), the Tribunal sets aside the decision made by the delegate of the Respondent dated 3 January 2023 and substitutes it with a decision to revoke the mandatory cancellation of the Applicant’s visa

...................................[SGD]................................

Senior Member Theodore Tavoularis

Catchwords

MIGRATION – Non-revocation of mandatory cancellation of a Class TY Subclass 444 Special Category (temporary) visa – where Applicant does not pass the character test – whether there is another reason to revoke the mandatory cancellation decision – consideration of Ministerial Direction No. 99 – decision under review set aside and substituted.

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
Migration Act 1958 (Cth)

Migration Regulation 1994 (Cth)

Cases

Arachchi v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2022] FCA 1311
Kumar v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2023] FCAFC 94
PNLB v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] AATA 162
Tera Euna and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] AATA 301.

Walker v Minister of Home Affairs [2020] FCA 909.

Secondary Materials

Ministerial Direction No. 99 – Visa refusal and cancellation under section 501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under section 501CA (3 March 2023)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member Theodore Tavoularis

29 June 2023

INTRODUCTION

  1. Mr Phillip James McCombie (‘the Applicant’) is a 46-year-old man, born in New Zealand in April 1977. He has departed Australia on a number of occasions but it suffices to say that he has regarded Australia as his country of residence since about the time of his arrival here in April 2005. Since that time, while he has moved in and out of Australia, there is little to cavil with the proposition that the overwhelming majority of his time has been spent in Australia. Following his most recent arrival in Australia in September 2019,[1] he was granted was a Class TY Subclass 444 Special Category (Temporary) visa (‘the Visa’).[2]

    [1] G1, p 220.

    [2] Ibid, p 223.

  2. On 21 July 2021, while the Applicant was serving a fulltime custodial term of imprisonment, the Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (‘the Respondent’) notified the Applicant of the mandatory cancellation of the Visa pursuant to s 501(3A) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (‘the Act’).[3] The Respondent made this decision because the Applicant did not pass the character test as he was serving a full-time custodial term of imprisonment of over 12-months.[4] On 5 August 2021, the Respondent received the Applicant’s representations requesting the mandatory cancellation of his Visa be revoked.[5] On 24 November 2022, the Applicant voluntarily returned to New Zealand.

    [3] Ibid.

    [4] Ibid.

    [5] Ibid, p 40.

  3. On 3 January 2023,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McCombie and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 1884
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered the case of McCombie and the Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs. The dispute concerned the mandatory cancellation of the applicant's Special Category (temporary) visa due to failing the character test. The applicant sought to have this cancellation revoked, arguing there was another reason to do so.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether there was another reason to revoke the mandatory cancellation decision, having regard to Ministerial Direction No. 99. This involved assessing the applicant's character concerns, the protection of the Australian community, and other relevant considerations outlined in the Direction.

