McClintock v Commissioner of Police

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

McClintock v Commissioner of Police [2020] QDC 147

PARTIES:

Marc Christian McClintock

(Appellant)

v

Commissioner of Police

(Respondent)

FILE NO:

306 of 2020

DIVISION:

Appellate   

PROCEEDING:

Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:

Magistrates Court at Maroochydore

DELIVERED ON:

12 June 2020

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

15 June 2020

JUDGE:

Reid DCJ

ORDER:

1.   Appeal allowed.

2.   The head sentence for each of the fraud offences be reduced to 12 months imprisonment, to be served concurrently with one another but cumulative on those sentences imposed on the 16th of November 2018.

3.   Set a parole eligibility date of the 15th of June 2020.

4.   Appellant to report.

CATCHWORDS:

MAGISTRATES - APPEAL AND REVIEW- appeal brought pursuant to s 222 of the Justices Act 1886 (Qld) - where appellant appeals against the sentence imposed by the learned Magistrates – where the appellant was sentenced to 28 months imprisonment for each of two counts of fraud and a parole eligibility of 8th September 2020 was set – where this sentence was made cumulative on an earlier sentence of two and a half years imprisonment made on the 16th November 2018 – where the appellant spent from 21st of December 2018 up to his sentence in imprisonment - where the defendant has a personality disorder involving antisocial elements and a number of other mental health issues and intellectual impairments – whether the learned Magistrate placed sufficient weight into these issues when sentencing the appellant -  whether the appeal should be allowed

Justices Act 1886 (Qld) s 222

R v Guode [2020] HCA 8
R v Macklin [2016] QCA 244
R v Verdins (2007) 16 VR 269
R v Yarwood [2011] QCA 367

COUNSEL:

J. Feely for Appellant 

T. Little for Respondent 

SOLICITORS:

A W Bale & Son Solicitors for the Appellant  
The Office of Director of Public Prosecutions for Respondent 

Introduction

  1. The appellant appeals against the sentence imposed by the Magistrates Court at Maroochydore on the 31st of October 2019.  An appeal against his conviction was discontinued.  He was sentenced to 28 months imprisonment for each of the two charges of fraud.  A parole eligibility date of the 8th of September 2020, some 10 months, eight days after sentence, was set.  That sentence was made cumulative on an earlier sentence of two and a half years imprisonment imposed on the 16th of November 2018, for each of three fraud offences.  Two hundred and forty-nine days of pre-sentence custody was at that time declared as time served, and an immediate parole release date was set.

    Background

  2. Consequently, the appellant was released on the 16th of November 2018.  He committed the subject offences between the 27th of November and the 21st of December 2018, so within about five weeks of his release. 

  3. The overall effect of his sentences, including the pre-sentence custody up to the time of his sentence for the subject offence, was thus:

    (i)pre-sentence custody of 249 days, a little…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McClintock v Commissioner of Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QDC 147
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of McClintock v Commissioner of Police, the appellant contested the sentence imposed by the Magistrates Court at Maroochydore. The appellant was sentenced to 28 months imprisonment for each of two counts of fraud, with a parole eligibility date set for the 8th of September 2020. This sentence was cumulative on an earlier sentence of two and a half years imprisonment for three fraud offences. The appellant argued that the Magistrates did not adequately consider his personality disorder involving antisocial elements and other mental health issues and intellectual impairments when sentencing him. The appellant's appeal raised two key legal issues: whether the Magistrates adequately weighed the appellant's mental health issues and personality disorder in sentencing him, and whether the appeal should be allowed based on these considerations.

The court examined the evidence presented regarding the appellant's mental health issues and personality disorder, as well as the proportionality of the sentence imposed. The court found that the Magistrates did not adequately consider the appellant's mental health issues and personality disorder when imposing the sentence. Furthermore, the court found that the sentence was manifestly excessive and not proportionate to the appellant's offending. The court accepted the submission of counsel for the appellant that an appropriate sentence in this case would be one of 12 months imprisonment on each offence, to be served concurrently with one another but cumulative on the sentences imposed on the 16th of November 2018. The court allowed the appeal and reduced the head sentence for each of the fraud offences to 12 months imprisonment, to be served concurrently with one another but cumulative on those sentences imposed on the 16th of November 2018. The court also set an immediate parole eligibility date of the 15th of June 2020 and ordered that the appellant report to a Probation & Parole office within 48 hours of his release from prison.

