McCarthy v Queensland Building and Construction Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:

PARTIES:

McCarthy v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2021] QIRC 266

McCarthy, Jamie Louise
(Appellant)

v

Queensland Building and Construction Commission
(Respondent)

CASE NO:

PSA/2021/62

PROCEEDING:

Public Service Appeal – Temporary Employment

DELIVERED ON:

2 August 2021

MEMBER:

HEARD AT:

McLennan IC

On the papers

  ORDERS:

That pursuant to s 562C(1)(c) of the Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld):

1.   The appeal is allowed;

2.   The decision that Miss McCarthy not have her temporary employment converted to permanent employment is set aside and another decision is substituted; and

3.   Miss McCarthy's temporary employment status be converted to permanent employment.

CATCHWORDS:

LEGISLATION AND OTHER INSTRUMENTS:

CASES:

PUBLIC SERVICE – APPEAL – temporary employment – where the appellant was reviewed under s 149B of the Public Service Act 2008 –whether the deemed decision was fair and reasonable – whether vacant and funded position required for conversion – whether appellant required 'on a frequent or regular basis' – consideration of continuing need – consideration of genuine operational requirements

Acts Interpretation Act 1954 (Qld) s 14A, sch 1

Directive 09/20 Fixed term temporary employment cl 1, cl 4, cl 8, cl 11

Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld) s 562B,
s 562C, s 564

Public Service Act 2008 (Qld) s 27, s 148, s 149,
s 149A, s 149B, s 194, s 196, s 294

Statutory Instruments Act 1992 (Qld) s 7, s 14

Goodall v State of Queensland (Supreme Court of Queensland, Dalton J, 10 October 2018)

Katae v State of Queensland & Anor [2018] QSC 225

Page v John Thompson and Lesley Dwyer, As Chief Executive Officer, West Moreton Hospital and Health Service [2014] QSC 252

Reasons for Decision

Introduction

  1. Miss Jamie McCarthy (the Appellant) has filed an appeal against a deemed decision by the Queensland Building and Construction Commission (QBCC; the Respondent).

  2. Miss McCarthy is currently employed as a temporary AO4 Assessment Officer in the Dispute Resolution Branch of the QBCC.

  3. Miss McCarthy has been employed by the QBCC as a temporary employee since 16 December 2014 - her employment history is summarised below:

    ·AO2 Records Officer in the Records Unit of the QBCC from 16 December 2014 until around 2 August 2015;

    ·AO3 Customer Support Officer in the Resolution Services Unit from 3 August 2015 until around 10 January 2016; and

·AO4 Assessment Officer in various positions from 11 January 2016, as stipulated below:

-        Position number 1687 (145 days);

-        Position number 1412 (760 days);

-        Position number 1357 (394 days); and

-        Position number 1984 (from 1 January 2021).

  1. The period in which Miss McCarthy undertook the AO4 duties was also interspersed with short periods of higher duties at the AO5 and AO6 levels.

  2. Miss McCarthy's current temporary engagement is expected to conclude on 8 November 2021.

    The Decision

  3. Section 149B(4) of the PS Act provides:

    (4)     The department’s chief executive must make the decision within the required period after—

    (a)the end of 2 years after the employee has been continuously employed as a fixed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McCarthy v Queensland Building and Construction Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QIRC 266
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of McCarthy v Queensland Building and Construction Commission, Miss McCarthy sought to appeal a deemed decision by the QBCC not to convert her employment status from temporary to permanent, as provided for under section 149B of the Public Service Act 2008 (Qld). The appeal was lodged within the required period under section 564(3) of the Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld), and was therefore valid. The key legal issue was whether the decision was fair and reasonable, and whether the relevant criteria for conversion had been met.

The court examined the criteria for conversion under section 149B of the PS Act, which include the requirement for a vacant and funded position, and consideration of the continuing need and genuine operational requirements of the position. The court found that the QBCC had failed to properly consider the evidence in relation to these criteria, and had not provided sufficient reasons for its decision. The court also found that the QBCC had not properly considered the evidence in relation to Miss McCarthy's ongoing need and genuine operational requirements. On this basis, the court found that the decision was not fair and reasonable, and allowed the appeal.

The court's decision sets aside the QBCC's decision not to convert Miss McCarthy's employment status to permanent, and substitutes a decision to convert her employment status. The court also orders that Miss McCarthy's temporary employment status be converted to permanent employment. This decision provides important guidance on the proper application of the criteria for conversion under the PS Act, and the need for proper consideration of evidence and reasons in decision-making.

Orders

Orders of the court

That pursuant to s 562C(1)(c) of the Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld):

1. The appeal is allowed;

2. The decision that Miss McCarthy not have her temporary employment converted to permanent employment is set aside and another decision is substituted; and

3. Miss McCarthy's temporary employment status be converted to permanent employment.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Miss McCarthy's current temporary engagement is expected to conclude on 8 November 2021. The Decision Section 149B(4) of the PS Act provides: (4) The department’s chief executive must make the decision within the required period after—(a)the end of 2 years after the employee has been continuously employed as a fixed term temporary employee or casual employee in the department; and(b)each 1-year period after the end of the period mentioned in paragraph (a) during which the employee is continuously employed as a fixed term temporary employee or casual employee in the department. The 'required period' is defined at s 149B(9) as being: Miss McCarthy became eligible for review on 16 December 2020, being the six-year anniversary of her commencement with QBCC as a fixed term temporary employee.[1] Therefore, the required period within which the QBCC ought to have made a decision ended 28 days later on 13 January 2021. [1] Public Service Act 2008 (Qld) s 149B(4)(b). Section 564(3) of the Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld) (IR Act) requires that an appeal be lodged within 21 days after the day the decision appealed against is given. The deemed decision was given on 13 January 2021 and the Appeal Notice was filed 21 days later on 3 February 2021. On that basis, I am satisfied Miss McCarthy has lodged her Appeal Notice on time. The decision subject of this appeal is the Respondent's deemed decision not to convert Miss McCarthy's employment status from temporary to permanent. Clause 11.1 of the Directive 09/20 Fixed term temporary employment (Directive 09/20) provides that "A fixed term temporary employee eligible for review under section 149B has a right of appeal provided for in section 194(1)(e) of the PS Act in relation to a decision not to convert." Section 194(1)(e)(i) of the PS Act provides that an appeal may be made against "a decision (each a conversion decision) – under section 149B not to convert the basis of employment of an employee". This is the 'type of decision' Miss McCarthy indicated was being appealed against in the Appeal Notice. Section 196(e) of the PS Act prescribes that "the employee the subject of the decision" may appeal "for a conversion decision". For the reasons outlined above, I am satisfied the deemed decision was made under s 149B of the PS Act and is able to be appealed. Section 562B(2)-(3) of the IR Act provides that the appeal is decided by reviewing the decision appealed against to determine whether it "was fair and reasonable". The appeal is not conducted by way of re-hearing,[2] but rather involves a review of the decision arrived at by the Respondent and the associated decision-making process.[3] [2] Goodall v State of Queensland (Supreme Court of Queensland, Dalton J, 10 October 2018), 5.[3] Ibid. Findings made by the Respondent, which are reasonably open to it, should not be disturbed on appeal. Even so, in reviewing the decision appealed against, the QIRC member may allow other evidence to be taken into account.[4][4] Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld) s 562B(4)(b).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.