The Tribunal's reasoning focused on a holistic application of Ministerial Direction No. 99. It found that while the applicant's index offending, a conviction for grievous bodily harm, was serious, it was mitigated by several factors. These included the applicant's low recidivist risk, supported by assessments from Queensland Corrective Services and expert evidence from Professor Freeman, who found the applicant to be well-adjusted with no psychopathological symptoms. The Tribunal also considered the applicant's remorse, his strong work ethic, the impact of his offending on his family, and the support he received from them. Furthermore, the applicant's offending history, both in New Zealand and Australia, was found to be dated and relatively minor, with the exception of the index offence. The Tribunal concluded that these factors, when considered together, constituted another reason to revoke the mandatory cancellation decision.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the decision to refuse to revoke the mandatory cancellation and substituted it with a decision to revoke the mandatory cancellation of the applicant's visa.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Applicant’s position stated in his Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions (‘SFIC’): the Applicant’s SFIC canvases the virtual totality of the above-described elements speaking to the Applicant’s recidivist risk. It goes on to relevantly and validly say that the Applicant has been gainfully employed in Australia for 15 years and that his employer would readily re-employ him upon a return to this country. The Applicant’s SFIC notes that:‘…while we accept that the Applicant conduct will be considered as ‘very serious’ under the Direction No. 99, it is mitigated by the fact that the conduct in this case is out of character, and does not represent a pattern of conduct. It relates to a serious lapse of judgement for a few minutes of time in the context of an ongoing neighbourhood dispute. It is clear from the circumstances of this case that the Applicant is of very low risk of re-offending, which means that there is little risk of future harm to the Australian community.’[58][58] A1, p 13, [59].Findings about, and assessment of, recidivist risk I make the following findings about the Applicant’s recidivist risk:·the views and findings of Queensland Corrective Services are significant in terms of assessing this Applicant’s level of recidivist risk. Those prison authorities are charged with the significant responsibility of maintaining peace and good order in the often volatile atmosphere of a custodial institution. Those authorities do not lightly make assessments about a prisoner’s recidivist risk level, especially in circumstances where they are contemplating moving an Applicant from one custodial facility to another. Their assessment of the Applicant as representing a low recidivist risk is both current and contemporaneous with this matter. It is compelling evidence of his recidivist risk and should be accepted by this Tribunal;·the evidence of Professor Freeman is expert and otherwise unchallenged. True it may be that he was not produced for cross-examination, but so clear and strong are his findings that it is difficulty to comprehend what, if any, inroads could have been made into his findings during cross-examination. His report leaves the reader in no doubt that the Applicant is a well-adjusted individual with absolutely no psychopathological symptoms or pre-dispositions that could now raise any discernible element of recidivist risk. Professor Freeman’s findings about the Applicant’s level of insight into both the origins of the index offending and its primary (on the victim) effect as well as its secondary (on the Applicant’s family) effect is clinically sound and incapable of challenge. Professor Freeman’s finding of a low recidivist risk is likewise clinically sound, beyond challenge and worthy of acceptance by this Tribunal;·the Applicant’s own written evidence is demonstrative of a person who has been assessed to have clear and obviously high levels of remorse and regret for his index offending. It would be unsafe to doubt the Applicant’s evidence when he talks about ‘I believe the chances of me re-offending are zero. It is a path I will never follow again.’ The Applicant’s oral evidence given in cross-examination completely dispelled any suggestion of past or present pre-dispositions towards an abuse of alcohol and/or cannabis or any of other illicit substance;·well over a year before Professor Freeman reached his views, Judge Cash made the same findings about (1) the Applicant’s strong work ethic; (2) the obvious and significant levels of his remorse and regret; (3) the impact of his index offending on both the victim and the Applicant’s own family; (4) the extent to which the Applicant is held in high regard by his peers; and (5) the extent of the support he has derived, and continues to derive, from his family.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Applicant’s oral evidence: while not strictly speaking evidence of the Applicant himself, the Applicant’s representative did, in my respectful opinion, correctly describe the Applicant’s recidivist risk profile. In particular, she correctly noted the absence of any substance abuse history or any other psychological or psychiatric conditions that may have previously predisposed him to offending. The oral submission of the Applicant’s representative was put thus:‘It’s abundantly clear that there is a very low risk of recidivism in this case. That’s confirmed by the psychological report of Dr James Freeman. Dr Freeman notes that the applicant accepts responsibility. He demonstrates remorse and guilt. He notes that the applicant doesn’t have a history of drug or alcohol abuse and has no history of psychological or psychiatric conditions that might predispose him to reoffending. I have noted that the respondent’s SFIC mentions that he hasn’t undergone any treatment in relation to alcohol. That’s not in question here. That has not contributed to the offending in this case and that is clear from the sentencing remarks where that is mentioned. Dr Freeman described the applicant as a prosocial individual who’s expressed clear remorse. He has no risk factors.’[34][34] Transcript, p 6, lines 4-14. During cross-examination, the Applicant was questioned about the level of his alcohol use. To whatever extent this line of questioning may have sought to establish some kind of pre-disposition towards over-consumption of alcohol and that such over-consumption was somehow causative of his past offending conduct (especially his index offending) that line of questioning went nowhere. A similar finding can be made about questions put to the Applicant regarding his past use of cannabis. This is how the question/answer sequence transpired between the Respondent’s representative and the Applicant:‘MS TATTERSALL: And your evidence was that you weren’t drinking at the time of that offence, is that right?THE APPLICANT: That’s correct.MS TATTERSALL: So earlier you said you drank approximately every fortnight, is that right?THE APPLICANT: Yes.MS TATTERSALL: So would you have a drink after work, or is that on weekends, or when usually do you drink?THE APPLICANT: Normally on a weekend.MS TATTERSALL: And when you drink on a weekend, how much would you usually drink?THE APPLICANT: I don’t know, probably over a four hour of [sic] period for a game of footy, probably have about six to eight beers.MS TATTERSALL: And is it beers that you’d usually drink, or you drink some various things?THE APPLICANT: No, I only drink beer.MS TATTERSALL: And previously in your evidence-in-chief, I understand you said that you’d never had a problem with alcohol?THE APPLICANT: That’s correct.MS TATTERSALL: But you were assessed in prison as having substance abuse as one of your rehabilitation needs?THE APPLICANT: I was unaware of that.MS TATTERSALL: If you could show on the screen, please, exhibit G1, page 38. And if you could just expand the third paragraph at the top of that page commencing, “I considered the rehabilitation needs”. So, Mr McCombie, you can see on the screen there, that’s a printout from a Queensland Corrective Services report. And I’ll just give you a moment to read that?THE APPLICANT: Yes, I’ve read thatMS TATTERSALL: So that seems to say that although you denied any problematic substance use, that substance abuse was considered to be a need for you?THE APPLICANT: Well, that could have been based on my earlier childhood minor convictions with the cannabis and found on an unlicensed area.MS TATTERSALL: So, as I understand it, you accept that you’ve used cannabis before?THE APPLICANT: I tried it, yes, when I was a minor.MS TATTERSALL: So do I take that to mean that you’ve only tried it on a few occasions, or how many occasions have you tried it on?THE APPLICANT: Yes, probably only a couple of occasions.MS TATTERSALL: And in one of your statements, you refer to experimenting with cannabis but learning your lesson after you got in trouble for it. Can you let me know what you mean by learning your lesson there?THE APPLICANT: Well, I got caught with a cannabis cigarette, so I didn’t touch that again since.MS TATTERSALL: So was the cannabis cigarette that you were caught with yours?THE APPLICANT: Yes’[35][35] Transcript, p 35, lines 19-45; p 36, lines 1-18.