The final orders of the court were: 1. The appeal was allowed. 2. The head sentence for each of the fraud offences was reduced to 12 months imprisonment, to be served concurrently with one another but cumulative on those sentences imposed on the 16th of November 2018. 3. A parole eligibility date was set for the 15th of June 2020. 4. The appellant was ordered to report to a Probation & Parole office within 48 hours of his release from prison.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed.

2. The head sentence for each of the fraud offences be reduced to 12 months imprisonment, to be served concurrently with one another but cumulative on those sentences imposed on the 16th of November 2018.

3. Set a parole eligibility date of the 15th of June 2020.

4. Appellant to report.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellant appeals against the sentence imposed by the Magistrates Court at Maroochydore on the 31st of October 2019. An appeal against his conviction was discontinued. He was sentenced to 28 months imprisonment for each of the two charges of fraud. A parole eligibility date of the 8th of September 2020, some 10 months, eight days after sentence, was set. That sentence was made cumulative on an earlier sentence of two and a half years imprisonment imposed on the 16th of November 2018, for each of three fraud offences. Two hundred and forty-nine days of pre-sentence custody was at that time declared as time served, and an immediate parole release date was set.Background Consequently, the appellant was released on the 16th of November 2018. He committed the subject offences between the 27th of November and the 21st of December 2018, so within about five weeks of his release. The overall effect of his sentences, including the pre-sentence custody up to the time of his sentence for the subject offence, was thus: (i)pre-sentence custody of 249 days, a little over eight months, from about the 10th of March 2018 to the 16th of November 2018; (ii)he was in the community for a period of about five weeks from the 16th of November to the 21st of December 2018; and(iii)he was returned to custody when parole was cancelled from the 21st of December 2018 to the 31st of October 2019, a period of a little over 10 months. Thus, from the 10th of March 2018 the appellant was in custody up to the day of sentence on the 31st of October 2019, except for that five-week period when he was in the community, a total period of about 19 months. The effect of his Honour's sentence that is the subject of the appeal was that he would not be eligible for parole until the 8th of September 2020. Consequently, he would have been in prison for all but five weeks of the period from the 10th of March 2018 to the 8th of September 2020, i.e. is a period of about two years, four and a half months in actual imprisonment. Furthermore, the full-time discharge date of his October 2019 sentence would be the 22nd of January 2023, almost five years after his incarceration in May 2018. Of that four years, 10 and a half months, he will have served at least two years, four and a half months, plus, of course, any time that he might serve after the 8th of September awaiting parole. What has the defendant done to deserve such treatment? The first point to note is that there has been no actual violence in respect of any of his offences. The offending in March 2018 involved three fraud offences. It involved him defrauding a motor vehicle sales outlet in the amount of $50,000. The two other offences involved him engaging escorts and fraudulently evading paying them a significant pre-arranged fee. He was, as I have said, sentenced to a head sentence of two and a half years in relation to those three matters. This sentence was given in circumstances where, in August 2015, he had committed four fraud offences and one attempted fraud. Those offences involved a fraud of $18,360 of a commercial retail outlet. The balance, I understand, involved similar fraudulent activity in relation to escort services. He had on that occasion been sentenced to two years imprisonment with parole release after a bit more than six months, being four months plus 72 days of pre-sentence custody.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Quite apart from those identifiable errors, in my view, the sentence imposed was, in any case, manifestly excessive.Conclusion I accept the submission of counsel for the appellant that an appropriate sentence in this case is one of 12 months imprisonment on each offence, to be served concurrently on one another but cumulative on the sentence imposed on the 16th of November 2018. I will set an immediate parole eligibility date. I therefore allow the appeal in relation to sentence: 1. By varying the sentence imposed so that the head sentence for each of the fraud offences be reduced to 12 months imprisonment to be served concurrently to one another but cumulative on those sentences imposed on the 16th of November 2018; and 2. I set a parole eligibility date of the 15th of June 2020. i.e. immediate parole release. I also order that the appellant report to a Probation & Parole office within 48 hours of his release from prison.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established