Decision

Reasons for decision

A holistic application of the considerations in the Direction therefore militates in favour of this Tribunal finding that there is another reason to revoke the mandatory cancellation decision of 21 July 2021.DECISION Pursuant to section 43 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), the Tribunal sets aside the decision made by the delegate of the Respondent dated 3 January 2023 and substitutes it with a decision to revoke the mandatory cancellation of the Applicant’s visa.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Paragraph 9 of the Direction sets out four Other Considerations which must be taken into account. These considerations are:(a)legal consequence of the decision;(b)extent of impediments if removed;(c)impact on victims; and(d)impact on Australian business interests.PRIMARY CONSIDERATION 1: PROTECTION OF THE AUSTRALIAN COMMUNITY In considering this Primary Consideration 1, paragraph 8.1(1) of the Direction compels decision-makers to keep in mind the Government is committed to protecting the Australian community from harm as a result of criminal activity or other serious conduct by non-citizens. Decision-makers should have particular regard to the principle that entering or remaining in Australia is a privilege that this country confers on non-citizens in the expectation that they are, and have been, law abiding, that they will respect important institutions and that they will not cause or threaten harm to individuals or the Australian community. I make specific reference to Principle 5.2(3) of the Direction which contains the following words: ‘The Australian community expects that the Australian Government can and should refuse entry to non-citizens, or cancel their visas, if they engaged in conduct, in Australia or elsewhere, that raises serious character concerns.’[12] I will therefore look at the Applicant’s offending both in Australia and anywhere else. As best as I have understood the material, apart from Australia, the only other country where the Applicant has an offending history is New Zealand where his offending is recorded thus:[12] Paragraph 5.2(3) of the Direction. His offending history in Australia is of similar brevity to that of New Zealand. In Australia he has committed the following offences: I carefully searched the material and located the following very brief and mostly insignificant traffic history: Stated in summary then, the Applicant’s offending history in New Zealand is 25-27 years old. It involved the commission of three relatively unremarkable offences and was punished by a cumulative total of fines in the sum of $375. He has committed four offences in Australia. Three of them were committed some 12-13 years ago and involve convictions for three relatively unremarkable offences involving petulance towards, and disregard of, directions given to him by police officers lawfully authorised to do so. Those three offences were punished by a cumulative total fines amounting to $1300. His index offence[13] is clearly his conviction on one count of Grievous bodily harm pursuant to s 320 of the Criminal Code Act 1899 (Qld). The Applicant was sentenced to a head custodial term of imprisonment for four years to be suspended after he served a period in actual custody of 16 months. The operative period of the suspension was ordered to be four years. [13] That is, the offending for which he was sentenced by Judge Dearden in June 2021. The sentencing remarks of the learned sentencing judicial officer, His Honour Judge Cash DCJ KC, appear in the material.[14] His Honour noted the Applicant entered his own plea of guilty to this index offence and that this plea was an early plea entered upon presentation of the indictment.[15] His Honour then recounted the material facts of the offending in these terms:‘What you did is summarised in exhibit 2 the statement of facts. You lived next door to the complainant, who was a 54 year old man, who you did not really know beyond him just being your neighbour. On the evening of the offence, which was the 27th and the 28th of March last year, he had been on his patio with some others, drinking and listening to music. Obviously, that was loud. By 1 am, you went next door to tell them that they were being too noisy.The complainant, instead of responding like a decent person might, acted belligerently and told you to go and call the police. Regrettably, for him, for you, and for your family, your response, though, was inexcusable, and constitutes the offending behaviour. First, you grabbed him and threw him to the ground, whereupon you punched him several times in the ribs. There were brief stops over the next couple of minutes, but in the next few minutes, or perhaps two, you retuned and kicked and punched him, and that included stomping on his chest. The violence, as I have mentioned, spanned perhaps a couple of minutes. You did stop. The police attended. The complainant, who I am guessing must have been substantially affected by alcohol, did not want medical treatment, but the next morning he collapsed and it turned out his spleen had been lacerated by the blows.’[16][14] G1, pp 28-30.[15] G1, p 29, lines 1-7.[16] Ibid, lines 7-24.